Search results

They weren't mine, they were my brothers (AD&D 1st ed) - and my parents bought them for him as a Christmas present. I wound up playing way more than he did.

You do, really? Personally I think the Balor would look strange in thigh-highs, but to each his own I guess.

This sounds like one of those issues where you have to look at sales numbers. Did modules intended for generic campaign worlds sell better or worse than modules set in specific campaign worlds? (Although the best indicators would be from 2e, where records are poor.)

I'll have to remember this phrase the next time I get into an argument about fire snakes.

I wonder if it would be easier to come up with a backstory reason why your low level starting area is (a) threatened by a lot of monsters right now, but (b) hasn't been so until recently.

Yes, that's what I think. You didn't read the comment or think about it until I'd said some variant of it for the fourth time. Demonstrating that you only argue with what you think I'm saying, not what I'm saying. I suspect more people do agree with me - they're just not bothering to post in...

Thank you very much!

As I said when I first mentioned it, that was what I was told. While I may be mistaken - the fact that you only this time around even brought this up tells me how much you're actually reading my arguments. The fact that you think that tells me a LOT about you and how you think.

I plan to have an encounter with a legendary moose. What you need to do is compare a creature in the MM that has legendary actions, with a creature of the same CR that does not. I suspect that the legendary creature does not have fewer HP or do less damage than the non-legendary. Ergo, no...

As I have pointed out many times, WotC has already addressed the comment of "underage offspring of a sentient race" by deliberately removing the stats for baby dragons from 4e and 5e. So it's not up to me, as it's already been ruled upon. And I question your statement that the burden of proof...

This may be true - but it's only true because WotC decided to make it true. It's not an unfortunate fact of life that we who encounter salamanders and their offspring have to deal with. It's just a particular thing they made up. (Well, I'm told the original Fiend Folio submitter made up.)...

You could do the same story with baby fire giants too, but you wouldn't. You could do the same story by making fire snakes the non-sentient, ancestral relative of salamanders and use dark magic to transform them, much like turning monkeys into orcs or something. And then blow up the Statue of...

A fire snake is whatever the game designers wrote it to be. It has no real world existence. The designers could have chosen to make it something other than the underage offspring of a sentient race, and you would have been none the wiser. This is the point you keep deliberately avoiding...

As I said in the other thread, I'm going to need a barghest in my game.

The distinction is in how you argue. You have previously compared Planescape Lore to elements like Dragonlance or Ravenloft - implying that the version of these creatures we describe is a niche interpretation, an offshoot from the main game. And that including PS in core materials is...

I ignore a lot of lore when it suits me. That said, there are so many people on this forum that sing the praises of the 4e Monster Lore Books, that I suspect WotC saw a desire in the fanbase for richer lore and not sparser.

In the real world at the time, most if not all diamonds came from India. Imagine one country having a monopoly on the power to raise the dead. Then the dwarves come along and discover kimberlite pipes, and that there's enough diamonds for everybody and then some. Imagine then what the diamond...

How many fingers am I holding up?

No, no, those monsters are your friends. Which is why you keep them in small balls.

See, you keep getting it wrong. The stuff you call PS continuity is, in fact, just the 2e continuity. Not the continuity from one boxed set - the continuity from the core rules. Because the issue you keep bringing up is the description of the outsiders - which was laid out in the MM. If you...