Search results

Just wanted to thank you for the review it was very interesting. You're to hard on yourself you gave a fine description of how the play works or at least I got it it's a sort of betting/bidding thing sounds interesting

you know it's gonna be d20 baybee

Roll inish put it in order call out a range say any over 20 if there's a lot start asking specific #'s over 20. figure out who's first then tell who's second to make ready. whoever's second ignores me. Then they're playing a spellcaster and don't have a clue what the spell is AND THEY'VE...

we created some instant 10th level characters for Tomb of Horrors. I was playing a dwarf mage who I decided had created a shield with a compartment in it that was levered and contained an everburning torch. He could open the lever on the front of his shield allowing differnt amounts of light...

gotta go with x2 castle amber the npc's were insane which is good for story/fear

like greylock said but not for the reasons they said it. flawed poll for you only list one type of d4 and not the truly inovative norse style square d4 with mini pyamids on the ends. So assuming you meant the one that hurt the feet I voted against it.

Say it again brother Although third edition finally gave us a human race that was actually worth playing not crippled out of the gate by the rules. Still This is a fantasy game and let us please have a fantasy race win the race survivor :heh:

I'd be in the 50% to 75% range 75% being if is was a really good product that fit a niche I was needing in my chronicle. Even then it would need to be by a producer that has proven to make good stuff like Malhavic. That said I'm not afraid to pay for something that I think is good since I'm...

Kapture said <How about this: No one would ever confuse the Wizard of Oz with Lord of the Rings, or the Chronicles of Narnia, or Harry Potter, or Chine Mieville, or Clive Barker.> again that's what I'm talking about

Yes you have variety plenty of it in fact which is why what I want instead of Wotc spoonfeeding me what classes they deign to. I'd like a book that lets me the Dm create core classes whole cloth and them not be completely wonky in terms of balance. I'd pay good money for that product instead I...

It's the bullywug book 20% tougher than all the books that have come before

Death by snu-snu y'know if you gotta go there's many worse ways :heh:

answers and comments to your questions follow, in order of apperance I understand it (darn it now I think I just went back on my original post :) ) I could see it but that's different than what was originally asked. What was originally asked as I understood it was would someone ban a woman...

they're all to good so I'll just abstain note I believe the D&D basic set they're referring to is the most recent beginner set with the miniature figures in it not the classic D&D basic set

My biggest problem with Noir and I'll admit it's not entirely justified is that I thought it was going to tell us how to do MnM a little darker. As I said it never advertised itself as that but that's what MnM really needs. I love what they've done and am amazed at how good they've made 4...

The only thing worse was what they had before where well every race has a certain class they're good at except for gnomes they only get a part of a class. that just sucked

good knowing you gnome. I like the gnome alright but of all the races it really has no niche all it's own.

Eolin I'd have to say from what I've read of Crothian that's some sound advice

Alright I'll give you that however that wasn't my point. I grow weary of being locked in to what certain people think fantasy should be. Not that it's wrong just that it's a bit chafing to my particular creativity and I would like to see this done in a way that was balanced. Didn't mean to...