Search results

  1. see

    D&D (2024) Do you plan to adopt D&D5.5One2024Redux?

    Not really. There's a serious conceptual difference between "Every single being in the universe who is Lawful Good speaks the Lawful Good alignment tongue, which they didn't have to learn and which they cease to be able to speak if they change alignment, and the only non-Lawful Good beings who...
  2. see

    D&D General The D&D Cartoon is set in Faerun since when?

    Amazing. I mean, the cartoon was cancelled before TSR bought the Realms.
  3. see

    D&D General Demetrios1453 Plays the Gold Box Games

    Mm-hmm. No wonder you kids these days can't afford a fine longbow for everyone in the party, what with your insistence on staying at inns that serve avocado toast.
  4. see

    D&D General Demetrios1453 Plays the Gold Box Games

    I note that once the slums are cleared, you can safely rest anywhere there. Which means that a real penny-pincher can save a platinum piece each time by ducking through the gateway to the slums before resting, rather than going to an inn.
  5. see

    D&D General Demetrios1453 Plays the Gold Box Games

    You're actually confusing 1e (where elf multiclasses could, in fact, cast spells while wearing any armor) and 2e (where they were initially limited to elven chain, and then later elven plate was added). Pool of Radiance accurately reflects the 1e rule.
  6. see

    D&D General Tell me of "PHB" classes of prior eras!

    There was also using Player's Option: Spells & Magic to add Crusader, Monk, and Shaman classes.
  7. see

    D&D General D&D Survivor: Planar Dragons

    Adamantite Dragon 5 Astral Dragon (Dragon #134) 12 Radiant Dragon 12
  8. see

    D&D General D&D Survivor: Planar Dragons

    Adamantite Dragon 8 Astral Dragon (Dragon #134) 11 Hellfire Wyrm 9 Radiant Dragon 11
  9. see

    D&D (2024) Do you plan to adopt D&D5.5One2024Redux?

    Not much. Oh, it was derided as a too-soon cash grab by WotC, and there was definite criticism of WotC for "they fixed things that weren't broken", but approximately nobody sticking with 3rd called other members of the community who were switching to 3.5 traitors. But then, approximately none of...
  10. see

    D&D (2024) [+] Future of The SRD Speculation Thread

    I do grant that WotC never came out and explicitly said, in so many words . . . "We're trying to patch up pubic relations after our missteps around the OGL. And, of course, we want to do that at minimal expense and effort (that's why we went with CC-BY so suddenly, after all, it was faster and...
  11. see

    D&D General D&D Survivor: Planar Dragons

    Adamantite Dragon 16 Astral Dragon (Dragon #134) 16 Concordant Dragon 12 Hellfire Wyrm 18 Oceanus Dragon 2 Radiant Dragon 15 Rust Dragon 16
  12. see

    D&D General D&D Survivor: Planar Dragons

    Adamantite Dragon 18 Astral Dragon (Dragon #134) 15 Battle Dragon -1 Concordant Dragon 15 Hellfire Wyrm 18 Oceanus Dragon 9 Radiant Dragon 15 Rust Dragon 19
  13. see

    D&D General The Making of Original Dungeons & Dragons: 1970-1977 Coming In June

    Yeah, so, is that more or less funny now that, twenty years later, everyone and their mother (Gillette, Schick, Bic, even Amazon Basics) is selling five-blade disposables, and there are companies selling six- and seven-blade ones?
  14. see

    D&D (2024) [+] Future of The SRD Speculation Thread

    [Edit: The following was based on what apparently was my misunderstanding of what Parmandur meant by "loss leader", thanks to my unfamiliarity with DDB. The basic point that the SRD isn't particularly important for DDB going forward.] The current SRD is the free content on D&D Beyond for 5th...
  15. see

    D&D (2024) [+] Future of The SRD Speculation Thread

    My primary speculation is that we won't see the new SRD until 2026. After all, we didn't see the SRD5 until 2016, and 3rd edition didn't have the official release of any part of it SRD until April 2001, and was not fully officially released until early 2003. (Yeah, I fired up the Internet...
  16. see

    D&D (2024) Do you plan to adopt D&D5.5One2024Redux?

    Depends on what you mean by "the lore". There's a lot of stuff in the three SRDs (3rd, 3.5, and 5th) and the original/revised/complete Tome of Horrors that very clearly and distinctively originates in D&D, rather than, say, Tunnels & Trolls or Palladium Fantasy. It might not be "the lore" in a...
  17. see

    D&D 5E Vecna: Eve of Ruin Coming May 21st!

    I mean, my question was, "Wait, why is Vecna trying to destroy the multiverse? Isn't that Tharizdun's job?" Reading the link, it instead seems to be a repeat of the Die Vecna Die! transform-to-take-over plot. Perhaps Vecna has simply forgotten that didn't work last time?
  18. see

    D&D 5E Why Is The Assassin Rpgue?

    It's not that bad. At worst, "Assassinate" is overly-circumstantial, and the disguise stuff doesn't see any use in a campaign, and you have a character who simply does what literally any rogue could. That's not great, but the Way of the Four Elements tempts inexperienced players with a promise...
  19. see

    WotC Hasbro selling D&D IP?

    In retrospect, I'm convinced what truly killed 4e was the "annual PHB" model choking off new player acquisition even harder than the old "release a splatbook for everything" model did. I wouldn't have diagnosed things that way even as late as 2016. But 5e's totally atypical sales growth curve...
  20. see

    D&D 5E Amazon US book sales rank.

    I might have believed it outselling any previous edition's PHB, actually. IIRC, back in 2014 I thought 5th had hit a sweet spot, design wise, and was well suited to be the baseline reference edition for Hasbro efforts to license the brand. More logical/systematic than AD&D ever had been, much...
Top