Search results

  1. T

    Why do drow have black skin?

    Wikipedia has a bunch of stuff. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dökkálfar_and_Ljósálfar Note that "dark elves" originally was synonymous with "dwarves"... ;)
  2. T

    D&D 5E Evil characters material not going to be in the PHB

    My guess is that it isn't about page count or complexity, but rather a Hasbro boss somewhere concerned about Concerned Parents.
  3. T

    Anyone tried no offensive spellcasting?

    We used the Dragonstar Science-Fiction setting for D&D 3E in a campaign that was in part influenced by the Marines of the movie Aliens. The idea was that each player should have a stable of characters, from which we handpicked one each for any given mission. Predictable enough, most players...
  4. T

    ZEITGEIST Suggestions for things to improve, fix, or add for the ZEITGEIST Act One compilation?

    Yep, that auto-substitution 4E Eladrin -> Elf really confused me when I read the Pathfinder version of the players guide, especially as the 4E elves kept being elves..... "The elven females died, so elven females was kidnapped and sold to be polymorphed into elven females... HUH?"
  5. T

    D&D 5E Q&A 10/17/13 - Crits, Damage on Miss, Wildshape

    "I swing at him with my sword!" "But he's fifty feet away! You could not possibly hit him!" "No worries, I do damage even on a miss..." :D
  6. T

    Pathfinder 1E Do Traps (almost always) Surprise?

    Well, you could use it as a kind of Turing test... As Baldor the Brave crosses square X, a crossbow dart shoots out of a tiny hole in the wall. Was it a trap, or an orc hidden behind a murder hole with a crossbow and a delayed action? We can determine this by simply observing whether Baldor...
  7. T

    Pathfinder 1E Do Traps (almost always) Surprise?

    From http://www.d20pfsrd.com/gamemastering/traps-hazards-and-special-terrains/traps : "Traps that attack with arrows, sweeping blades, and other types of weaponry make normal attack rolls, ... "
  8. T

    Pathfinder 1E What to play?

    Love Pathfinder's Archetype system.
  9. T

    D&D 5E Skills - Does anyone actually like the way they're headed?

    A great difference between combat rolls and skill rolls is that skill rolls often are linked, whenever you make even the simplest plan. Let's pick this simple example, something a skilled rogue would expect to do: "I sneak past the guard, climb up the wall, and then listen at the window."...
  10. T

    What's your favourite version or variation of D&D?

    My favorite for playing D&D-esque adventures is my GM's homebrew: http://hastur.net/wiki/Action, which has very different mechanics, but picks up D&D/Pathfinders adventures, settings and mood real well. That said, Parthfinder has surprised me favorably as a player. There are enough oddities...
  11. T

    D&D 5E Skill Challenges in 5E

    This is spot on the problem with "before Y failures". If a bad shot caused a fight to be lost by shooting four misses in a row, then the party would very soon start shouting "put *down* that crossbow!"...
  12. T

    D&D 5E Sneak Attack: optional or mandatory?

    In my personal opinion, I'd say that "Line'm up an' knock'em down" gets pretty boring after a while. D&D is so much more, and has to be much more. If all you want to do is kill monsters, then Descent is a much better board-game for that, and there are hundreds upon hundreds of computer games...
  13. T

    How Much of D&D is the Rules?

    I play in Starfox home-brew mentioned above. In fact, we play a Pathfinder campaign using the "Skull and Shackles" Paizo AP in parallel with the home-brew campaign, which uses the "Crimson Throne" Paizo AP. Both throw in a lot of other "extra" D&D/Pathfinder scenarios scrounged from Starfox'...
  14. T

    Pathfinder 1E Post here if you're a PATHFINDER RPG fan!

    I would not say that they are few. As a point sample, my unfiltered front page of this forum when writing this is: 11 Pathfinder threads 9 5E threads 6 all edition threads 4 3/3.5 threads 1 1E thread 1 2E thread 1 4E thread 7 others out of 40 threads.
  15. T

    Are we fair to WotC?

    Nailed it in one! :D
  16. T

    Are we fair to WotC?

    Just think of how capricious Microsoft has been with edition names: Windows 3.0, 3.1, 95, 98, ME, XP, Vista, 7, 8... Perhaps the should call the version after "D&D Next" "D&D Try"? (Let's see how many get *that* reference... :D )
  17. T

    3d6 opposed roll probability

    There is a very nice dice probability calculator at http://anydice.com Just put this as two separate lines into the big input field: output 3d6-3d6 output d20-d20 and press first the "Graph" and then the "Calculate" button. This will give you a nice comparison graph of the probabilities of...
  18. T

    D&D 5E D&D Next Q&A: Fields of Lore, Skills and Average Hit Points

    Depends on how willing the DM is to let the players get away with intentionally and repeatedly putting their low roll result characters in harm's way and getting them killed, until they get a "keeper" with a high roll result.... :D :D
  19. T

    Pathfinder 1E I just found a new stupid rule!

    In our "Savage Tide" D&D 3.5 campaign, I had a fairy that liked to tinker with mechanical inventions. The group's ranger wanted a nice rifle, so I crafted one for him. Now, my DM ( Starfox ) house-rules "crits" on skill rolls in the same way as for attacks (reroll for confirm on a natural 20)...
  20. T

    The Sundering has launched...

    High-level cmd-Z? :D
Top