Search results

Post some arguments why they don't "must-have" feats? Even in 90% roleplay 10% combat game, when you have the only fight in that night, and the enemy rolls an attack, and hits you on 2 die, and you are dominated/stunned and can't do nothing, it's not fun! Even if you can deeply describe what...

@Stalker0 and what you think about the math? You think it's broken? I saw you made some very nice mathematic calculations about skill checks and Skill challanges. I will be realy happy if you say something about this issue. @keterys I agree about Orcus, but this was an example of another user...

@James McMurray I don't forbid you to post, just to make it on topic. Anyway I don't replie on most of you text, couse it will make discussion stay not on topic. Btw Orcus was an example of another person, and I just pointed him, that his recharge power is deadly. The same wiht epic destinies...

I'm lookin at them now. Well, some extra save, spend healing surge... Anyway we going off topic. That don't change anything. Just minor add-ons. The problem is not when you go to 0 HP, but with hitting monsters and monsters hitting DEFs. Barley? Without the Leader the game will crush PCs. Have...

Ok they are dying. That means if you were have 200+ HPs you have no 0 and you laying unconcious on the ground. For the comment to second part of post... :) Yeah, there are some options like Deva have, that with feat gives him +2 to dmg and attack until the end of encounter, but... ;) I was...

@KarinsDad +1 That's one of the factor I didn't mentioned before. I will just add that when monster have easier time hitting you NADs and place effects on PCs, the game become much longer, couse that just hinder PCs more, not make the game more challanging. In fact, it makes game more boring.

No you analysis is flawed. Roleplay don't have ANY impact on game math! Well maybe giving +2/-2 for nice description and that's in core rules. You still missing the point. RP is nice thing. You made wrong assumptions that I'm hack and slash player. Man. Even if I will be that doesn't...

Any proof here? It's obvious that some monsters don't have the stats equal to what DMG propose. They are diffrent couse some have better FOR and weaker Will or just flaw designed etc. What DMG gives are just average stats and all monster fall into this. If you don't belive just take random...

No it isn't! Look above examples.

:) It's not in a vacum, it's an attack roll versus your PC NAD that will autohit you and make you stunned/dominated and you can't do nothing now. Wy on earth you take powers that hit AC! We don't talk about that. We talking about the NADs and attack versus them and attack rolls of players vs...

@AbdulAlhazred Skill feat is just only pseudo-roleplay feat option in game. Linguist may be better and that's it. We don't talk about skill use couse it will need another thread when we can discuss about it's broken ST ie. Skill Challange. Stop making an examples of roleplaying combat...

@AbdulAlhazred You still talking about diffrent thing that I'am. Roleplaying isn't topic here. We talking about facts. The fact that wizrds gives us overpowered feats that fix the math, and the fact that was bad idee. Thus I give my proposition how to fix that issue, by giving this feats for...

High? Making the NADs hittable at 50% when you spend all this feats is for you a choice? I will say. LOL! If this feats will give you choice to make them better than average I could agree with you, but... If you don't take this feats your character will be too easy target for monsters. Hitting...

So? One paragon path and now the warden and that's it. Are you saying that fact that this option egzist, autihiting one of you NADs with monster attack is ok? Even Dreadnought can't take damage to get the off dominated/stunned effect, so popular at epic level, where the problem is very huge...

14+lv 12+lvl 5+lvl 3+lvl AC DEF vs.AC vs.DEF This are skirmiher stats taken from DMG (chapter about creating monsters).

Elric all what you ares saying is true. The completly math crunch was in first post and here's the link again: http://www.enworld.org/forum/4735419-post1.html Your optin how to fix it is ok, and was almost the same as mine. But. I considered that, giving feats for free is much simpler than tha...

I think that this is even greater problem than Expertise. Let's see how this look: http://www.enworld.org/forum/4735419-post1.html So we can see that our NADs are terribly designed. When PHB2 comes out we see some fixes to this problem. Paragon Defenses gives +1 to all NADs (it's feat bonus)...

Well if someone is interested hows the math works on higher levels here is complete crunch: http://www.enworld.org/forum/4735419-post1.html At late paragon player must roll 12 to hit monster, at epic it's 13 now. And we talking about the skirmisher whose level is the same as player. That's no...

Well I think that the fair solution will be also (as addition to previev solution) to give just players for free one Epic defense feat (Epic Wiil/Reflex/Fortitude). That will make your lowest DEF at +4 (of monster adventage) - he must roll 6 on die to hit. This also will give options to players...

Well with 14 on stat you have FORT34. Monster has adventage of +9. With my house rule it drops to +7. When he take paragon feat it makes it +5, and with epic feat it gives +1. I can say not bad. Only 2 feats needed now. The middle DEF will need only one feat to make monster adventage to +0 and...