Search results

  1. A

    The Nature Knight, how would this work in AL - How would you rule it?

    Ok, I think we are getting away from the purpose of the thread. I see that most on this thread are against it. Thanks for your participation
  2. A

    The Nature Knight, how would this work in AL - How would you rule it?

    You guys are thinking along the lines of awards. Find steed is a spell, that allows you to summon a riding horse. Animal Friendship is a spell that allows you to befriend an animal
  3. A

    The Nature Knight, how would this work in AL - How would you rule it?

    Well, technically there is nothing that says you can't, and I'm willing to bet the AL Admins won't make a ruling on this and leave it to the individual DMs. That's why I was asking who would allow and who wouldn't. If I was DMing, I would allow it but I wouldn't let the character use it like a...
  4. A

    The Nature Knight, how would this work in AL - How would you rule it?

    Understood, I thought you were talking about restrictions. The fact that the befriended animal doesn't have those abilities makes it more fun. That's why I would do an animal handling check before each battle. I think the more I feed it, heal it and treat it well, the more loyal it will become...
  5. A

    The Nature Knight, how would this work in AL - How would you rule it?

    Tanks for your responses. Let me address your concerns and explain why I would allow it. 1 - Find steed does not have specifics around it. There is all kinds of animal variants used for find steed. A 5th level paladin pre-gen created by AL had a Paladin with a bear as a steed. They purposely...
  6. A

    The Nature Knight, how would this work in AL - How would you rule it?

    17 views and no comments? I guess I'm alone in my desire for a proper savage knight. He he. I'm trying to get a feel if i'm going to be denied my mount whenever I play outside my normal circles.
  7. A

    The Nature Knight, how would this work in AL - How would you rule it?

    I'm a fan of knights. I have maybe 6 characters that have at least one level of Paladin. My favorite feature of the paladin class is the find steed spell. I find it to be very flavorful and thematic without being over powered. I love the concept of a savage knight riding a feral animal. I...
  8. A

    D&D 5E Player Races in Upcoming Volo's Guide to Monsters

    The Aasamir were in SCAG to, but AL still said a cert was required. I wonder if they will do the same with the races here?
  9. A

    D&D 5E Why ever play a cleric?

    I have some issues with this statement, and it doesn't match my play style or experience. A cleric is so much more than a Healer; in fact, my clerics taking healing as a secondary role. My other characters rarely rely on the cleric to heal them. Cleric vs Paladin - Clerics have one less...
  10. A

    Exclusive content not so exclusive anymore.....Thank God!

    So, it looks like we had an Epic in California. It was down in LA, but at least it was somewhat local. I unfortunately didn't hear about until it was too late, but I'm glad it happened. How did it go? Was the experience lessened because of the size of the con? Thank you Admins for listening. I'm...
  11. A

    AL VS LFR of 4th and why I'm so disappointed

    I get your point Kalani, and I appreciate it. You are saying that if there is a desire for Genasi using SCAG material, and you already know it isn't broken, you will find a way to add in a future story origin. That directly addresses one of my concerns if it is done in a timely manner. My thread...
  12. A

    AL VS LFR of 4th and why I'm so disappointed

    Doesn't the rule prevent this as well?
  13. A

    AL VS LFR of 4th and why I'm so disappointed

    Ok, I'm done. I won't be responding to this thread anymore. I've made my point, and I just hope you guys are listening. If not, I'm sure I'll be back to make my point again. Sorry about the noise, but there were some things that needed to be said. As far as shutting this thread down. I've...
  14. A

    AL VS LFR of 4th and why I'm so disappointed

    I'm sorry, but I don't roll over and show my belly. We are a community and sometimes the loudest squeak gets the grease. Others have joined this thread and expressed their displeasure on the ruling concerting EE Companion and SCAG, and as long as I can't have my Genasi EK with GreenFlame Blade...
  15. A

    AL VS LFR of 4th and why I'm so disappointed

    I agree with this whole heartedly There are so many things wrong with this statement its not even funny. This thread started with you attacking me saying I'm making stuff up, and you were very condescending about it. I've countered your every statement with direct quotes from the rule books...
  16. A

    AL VS LFR of 4th and why I'm so disappointed

    I"m sure you wish this was true, but it is not. Page 9 of said book under "Toril and Its Lands" the part about Calimshan starts off with saying "This southern land has long been a battle ground for warring genies", and then goes on to describe how the humans slaves over threw the two Genie lords...
  17. A

    AL VS LFR of 4th and why I'm so disappointed

    I have to say. Making content, then announcing it to the world and saying "If you wan this, pay for me to come run it for you" I think is giving the wrong message. Make the content available and then say "Special guest star "This dude" will be here to run it for you. This sends a better message...
  18. A

    AL VS LFR of 4th and why I'm so disappointed

    Well, my arguments are still valid. But it sounds like you are fighting on our behalf somewhat. You guys are my avenue to Wizards since they did in their forums and obviously created you to be the buffer. Also, it seems the admin staff and wizards staff are all are part of that special club and...
  19. A

    AL VS LFR of 4th and why I'm so disappointed

    Then why do I keep hearing that AL is separate from Wizards. If they are making granular decisions such as this, then AL and Wizards are one and the same as far as I'm concerned.
  20. A

    AL VS LFR of 4th and why I'm so disappointed

    Here's another example of blaming Wizards. You state the IDEA was wizards. Did they mandate that you restrict content to be story + PHB, or was that a decision that was made by AL. If the latter, it doesn't matter what Wizards says. If the former, what do you decide on? Did Wizards mandate...
Top