Search results

  1. ichabod

    The "I Didn't Comment in Another Thread" Thread

    And remember that smart people aren't any more rational than average or dumb people. They're just better at rationalizing their irrationality.
  2. ichabod

    The "I Didn't Comment in Another Thread" Thread

    Sometimes I think I'm missing out not seeing all these bans. But a voice in my head says I'm probably not missing anything I want to see.
  3. ichabod

    D&D 5E Your top 3 official 5E full book adventures.

    I've run Curse of Strahd, Dungeon of the Mad Mage, Dragon Heist, Princes of the Apocalypse (early TPK), Storm King's Thunder. I haven't really liked any of them enough to put them in a top 3. In my opinion Mad Mage and Storm King are okay, Strahd is bad, and Dragon Heist/Apocalypse are...
  4. ichabod

    How Should RPG Books Be Organized - on your shelf?

    I find that the only organization I need are the ones I need for my current game, and the rest.
  5. ichabod

    D&D (2024) No new OneDnD encumberance?

    Are your players capable of keeping tracking of their wealth precisely? Then they can keep track of their weight precisely.
  6. ichabod

    Ravenloft in Space!

    Hear me out: what's the first thing you think of when you hear Ravenloft in Space? Well, obviously, it's Pigs in Space. So change it to Baconloft in Space. Then you have the obvious system: Toon.
  7. ichabod

    The "I Didn't Comment in Another Thread" Thread

    Damn, don't be subtle about it or anything.
  8. ichabod

    Describe your last rpg session in 5 words

    Freed hobgoblin, found pirate booty
  9. ichabod

    The "I Didn't Comment in Another Thread" Thread

    Yeah, yeah. They said that 20 years ago, and I bet they'll be saying it 20 years from now.
  10. ichabod

    The "I Didn't Comment in Another Thread" Thread

    Thank you for proving there is a martial/caster imbalance. The two most popular classes in this thread are wizards and bards, both full casters.
  11. ichabod

    D&D 5E If WotC Did A New Setting Search

    Fine, straight European fantasy, or whatever you want to call it. Dragonlance, Forgotten Realms, Greyhawk, all of those. It's been done to death.
  12. ichabod

    D&D 5E If WotC Did A New Setting Search

    Whatever it is, it can't be straight medieval fantasy. There's tons of those settings already, and whatever D&D will be, it will fit easily into those settings. We need something new. Some have mentioned non-Western mythologies as a base, and that would be one way to do it. One thing I would...
  13. ichabod

    How do deal with players who don't search?

    I think this is the heart of the problem: I just have a bunch of casual players. I think what I am going to do is treat them as other player types based on small deviations I've noticed from the casual player type. I'll let that ride for a while and then have an intermission session to make sure...
  14. ichabod

    Update: Sadly Jennell passed away Jan 10, 2024. Jennell Jaquays, one of the founding creators of this hobby, needs our help.

    What kills me are the people who are getting divorced so that no one can go after their spouse for their medical debt after they die.
  15. ichabod

    D&D General Multiclass names

    Rogadin and Eldritch Rogue
  16. ichabod

    How do deal with players who don't search?

    Combats are not a big thing. They're really just four casual players, except one guy who is a little bit of an optimizer. I don't have any real butt kickers or tacticians. When some time frees up I'm working on another campaign for a new group, but I don't want to just dump these guys. They're...
  17. ichabod

    How do deal with players who don't search?

    The feeling was that it was a play style difference and we then started the Dungeon of the Mad Mage campaign. And things haven't really gotten any better. They'll search when something is really suspicious, but not otherwise. I am frequently cluing them in to bits they forgot (like you've been...
  18. ichabod

    How do deal with players who don't search?

    The thread about the player who loves evil characters reminded me of my problem players. I've been playing with them since I got back into D&D at the start of the pandemic. But they are oblivious. The first thing we did was go through the Yawning Portal adventures in a home brew world I threw...
Top