Search results

Unlikely. I've skipped 5E entirely, and it doesn't look like 5.5/6E is going to do much to change my problems with the game.

"If the players disagree with you, have them hit by lightning bolts, reduce their Charisma, or have them attacked by an invisible ethereal mummy" -- as suggested in the 1E DMG.

Tier 4 - Masters of the World Fingolfin (Tolkien) Ecthelion (Tolkien) Gil-Galad (Tolkien) Glorfindel (Tolkien) Erekose (Moorcock) John Carter, Warlord of Barsoom (Burroughs) Icarium (Erikson) Elric of Melnibone (Moorcock) Culain Lord of the Lance (Gemmell) Cohen the Barbarian (Pratchett) Kane...

In play? Rarely. But I have let players redo their characters between sessions -- switching classes, reassigning skills, etc. -- especially in cases where the player is new to the system and is still getting the hang of how it works. Of course, this doesn't mean unlimited redos, but I don't see...

Tier 4 - Masters of the World Fingolfin (Tolkien) Ecthelion (Tolkien) Gil-Galad (Tolkien) Glorfindel (Tolkien) John Carter, Warlord of Barsoom (Burroughs) Icarium (Erikson) Tier 3 - Masters of the Realm Hurin (Tolkien) Conan (Howard) Corwin of Amber (Zelazny) Aragorn (Tolkien) Drizzt Do'Urden...

Yeah. I see way too many D&D fans who apparently think the fantasy genre stopped in 1989. As for Moorcock being lesser known today ... while I yield to no one in Moorcock fandom (I've been Lord Shark online for 36 years now, ever since reading "White Stars" in Legends from the End of Time)...

For another example of Law as evil from Moorcock's work, see the Singularity and the Original Insect from the"Second Ether" trilogy (Blood, Fabulous Harbours, and The War Amongst the Angels).

For one example, 1E thieves' ability to read spell scrolls (with a chance of reversed effect) is derived from The Eyes of the Overworld. Cugel steals Iucounu's spellbook and casts some spells by reading directly from it, but then has a spell backfire when he mispronounces a word.

My first non-D&D fantasy RPG? Probably RuneQuest (the 2E boxed set). These days, if I wanted to run fantasy, I'd probably reach for 13th Age, Beyond the Wall, TOR, or Fellowship. Maybe PF2E, although I'd need more experience with it to be certain.

In AD&D 1E and 2E, a trident does 3d4, although only against large enemies.

Search for the Emperor's Treasure was one of Tom Wham's best games, along with King of the Tabletop. It was reprinted in the Best of the Dragon Games boxed set. Unfortunately, the reprint version replaced the original Darlene Pekul-drawn map with Catan-style rearrangeable hexes, which weren't...

Holmes Basic: 1979 AD&D 1E: 1980-1989 AD&D 2E: 1989-2000 D&D 3E: 2000-about 2004? I don't really remember when I stopped playing 3E, I just drifted away. D&D 4E: 2008-2014 Pathfinder 1E: 2011-present 13th Age: 2013-2016

Honestly, if you armed a fighter with a spear, polearm, or flail, you could get pretty controllery with tripping, slowing, and forced movement.

Yeah, the seeker and runepriest desperately needed more support that they never got. Some of the PHB1 classes were weak as originally created (paladin, star pact warlock, and I'd say wizard), but they eventually got improved through the Power books. As for best pre-Essentials classes, that...

Strength of Thousands is set at a magic school but it's not really Harry Potter -- the PCs are more like grad students than elementary school, and they are expected to become members of the school's faculty after the second adventure. The African-inspired setting is interesting, and there's more...

One of the things I liked most about 4E is that, through feats and powers, they made weapon choice actually matter. Instead of just "this one does d4 piercing, this one does d8 bashing," different weapon types had different applications -- spears and polearms were better for tripping and...

As a 4E fan, I think the biggest problem with Essentials is not the books themselves but how poorly they were marketed. WotC wasn't clear about whether Essentials was meant as a replacement for the original books -- i.e., a "4.5E" -- or whether it was meant as a supplement to the game, and it...

Because after 40+ years of playing D&D and other RPGs, I find magic in most games dull, flavorless, and repetitious. When "magic" means a 100-page list of spells, only a handful of which most players will ever use, I'm going to avoid interacting with that system as much as possible. Also, D&D...

Likewise, ever since 3E I've soured on the idea that everything in the universe with supernatural powers has to express them in terms of the same spell list. Say an angel, a wizard, a dragon sorcerer, a firebending monk, and a fire elemental all cast wall of fire ... and despite the fact they're...

It's not 5E, but there's a 13th Age campaign, Shards of the Broken Sky, that revolves around exploring a crashed flying city.