Search results

I was about to put this in a 2e thread, but since mayfair games was 3rd party I guess 3e fits more. I like prestige classes, things you grow into. Archmage, Master of 9, Lore master.

Of cource not, but it is easy enough to see people being against some races being presented as rare, but still in the world. I know when I see rare dragonborn, My first thought is "Well if I am the only one in this city, isn't that still rare" I am not sure that anything is a no-brainer...

I am totally a 2e girl. I love almost everything about it. I will totally agree with not thac0, and I understand that saves will be different. I really want to go back to weapon specialization, and system shock. I also want to see spells with draw backs (hast ages you a year, and res cost a con...

I would say Wizard 1-10 with them getting spell levels on every odd level (so at level 19 get level 10 spells) I would want Clerics to get level 1-7 getting them every 3 levels, so 1st, 3rd, 6th, 9th, 12th, 15th,and 18th Give them almost no class features (I said almost not none) then you can...

What if Fireball at 3rd level did 5d6, at 4th level did 7d6, and at 5th level did 10d6. would that be enough? or would you have to have a 6th and 7th level ones?

I like to see something closer to 2e, with a bit of 4e thrown in. I like the idea of the way 4e did utility powers, and I would make them all work that way. Lets say at level 5 I have 1 3rd level spell, 2 second level spells, and 4 first level spells per day. Lets say I have in my spell...

I got the Priest and Specialty Priests, Ok so all Divine spells/prayers are broken up into spheres. There is an all sphere that everyone gets (bless, prayer and miricle are in it) Each sphere has 3-5 spells per spell level. Depending on what god you worship you get access to 5 spheres+ the all...

I said this before (and I have to modfy it becuse I was proven to be a bit wrong) When did my fighter stop being a fighter? Ok so in the roles thread there is talk about there always being roles in D&D, and I won’t argue whether or not that is true, but let’s say that is true. I remember...

Over in the Giants in the Playground fourm another playtester is answering quastions about his playtest... Giant in the Playground Forums - View Single Post - Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition - Thread #2

I want the perfect mix. I want wizards with atwill cantrips (maybe include magic missile and ray of frost like offensives) and then vancian daily for everything else. I then want to see Sorcerers with Encounter powers and daily mana like powers. I then want to see warlocks with LOTS of at wills...

I could go for less bonus, but still bonus. Maybe instead of +1/2 level it is +1/5 level for everything. Then a level 30 pc is +6 higher from level to hit and def then a level 1 PC. Give both PCs and monsters less hp, and I could get behind this. If done right, you could bake into the higher...

Ok I do not remember New coke to be honnest, but I was told it was a good drink that did not catch on. no matter what side you come down on, would'nt that be a great next chapter in D&D history.

I could not say it better. 4e IS new coke, it isn’t bad, but it failed because it just isn’t the original. Going to far from basic is a problem. I think we really need to go back to AD&D (1st and 2nd e) for a lot of 5e.

Now that is a good point. I know in the warlord thread one of the people brought up an eladrin warlord who took the spiral tower Paragon path. Even at that point I would say that the PP in question is steeped in a magical school that you trained at, and as such is you beginning to become...

A lot of warlord powers come off very magical to me. Commander strike is great, and I can picture a faint giving an ally an opening, but at some levels they give free charge attacks out of turn, sometimes they give multi players attacks against multi enemies. They heal, they from a distance make...

Magic or Mundane? Well in the fighter and the warlord threads I have been accused of being ‘against’ the martial classes. If I did not know any better I would say it is a kin to a down trodden minority in a racist society. I don’t want to sound pushy or come off like I am championing the...

Well I would not go that far, I would prefer if they wanted a tactical guy that they give the fighter a few warlord like tricks (wolf pack tactics would make a great fighter trick). Just no magical effects.

Good point, I guess I was looking for “make 2 basic attack” powers, and missed them. I also associate cleave with the feat from 3e, and had forgotten it in 4e. Well I feel my point stands there can be more, I will admit you opened my eyes to some that I would not have seen otherwise. Thank you...

Yea it is so great that 2 men can laugh at the woman wanting equal treatment (the male dragon born look male to the untrained eye). By the way how am I supposed to tell who is male and who is female in those pics (not withstanding you telling me) If non human males had curves like a woman, and...

You even admit that Aragorn was as much a fighter. I bet in any edition I can make a ranger or a fighter and get pretty close to him in LotR. King Arthur, wow are you stretching here. He was a Fighter through and through, maybe a paladin. Batman and Captain America, both can be made without...