Search results

It's a legacy of the progressive "fair" challenge focus of "Classic" play culture. You can see proponents of OSR eschew this in favor of more variable challenge in statements about players learning when to run from a fight and the like.

Yes, I use the above rules when characters with darkvision are trying to see something in the dark. It works out fine.

These are the portfolios I'd generally expect to be part of a pantheon in one of my games: Air, sky, wind, poetry/song (usually having a "king of the gods" role) ~ Odin or Zeus Light, stars/planets ~ Selûne Water, oceans, rivers, music ~ Deep Sashelas Growing, living things, plants, animals ~...

It's an evil act but a minor one if not done to further the cause of Evil, so it doesn't make your character LE right away. But after, say, three to five times, I'd say you're headed for LE territory.

I thought about this some more and didn't make many changes, but I wanted to update what I posted here with something less tentative. So the idea is the elemental planes are arranged in a tetrahedron with the following faces: Fire Air Water Earth (The other inner planes (Material, Feywild, and...

Martin R. Stolar, civil rights and criminal defense attorney, has died. He was 81 years old.

I've been thinking along these lines as well. I think the Manual of the Planes (1987) got the para- and quasi-elemental planes a little wrong, especially the quasi-elemental. They just don't make a lot of sense to me as presented. I prefer if, rather than a ring, the elemental planes are...

In the cosmological scheme to which I generally default in my games, the elemental planes have a lower placement conceptually within the Ethereal Plane than does the Material Plane and are where the elementals "fell" when they were driven out and banished from the Material Plane by the gods just...

I voted for the second option with the caveat that, for everything from early 2016 forward, I prefer 5.1.

According to Wikipedia, the 5th Ed. SRD was released in January 2016 and updated to SRD 5.1 in May 2016. There don't seem to be any rules changes between the two versions (the update had to do with the inclusion of certain IP and the term DM, if I recall correctly), so I think the publication of...

WotC obviously doesn't want it to have its own name. They want you to call it D&D or 5E, just names that are already in use.

No, I don’t suppose they would be and wasn’t suggesting it as a replacement for what the OP says is the orog’s current “orc, but smarter” identity. Now that I think about it, it could hold a clue to a possible new identity for the orog as “ogre, but smarter”. And before someone says oni already...

I don’t understand your claim. Did TSR file the numbers off Uruk-hai, or did they totally not copy them? I don’t think they could do both?

I don't recall Uruk-hai being described as having been created from troll-stock?

You’re both right! Orogs result from breeding male orcs with female ogres, whereas ogrillons are the offspring of male ogres and female orcs. It’s like the difference between a hinny and a mule. Given the above, I think you mean Olog-hai?

Agreed, and I wouldn't associate it with "old school" as I understand the term is used by the OSR. I think it seems to align with some approaches to Trad. But "old school" isn't particularly well defined in this thread, so who knows?

In a recent thread about 5E, I was told I could only use my PC’s background feature if I had a detailed written backstory, approved by the DM, saying how my PC knows such and such person in such and such place. Maybe that’s the sort of thing @Chaosmancer has in mind.

Having failed to knock down her opponent, Bible takes another swing, hoping to bring the giant down this time. Waythe: 1D20+10 = [20]+10 = 30 Critical slashing damage: 8D6+6 = [1, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 5]+6 = 35 Pulling Waythe free of the skewered giant's body, Bible flings its blood from her...

Bible engages the wheezing, glowing giant as it comes within range, putting her full force behind Waythe as she swings. Waythe (advantage): 2D20.HIGH(1)+10 = [7, 13]+10 = 23 Slashing damage: 4D6+6 = [6, 5, 6, 2]+6 = 25 The giant must make a DC 15 Strength saving throw or fall prone.

Another vote for 5.2 here, to match the naming of the SRD 5.2. Referring to D&D (2014) with the equivalent naming convention, it would be version 5/5.1.