Search results

Banshee 12 Ghost 5 Ghoul 17 Revenant 13 Shadow 14 Skeleton 16 Vampire 14-3=11 Wight 19 Wraith 22+1=23

Downvotes are 3 Banshee 20 Ghast 12 Ghost 24 Ghoul 22 Lich 14 Mummy 6 Mummy Lord 6 Nightwalker 1 Revenant 24 Shadow 23 Skeleton 20 Spectre 19 Vampire 24-3=21 Wight 17 Wraith 24+1=25

This seems like a pretty simple and system consistent solution; for those reasons I like it better than Expertise being +2. I may have missed discussion of this idea from one of the earlier posts in the thread, but do any of you see any obviously bad consequences of making this rule change in a...

DOWNVOTES ARE 3 Banshee 20 Demilich 7 Ghast 15 Ghost 24 Ghoul 21 Lich 18 Mummy 12 Mummy Lord 16 Nightwalker 10 Revenant 22 Shadow 23 Skeleton 20 Spectre 18 Vampire 25-3=22 never liked 'em Wight 19 Wraith 26+1=27 arbitrary first place bump

Banshee 26 Bone Naga 20 Boneclaw 20 Death Knight 17 Death Tyrant 4 Deathlock 12 Demilich 23 Dracolich 22 Eidolon 12 Flameskull 14 Ghast 18 Ghost 23 Ghoul 23+1=24 Lich 21 Mind Flayer Lich 19 Minotaur Skeleton 13 Mummy 25 Mummy Lord 24 Nightwalker 22 Revenant 23 Shadow 21 Skeleton 25 Skull Lord 22...

I love this idea and may have to steal it. The change is elegant, since it's a minor one that only removes one rule. It's also elegant because it makes 13s and other odd numbers from char creation less egregiously sub-optimal; getting a 17 from standard array+race mod would be way better...

Alexander, Lloyd 22 Cook, Glen 19 Jemisin, N.K. 13 Kay, Guy Gavriel 9-2=7 LeGuin, Ursula 24+1=25 McKillip, Patricia 15 Pratchett, Terry 15 Wolfe, Gene 14

Alexander, Lloyd 19 Cook, Glen 22 Jemisin, N.K. 11 Kay, Guy Gavriel 18 LeGuin, Ursula 24 Lynch, Scott 12 McKillip, Patricia 20 Pratchett, Terry 17-2=15 Wolfe, Gene 18+1=19

Alexander, Lloyd 21 Cook, Glen 21 Jemisin, N.K. 16 Kay, Guy Gavriel 21 LeGuin, Ursula 21 Lynch, Scott 19 McKillip, Patricia 22 Peake, Mervyn 9 Pratchett, Terry 19-2=17 Wolfe, Gene 19+1=20

I would say: 1.) Changing which figures you choose to lionize with statues is eminently reasonable, take down all the statues you like 2.) Book burning/banning is never cool, stop with that nonsense 3.) I have to hedge on this one: it depends on the extent to which the methane emissions from...

I didn't check the thread for a few days and, lo and behold, my go to +1 vote Clark Ashton Smith was eliminated. As far as I can tell, nobody in the 6-7 pages of his slow burning elimination commented on their down vote. So, I'm curious, why did my boy CAS deserve the axe?

Alexander, Lloyd 22 Cook, Glen 21 Jemisin, N.K. 18 Kay, Guy Gavriel 21 LeGuin, Ursula 21+1=22 Lynch, Scott 20 McKillip, Patricia 21 Peake, Mervyn 18 Pratchett, Terry 17 Sanderson, Brandon 15-2=13 Wolfe, Gene 22

Alexander, Lloyd 24 Augusta, Lady Gregory 15 Bear, Elizabeth 5 Bulfinch, Thomas 22 Cook, Glen 24 Hodgson, William Hope 10 Jemisin, N.K. 22 Kay, Guy Gavriel 23 LeGuin, Ursula 24 Lynch, Scott 24 McKillip, Patricia 23 Peake, Mervyn 21 Pratchett, Terry 20 Sanderson, Brandon 20-2=18 Smith, Clark...

Alexander, Lloyd 23 Augusta, Lady Gregory 19 Bear, Elizabeth 15 Bulfinch, Thomas 23 Cook, Glen 23 Hodgson, William Hope 16 Jemisin, N.K. 22 Kay, Guy Gavriel 22 LeGuin, Ursula 22 Lynch, Scott 25 McKillip, Patricia 25 Peake, Mervyn 22 Pratchett, Terry 22 Sanderson, Brandon 23-2=21 Smith, Clark...

Alexander, Lloyd 25 Augusta, Lady Gregory 19 Bear, Elizabeth 16 Brooks, Terry 2-2=0 Bulfinch, Thomas 24 Cook, Glen 23 Froud, Brian & Alan Lee 11 Hodgson, William Hope 16 Jemisin, N.K. 22 Kay, Guy Gavriel 25 LeGuin, Ursula 26 Lynch, Scott 26 McKillip, Patricia 24 Peake, Mervyn 25 Pratchett, Terry...

Ahmed, Saladin 6 Alexander, Lloyd 25 Augusta, Lady Gregory 19 Bear, Elizabeth 18 Brooks, Terry 10 Bulfinch, Thomas 25 Cook, Glen 27-2=25 the black company series is full of awesome ideas, but I found the military fantasy writing style increasingly grating after the first book as the size of the...

Ahmed, Saladin 18 Alexander, Lloyd 27 Anthony, Piers 4 Augusta, Lady Gregory 19 Bear, Elizabeth 20 Brooks, Terry 24 Bulfinch, Thomas 25 Cook, Glen 25 Froud, Brian & Alan Lee 21 Hodgson, William Hope 18 Jemisin, N.K. 22 Jordan, Robert 14-2=12 Kay, Guy Gavriel 22 LeGuin, Ursula 25 Lynch, Scott 23...

Hey... wait a minute... :uhoh:

Ahmed, Saladin 18 Alexander, Lloyd 25 Anthony, Piers 12 Augusta, Lady Gregory 20 Bear, Elizabeth 20 Brooks, Terry 20 Bulfinch, Thomas 23 Cook, Glen 26 Froud, Brian & Alan Lee 21 Hickman, Tracy & Margaret Weis 7 Hodgson, William Hope 18 Jemisin, N.K. 21 Jordan, Robert 19-2=17 --after George RR...

Leiber, Fritz 9+1=10 Zelazny, Roger 3-2=1