Search results

  1. I

    Exploring Candlekeep Mysteries: An In-depth Review

    Agreed. I'm disappointed they're using Dyson Logos, but I'm hardly a basher; as I said above, DL's maps are "fantastic" in miniature, on the page, in the books. I've never used printed-out versions for live play, but maybe they do work great there too. The problem is they look really, really bad...
  2. I

    Exploring Candlekeep Mysteries: An In-depth Review

    Are all the Rime maps reprints of old maps? Edit: Schley did maps of Icewind Dale for Legacy of the Crystal Shard (2013), but the eleven maps in Rime are different from those. His website says they were "created for" Rime. I'm pretty sure they're new.
  3. I

    Exploring Candlekeep Mysteries: An In-depth Review

    I don't think anything happened to him, and I would expect to continue to see his work in future products. There's never been a period in which only he illustrated maps for WotC (they've always used other cartographers alongside him, often even within a single book). And his maps are prevalent...
  4. I

    Exploring Candlekeep Mysteries: An In-depth Review

    Should be, yes—but according to the book’s page on the FR Fandom site, it has been officially set as 1492 by WotC, and indeed the BG3 video game (whose plot takes up where Descent into Avernus leaves off) begins later in 1492. So the book’s own internal evidence doesn’t jibe with the place it...
  5. I

    Exploring Candlekeep Mysteries: An In-depth Review

    I'm with you, and very disappointed this book uses DL's maps. They are fantastic in miniature, in the books, but terrible for online play. I'm currently halfway through a Descent into Avernus campaign on Roll20 and we're wading through muddy chicken scratches in every location. The players all...
  6. I

    Exploring Candlekeep Mysteries: An In-depth Review

    That used to be so but they haven't stuck to the practice exactly for a while now. Princes of the Apocalypse is explicitly set in 1491 and that book came out six years ago, but we're definitely not up to 1497 yet. The farthest-ahead material we've seen in 5e is 1494 (Descent into Avernus)...
  7. I

    D&D 5E (2014) Do You Prefer Sandbox or Party Level Areas In Your Game World?

    I’m up against this problem right now, as I prepare to start running a campaign of Princes of the Apocalypse. For those unfamiliar with that adventure, it’s a sandbox multi-dungeon crawl. It’s a great book that still holds up in a lot of ways, but it deserves its poor reputation, which rests on...
  8. I

    WotC James Wyatt is on the Dungeons & Dragons Team Again

    Exactly right—but from a nonfinancial standpoint there are a couple of reasons to go ahead and create a new (or revised) edition: 1) you think the game could be improved mechanically in a way that would enhance players' experiences without alienating other players or pissing them off about...
  9. I

    D&D General I'm reading the Forgotten Realms Novels- #202 The Howling Delve by Jaleigh Johnson (Dungeons 2)

    For me the low point is the Hunter’s Blades trilogy, which I think is next up in Goonalan’s reading order (next for the Drizzt series anyway). Those books felt very stale to me. They still have their moments, though.
  10. I

    Is The One Ring 2E Kickstarter going to break the records?

    Of course! It's a fantastic success.
  11. I

    Is The One Ring 2E Kickstarter going to break the records?

    In the comments, Free League has said you just click "Manage My Pledge" and then you have to do math. (Add the extra money to your pledge by manually increasing your pledge to the new total—in SEK.) Seems it might crack $2 mil USD—but doesn't look like it's going to beat Strongholds and...
  12. I

    D&D General I'm reading the Forgotten Realms Novels- #202 The Howling Delve by Jaleigh Johnson (Dungeons 2)

    I liked this one more than you did, though I agree with your criticism of the out-of-nowhere final act with Artemis—which I nonetheless sort of liked on its own terms as a Tarantinoesque real-world-issues revenge fantasy. I remember reading an interview with Salvatore about this in which he...
  13. I

    D&D 5E (2014) Sell Out: Hasbro and the Soul of D&D

    As long as we're doing musical references about selling out, here's mine—and it does sum up my feelings on the matter: "I don't believe you. You're a liar! (Play ****ing loud!)"
  14. I

    DMs Guild Roundup: February

    You can wait as long as you want to get it, of course, but (in the USA at least) Candlekeep Mysteries goes on sale two weeks from today. As for the map in Elminster's Candlekeep Companion, it is indeed excellent. There's a different map of Candlekeep coming as a tear-out poster in Candlekeep...
  15. I

    D&D 5E (2014) Monster Manual Expanded III HARDCOVER/PoD is FINALLY OUT! Get it now from the DM's Guild!

    Thanks for clarifying, sorry I misunderstood. Yeah, international shipping from the DM's Guild is very expensive, so the buy-in-bulk-and-mark-up strategy sounds like a potential winner for international shops. Funnily enough, shipping to for example Europe is (according to the site's FAQ at this...
  16. I

    D&D 5E (2014) Monster Manual Expanded III HARDCOVER/PoD is FINALLY OUT! Get it now from the DM's Guild!

    If I (in the USA) purchase a hardcover POD book from DM's Guild today, I can expect it to arrive in three to five weeks. It might get here sooner, but according to the site's FAQ at this moment, there's currently a twenty-four-day delay for USA/Canada POD products to be printed. There would...
  17. I

    D&D 5E (2014) Monster Manual Expanded III HARDCOVER/PoD is FINALLY OUT! Get it now from the DM's Guild!

    Does the site actually try to impose a “no reselling” policy on purchasers (as opposed to content creators)? I’m asking because, in the US at least, I don’t think that would be legal for books. If I purchase a book, I can turn around and immediately resell it at a markup to whoever (I think...
  18. I

    What's the best and worst D&D book you own from any edition?

    So, when I glanced at the thread title, I mistook "any" for "every," and that still seems like a more fun list, so I'm making it. You'll notice a theme. pre-2e Best: Waterdeep and the North — Incredibly imaginative, it feels like this book plus the grey box constitute the real start of the 2e...
  19. I

    D&D General I'm reading the Forgotten Realms Novels- #202 The Howling Delve by Jaleigh Johnson (Dungeons 2)

    Goonalan, my advice differs slightly from that given by Alzrius. I would say that you've got the recommended reading orders correct for everything except the Return of the Archwizards series. Best to read that one in this order: The Summoning – The Siege – Realms of Shadow – The Sorcerer. You...
  20. I

    D&D 5E (2014) Here's the Ravenloft Alternate Cover!

    Can confirm. As Chris Perkins pointed out in an interview around the time they announced the "revamped" version, she doesn't appear to be concealing the prosthetic in the illustration of her in the book (p. 230), so the text is sort of mismatched with the image to begin with. The revision (on...
Top