Search results

  1. T

    Gestalt Madness

    They're meant to be played in a game where all PCs are gestalt.
  2. T

    Rogues flanking at range?

    What the first line does is showthe bonus (When making a melee attack, you get a +2 flanking bonus), andthe requirements (if your opponent is threatened by a character or creature friendly to you on the opponent's opposite border or opposite corner) for flanking which must still be active when...
  3. T

    Rogues flanking at range?

    Why would it need to, flanking is listed in the PHB. As for designer intent it's pretty obvious. Does any PC race in the PHB have space/reach of anything other that 5 feet...no. How big is a square according to the rules...5 feet. The problem with your blanket statement is that a fine or...
  4. T

    Rogues flanking at range?

    As you've pointed out in 3e it was a ranged weapon so that handles itself doesn't it ;)
  5. T

    Rogues flanking at range?

    Not true, that is your interpretation of the text. Firstly please use the correct terms flanking is not a condition (check the DMG), it is a combat situation. Of course flanking is not dependent upon combat placement alone. It is based on combat placement and being able to make a threatening...
  6. T

    Rogues flanking at range?

    It is a very valid objection as your interpretation changes the situation from only being able to flank in melee, for which the reach of 0 feet rule makes sense, to a situation which no longer makes sense as they aren't constrained by reach when using a ranged weapon. As to whether tiny or...
Top