Search results

  1. A

    TPK Dillema

    Stupid to how much of the table? Generally, gms are outnumbered. Plus, if it's really stupid, the character with high int or wis would likely realise that IC, or is thinking entirely on the heads of the players? Also, there are people who don't play for the ever-present impending doom and...
  2. A

    Rewarding Roleplaying

    It seems like you are saying that fluff doesn't matter at all. Which, in a particular light is true, but... In my experience, I've not ever ran across someone playing dnd who's there entirely for the mechanical idea. I've never seen the player who'd be fine with their character being a large...
  3. A

    Teleportation at level 1

    Or, if you really want to lock it down, steal shamelessly the Lunar Exalted method of it. Make the druid ritually kill a given animal to be able to assume their shape at a later date. That way, they would have to actually encounter whatever animal form you don't want them to have.
  4. A

    Wielding a shield and off-hand item

    He does, as dual implement spellcaster has the same prereq. However, two weapon fighting is a prereq, so extra feat again.
  5. A

    Bladesinger Preview!

    Huh, requires offhand to not hold a weapon or a shield. Nothing about an implement. Go bladesingers with a spear and orb! Chaaaaaaaarge~
  6. A

    Wielding a shield and off-hand item

    What sort of implement chease is the player trying to pull? If not using staff fighting with a rod of ruin, he can use rhythm blade parrying dagger to get the offhand shield bonus, cept better then light sheild. Needs 2 feats, prof parrying dagger and arcane implement prof light blades though...
  7. A

    D&D 4E What's so bad about 4th edition? What's so good about other systems?

    In the game I'm in a within level + or - 1 damage dealer using new damage math can knock 1/4 to 1/3 of a player's hp off if they are squishy class hp. (we are level 5) I do say that it's actually a fairly common occurrence assuming 3-4 monsters can sidestep the defender. In my experience...
  8. A

    Hitting one's self question

    Auto violate palidin mark. With certain pali's, that means weakened as well as damage, plus they might hit themselfs too. There are several builds that make violating marks a really bad idea, being able to make an enemy standing next to the fighter do it with an at will with no further setup...
  9. A

    D&D 4E What's so bad about 4th edition? What's so good about other systems?

    Are all controllers supposed to be not targeted? It's infrequent at heroic levels that a single defender can stop the traditional 5 or 6 enemies all the time from getting to whoever they feel like in say an outdoors encounter. Or a large cave. Or pretty much anything without a convenient choke...
  10. A

    Hitting one's self question

    Where, if anywhere, does it say that you can or can not hit yourself with a melee basic attack. Same with a targeted burst? This comes up occasionally with the dominate status, the hypnotism power and similar.
  11. A

    D&D 4E What's so bad about 4th edition? What's so good about other systems?

    Not true. Second wind plus heal back to full from being dropped is 5 surges. 6 if you got a cleric heal as well. Extremely likely if you are a squishy that gets surrounded. Unless you squishes never get surrounded or dropped. Also, I guess if you have the healing surge moving ritual, but that...
  12. A

    How Can a DM Encourage Roleplaying?

    Thing is, generally speaking the gm gets to play other gendered people. If not, that leads to some interesting world-building gender roles. Really, that particular thing is just silly, as it tends to mean just 'I prefer that guys play guys' as people tend to be more uncomfortable that a girl is...
  13. A

    Birth control in D&D

    If you don't mind brain-hurtingly bad, the BoEF has stuff like that.
  14. A

    Character Optimization as a Graduate Thesis title

    Cold Steel: On the tactical and raw effectiveness of sub-zero weaponry for combat distraction and additive grievous harm.
  15. A

    Can you sleep in armour with no penalty?

    After a few levels, main plait enchantment -1 summoned plate becomes nightwear. Bam. Minor action and -1 to ac only. Since it's a level 6/11/16/21/26 armor, it's as cheap as you can get the enhancement bonus anyway. Also, enhancement bonus is necessary for game math, remove it without...
  16. A

    Dragon mark feats

    A few of them are 'good' for a given build. But the same can be said of quite a few normal feats. Remove the "Also gives you a glowing mystical prophecy tattoo" property and they are just feats. It's a home game, fluff isn't fixed. Evaluate whatever is being tried, and if it's obnoxious to your...
  17. A

    Players that just don't *get* the genre

    If nothing else, they were working together too well and should be killed for being communists.
  18. A

    Essentials multiclassing playtest?

    And, as a cha user and a healer, they can eaisly 'also vampire' plus 'also blackguard' or some divine class to get 'also ignores daylight/radiant vulrn'. More hilarity ensues if you have encounters from more than one power source to use the 'you can get a healing surge with your encounter'...
  19. A

    What's the big deal with "feat taxes?"

    You'd be more effective with expertiese, with all of one base assumption: are we talking about a warlord that swings and are we talking at upper heroic or higher? There are things better then +1 to hit, not terribly many, but there are, when it gets to +2, there really isn't better. +3 is right...
  20. A

    What's the big deal with "feat taxes?"

    5% aboslute. If you are hitting 50% of the time, 5% more is 10% of what you have. Also, at epic its 15% absolute. Same 50% normally, it's 30% more hit. Assume you 'need' it to hit half the time in epic, you have a base 35%. That's 42.8ish percent of you base that you get added for a feat...
Top