Search results

I really like the idea of having an Advanced Dungeons and Dragons book as a supplement to 5E. Why not dig out an old title and give it a new purpose?

Mine arrived from Amazon yesterday. Definitely looks nice and will come in handy as I have a big nautical campaign.

I backed for the hardcover, but man would I love these ten times more if they were able to be used on dndbeyond... but there’s no class creation...

Man, I miss the 2E days of opening a box and taking out books, monster pages, and HUGE COLORFUL MAPS with numbered areas... Dragon Mountain...

While that’s true, having stats for all of the various Stargate baddies would make it easier... (Wraith, Ori, etc) and not just Gou’ald and Jaffa and Asgard. Thanks!

While that’s true, having stats for all of the various Stargate baddies would make it easier... (Wraith, Ori, etc) and not just Gou’ald and Jaffa and Asgard. Thanks!

Will all of the canon from Atlantis and Universe be used as well? The Goa’uld system lords were defeated... I just hope other eras and locales of the shows will be available.

Will all of the canon from Atlantis and Universe be used as well? The Goa’uld system lords were defeated... I just hope other eras and locales of the shows will be available.

I'm guessing you don't like Spelljammer or Planescape, then?

I'd love an adventure path that jumps from world to world dealing with something like this... Start off in the Realms, next adventure takes the characters to Eberron, then the third is Dark Sun, then Mystara, with it finally ending with Greyhawk. Use Planescape and Spelljammer as in-between...

Speaking as someone who never played 1E (went from BECMI to 2E), I personally loved 2E. I did have the 1E DMG before I had the 2E one, so I used the magic items from that, but I loved the flavor of 2E. However, I definitely understand how they hung themselves with supplement after supplement...

Looking back, I had the most FUN playing 2E. I started with BECMI, had a couple 1E books before 2E came out and we graduated to that. Played for 10 years. Definitely had lots of fun adventures in various settings. 3E was all well and good and was very modular and easily customized, but it just...

Good for those that want it. I’ll get it on deep discount someday just to stay complete and I’ll get the races and classes from dndbeyond. I’m sure I can harvest bits for my homebrew. I already integrated an origin for the Warforged in my world..

I would hate to see Spelljammer and Planescape combined. On paper, it makes sense, but the settings have vastly different “personalities” to them. I’d hate to see either of them compromised for the other.

I flipped back and forth between voting 2E and 3E and chose 2E because, while overly complicated at times, we had the most FUN playing 2E... 3E was great for customizing characters and flexibility, but all of the balance added took away some of the crazy fun we had with 2E. And the...

Will the 5E book contain the NPC stats in addition to the monsters? Also what about all of the 5E skill check DC’s and trap conversions? If someone wanted this JUST for 5E, will it all be there somewhere?

What do I WANT? Spelljammer. But it ain’t gonna happen. Followed by Dark Sun. Again, not likely. Planescape is certainly possible given the new adventure, but... I think it’ll just be another Forgotten Realms thing. Hope I’m wrong!

Over the top, unbalanced spells.... Yes, they were broken, but they were more FUN. I'd love to see an unbalanced 5E fused with 2E craziness... and 3E's ability to make anything a PC race.

Hey, I really like that idea. I’d be all in!

Player can control them until they prove unable to control them fairly.