Search results

  1. T

    Rapiers

    For that matter, most weapons apart from daggers, polearms, and the two handed swords, weighed between two and three lbs. Even the largest practical two-hander weighed no more than six and a half/seven lbs, and averaged close to four and a half to five. Weight is always an issue when it comes...
  2. T

    Smudges - All Core books

    Gloss paper + cheaper inks = faster smudging.
  3. T

    Melnoboneans and Elves

    Oh, if you're referring to the AD&D alignment axis... Elric was chaotic neutral tending towards good (in the first two books) in a society that was chaotic evil. In AD&D terms, Elric suffered more than a few alignment shifts around chaotic neutral/neutral/chaotic evil. I think at the end, he's...
  4. T

    Please critique my kitchen-sink fantasy demography

    Druids and agricultural clerics also become highly important. If I recall correctly, what little evidence we have of the ancient druidic religion is that they functioned as intercessors between a hostile natural world and the needs of the local community, and not as the "nature is balanced/man...
  5. T

    Cryptic Prophesies

    "Everything will now come your way." I like that, especially in mountainous regions. Or "You will make a fortune with your friend" ... in an evil country that allows slavery. For the top henchman (or any minion) of the Big Bad Evil "Your talents will be recognized and suitably rewarded."
  6. T

    Forked Thread: I hate game balance! (How elves wrecked the wizard and game balance)

    Dual-classing... seems to be useful, yes? Not so much if you actually play out the dual-class and the DM enforces the rules. "Oh, you're acting as a fighter for this combat, putting on the chainmail? Well, no XP for you for this *adventure*." Kinder DMs would only take away XP for that...
  7. T

    Forked Thread: I hate game balance! (How elves wrecked the wizard and game balance)

    It happens to be my real name. As for Prismatic Blade, I think it was an eighth or ninth level spell, and at that level, well... there were considerably better spells available. Chromatic Orb was an illusionist-only spell in 1st edition, and it was *the* major attack spell for illusionists. It...
  8. T

    Melnoboneans and Elves

    I don't see that they'd care about what another Melnibonean does, even if it is to be nice/gentle/compassionate. Unless that other Melnibonean is in a position of power. About the only time they did care was when it was the Emperor himself who wasn't completely amoral, i.e. Elric. Remember...
  9. T

    Players Vs. DMs

    "On the 3rd attack of the round it uses the holders magic item daily slot, and brings both the character and the target to 0 hp." Yeah, I'd be pretty peeved if this was the only weapon I could ever use because the curse forces me to use it, which is what is strongly implied in your earlier posts.
  10. T

    Death of the LGS

    Calico_Jack, all you have to do is go to the employee working at the register and ask to crack the shrinkwrap. They'll happily allow you to. The reason for the shrinkwrap is to keep the books looking nice despite the number of people handling it, and to provide a place for the price stickers to...
  11. T

    Does anyone actually like Dragonborn and Tieflings?

    I don't have a problem with the *idea* of either as a race. What I have problems with are the specific background fluff elements that Wizards put in for the races. "Paragons of honor" for Dragonborn? You're talking about sapient reptiles who are closely related to DRAGONS. "Paragons of...
  12. T

    Melnoboneans and Elves

    If you read the books of Corum closely, and then read the Elric books... the Melniboneans are the Vadagh, decadent and corrupted by tens of thousands of years of contact with Chaos.
  13. T

    Forked Thread: I hate game balance! (How elves wrecked the wizard and game balance)

    I'd like to point out something important about the multi-classed fighter/magic-user/thief/whatever in 1st edition. Experience earned was split equally between the classes. This is important. It means that instead of advancing at the same rate as human single-classed characters, the...
  14. T

    Company Mitosis, GSL and OGL

    Considering that the decision is by product line and not by company, there's no reason that a company cannot produce both OGL and GSL books. The only conflict is that they cannot produce OGL *and* GSL versions of the *same* product.
  15. T

    4E Combat isn't like WoW, it's like Street Fighter.

    4e is, in my opinion, most like City of Heroes, in terms of its approach to spell-like abilities and special attacks, and the way they're chosen. Seriously. Think of the different classes as Archetypes, and the at-will, encounter, daily, and utility powers as being different power pools.
  16. T

    D&D 4E When will 4E break?

    4e will break the moment they publish anything that hasn't been tested in play for at least a month. i.e. the first time they publish a rules supplement.
  17. T

    What *is* D&D?

    D&D ...is a specific set of rules and assumptions about a fantasy setting that incorporate certain elements that are unique to Dungeons and Dragons (such as but by no means limited to wizards not being able to cast spells in armor, paladins being or attempting to be paragons of order, honesty...
  18. T

    TSR Q&A with Gary Gygax

    For another little twist on this, give the treacherous noble the following device on his coat of arms: gules, a Dragon rampant sinister. Or maybe; gules, a Dragon affronty. :)
  19. T

    "in 1st Edition...every DM...assumed that Corellon Larethian put out Gruumsh's eye"?

    Corellon and Gruumsh made their first appearance in the 1st edition Deities and Demigods book, they were definitely part of the Greyhawk setting. It was the Forgotten Realms which took the handful of Elven deities and expanded it into a large pantheon, introducing a couple dozen gods and...
  20. T

    Iggwilv's Legacy

    The original module wasn't designed for "straight through" play, just like most other large dungeons. You would go in, mess around for a while, then leave to recover. In Tomb of Horrors, if you just kept pressing on, your party would end up stomped flat. If you played intelligently, there was...
Top