Search results

  1. G

    D&D 5E Thoughts on Mearls' Comments on Fighter Subclasses Lacking Identity

    Just thinking outloud here... Names that would have fit the Champion: Strongman, Soldier, Beast, Gladiator, Grunt Names that would have fit the Battlemaster Fighter: Tactician, Weaponmaster, Warlord, Captain, Duelist I'm not sure if any of those are necessarily more flavourful than the...
  2. G

    D&D 5E Assassinate

    I don't agree with that RAW interpretation, nor that being RAI.
  3. G

    D&D 5E Assassinate

    Keeping track of each surprised creature to know if its still surprised on any particular player's turn seems like too much of a headache to make it worth while. Unless the target attacked/ran before the assassin goes, I give the assassin advantage. If a creature was surprised, I allow the first...
  4. G

    Mike Mearls on stuff... (Tome Show interview from GenCon)

    What is the shape of a wahoonie?
  5. G

    New D&D Movie To Go Ahead - Produced By Lego Movie's Roy Lee

    I don't understand why D&D movies get treated so differently than D&D novels.
  6. G

    Unearthed Arcana Unearthed Arcana Takes on Modern Magic

    I opened the link being skeptical that this would interest me at all... but I must admit, they got my attention with "Ghost in the Machine" and the Cleric linked with the city.
  7. G

    Mike Mearls on stuff... (Tome Show interview from GenCon)

    I don't see anything in the top 10 links which show that people are upset that Pathfinder keeps printing new versions with errata. But maybe I didn't look hard enough. I only see complaints about the rules themselves...
  8. G

    Mike Mearls on stuff... (Tome Show interview from GenCon)

    I don't know. Is Drivethrurpg able to split the sale between the uploader and wizards and allow anyone to upload content? They did say the project was big.
  9. G

    Multi classing

    Where there are stats and choices there will be builds. That's why the 5e DMG tells you about the Optimizer play style. See here for but one example: http://brilliantgameologists.com/boards/index.php?topic=10675.0
  10. G

    Crtitique my Pharmacist?

    Well, I'm open to ideas.
  11. G

    D&D 5E Assassinate

    In dungeons, with monsters in various rooms, sometimes future creatures can be surprised. So its not that it only works on the first round of combat, its that it only works on the first round of combat from the victim's point of view.
  12. G

    Multi classing

    People have builds for 2e also.
  13. G

    D&D 5E Convert ROTRL or wait for Out of the Abyss?

    Based on what we know so far my guess is as follows. You will be sent to the underdark to discover the cause and truth of rumors about Demon Lords running amock in the underdark. You will fall through some hole and feel like alice in the underdark of maddness, since the demon lords will have...
  14. G

    Multi classing

    By creating such a game system, all you will do for that type of player is that instead of having a plan for class options, they would have a plan for which adventures they plan to go on and in which order they plan on doing them.
  15. G

    Crtitique my Pharmacist?

    I see. But how would I flavour that? Currently, I'm basically saying that the ingredients used to create the items can't be stored very long without large heavy equipment in a lab. So you can only collect enough ingredients to make an item using the slot system, and if you don't create the...
  16. G

    Multi classing

    I find multi-classing worth it, when its something you want to do. My Cadderly clone for example, didn't feel right without multiclassing.
  17. G

    Mike Mearls on stuff... (Tome Show interview from GenCon)

    If they create an app store for third party content, then there won't be a license but everything else you mentioned would be possible. Another option would be for people to submit their publications to WoTC, and then WoTC gives a "yes/no" response to it. And so they release guidelines for...
  18. G

    Mike Mearls on stuff... (Tome Show interview from GenCon)

    I find that the DMG gives everybody the tools they need to add more content and options if there is a specific character concept that they have that they want implemented. I find what the published character options do, is give people new ideas for concepts they may not have otherwise thought...
  19. G

    Crtitique my Pharmacist?

    What am I missing? It looks the same to me, only based on the Warlock or maybe the Paladin instead of the Wizard.
  20. G

    Crtitique my Pharmacist?

    What do you mean by free? It takes up a recipe slot, and the item gets lost before the recipe slots get restored. Looking over the link now.
Top