Search results

  1. H

    Vancian? Why can't we let it go?

    But the 4E power system is kinda Vancian, except you not only have per day spells, but per encounter and per round.
  2. H

    Making Magic Magical Again?

    Sometimes magic can "fail", even in D&D. It can be more effective than ordinary weapons, but it can make its blunders now and then. If magic is always reliable and predictable, it becomes less magical, IMO.
  3. H

    Making Magic Magical Again?

    Giving the 1st level M-U one Magic Missile per day is good start. Magic starts to feel less magical when it can be used too often, like an bow.
  4. H

    D&D 5E Skills in 5E. Do we want them?

    Trained skills: roll 1, 2 or 3 on a d6 Untrained skills, roll 1 on a d6 GM gives +1 or -1 depending on the difficulty of a particular task.
  5. H

    D&D 5E [5E] To Vance or not to Vance - That is the Question

    A wise mage always carry a set of scrolls for every occasion.;) ------ Vancian yes! ALl editions had Vancian Magic, it isn't D&D without it.
  6. H

    D&D 5E Hopes for the 5E Fighter

    Mike and Monte released the Book of Iron Might a long time ago, and in my opinion it is the best supplement for the fighter class so far. I hope they can put in 5e some of the ideas from that book. I don't like powers and/or feats that give certain "maneuvers" to the fighter because I believe it...
  7. H

    So what races and classes do we consider core?

    Humans Elves Dwarves Gnomes Halfling Orcs Trolls Tauren Undead Goblin
  8. H

    "Railroading" is just a pejorative term for...

    Not if the players believe and trust the DM.
  9. H

    "Railroading" is just a pejorative term for...

    DMing is also a type of illusionism. If you run a railroad adventure, but give to the players the illusion of choice, that it's a sandbox and they can do whatever they want, and they buy it, than you're golden. The best DM I played with were also good liers.
  10. H

    What would WotC need to do to win back the disenchanted?

    But it is. I remember Mearls saying (or some other designer back then) that they put some kids that never played RPGs in a room with 3.5 books so they could play D&D. They took like 4 hours learning the rules in order to play it, IIRC. So one of the design goals for DD4 was to make it easier for...
  11. H

    [setting help] Science fantasy races

    Reptilians. An ancient race of master magicians that controlled most of the known world, now a decadent civilization. Less like V and more like reptides from chrono trigger. Proto-humans. Remaning ancestors of humans that weren's touched by the space gods and didn't evolved to a more...
  12. H

    PHB2 sold out!

    Hundreds of thousands, let's say 500,000. A poster suggested some groups have only 1 or 2 PHBs, so let's say all groups buy only 1 PHB. Let's say all groups have the good number of 6 people. (1 dm, 5 players) That's 3 million 4e players, out of 6 million D&D players, with very very optimistic...
  13. H

    PDFS--Of the WotC Court Case

    What's the point in sueing a guy from the Phillippines?
  14. H

    WotC puts a stop to online sales of PDFs

    huh? The people actually suffering the consequences are those who legally buy the PDFs. The harder is for the pirate to put on an ilegal PDF, the more prestige he gets when he does it. 4E PDFs now gained an extra 100 prestige pts per book.
  15. H

    WotC puts a stop to online sales of PDFs

    2E books were available even before 3E.
  16. H

    WotC puts a stop to online sales of PDFs

    Well done indeed. Unfotunately they pissed off all the 4 guys who paid for the PDF yesterday.:p
  17. H

    WotC puts a stop to online sales of PDFs

    I honestly assume it wasn't. link
  18. H

    Why DON'T you pirate?

    What if I download a pirate PDF for the sakes of taking a look to see if it's worth a buy, pretty much like paging a book in the local store? What if I download a pirate PDF I know i'd never ever be able to buy legally? (in PDF or the real book) Just asking.
  19. H

    WotC puts a stop to online sales of PDFs

    Are you serious? Gleemax. DDI. The kitchen table in your PC thing.
  20. H

    Skill Chellenges - unfun?

    Hell is repetition.
Top