Search results

  1. Voadam

    TSR Why would anyone want to play 1e?

    When I was running my 1e Temple game the total party number varied widely but was often just a core four PCs. The one NPC they hired in Hommelette, it was solely a setup to get him alone and kill him for the magic that the drow cleric/MU detected on him. They got a +1 dagger out of him.
  2. Voadam

    What are you reading in 2025?

    I wouldn't say that it was because he was expected to be adversarially against their interests, rather that he was expected to be a neutral referee as the players gamed in the world. The ref breaking the rules in making their calls can be an issue.
  3. Voadam

    City-States of Adventure

    For a sword and sorcery vibe there is the OGL 3.0 128 page city state sourcebook Shelzar City of Sins that always seemed to be the Conan style decadent city/city state of the Scarred Lands setting. The various city states of the Scarred Lands each have a very different theme and flavor (paladin...
  4. Voadam

    Would ACKS be a good fit to capture the BECMI-feel?

    I have a bunch of ACKS 1e stuff but I have not really delved into it. My understanding of it is that it is basically B/X rules going for BECMI style stuff so including running domains and war gaming with Conan style sword and sorcery aesthetics. I would expect the rules elements to fully support...
  5. Voadam

    Undead Origins

    Pocket Grimoire Divine 3.0 Crypt Lurker: Neroth's Embrace spell. Shadow Raven: Shadow ravens are undead birds created to serve as familiars and pets. Most are gifts from evil gods or manufactured by necromancers by some unknown ritual. Shadow Raven, Undead Bird, Shadowy Bird: ? Shadow Raven...
  6. Voadam

    TSR Why would anyone want to play 1e?

    I didn’t see them used either in 2e but I had started with 1e and B/X in 81 and never saw them used then either. For my experience it was always about the PCs and not about PCs with their hired help. I think it is another area where experiences vary widely.
  7. Voadam

    Goodman Games: Our Efforts Have Been Mischaracterized

    Everyone from the original kickstarter who is still on kickstarter got an email from Bledsaw through the original kickstarter one alerting them about this. So it should be more than just those who follow GG news. Some may have switched emails and not updated KS or died in the interim or whatever...
  8. Voadam

    Goodman Games: Our Efforts Have Been Mischaracterized

    The original kickstarter was almost 80K I believe, with an unknown number of people already refunded and an unknown number applying for the refund now. so 60K to pay off no more than 80K worth of refunds.
  9. Voadam

    TSR Why would anyone want to play 1e?

    2e had little rules things for more heroic fantasy than 1e did. Death at -10 instead of 0 (1e had the negatives only for if you hit zero exactly and lost one a round until dead at -10) Healing non-weapon proficiency in the core PH for potential faster healing. More xp for fighting monsters...
  10. Voadam

    TSR Why would anyone want to play 1e?

    2e had the same henchmen stuff that I remember
  11. 1749667086314.png

    1749667086314.png

  12. 1749667312067.png

    1749667312067.png

  13. Voadam

    TSR Why would anyone want to play 1e?

    I believe Neonchameleon was more saying that 1e says it is a game for dungeon crawling and has rules that suit dungeon crawling while 2e says it is a game for high adventure but has rules for gritty dungeon crawling that do not suit high adventure. The rules are mostly the same.
  14. Voadam

    Do You Care About Cosmology?

    I really like the 4e world axis cosmology. There is just a couple of pages in the 4e PH and DMG to explain the whole thing and it is super evocative on its own but with cool deeper lore as well in other sources. The World with its own underdark, the Astral Sea above with floating god domains...
  15. Voadam

    Undead Origins

    Pocket Grimoire Arcane 3.0 Crypt Lurker: Neroth's Embrace spell. Shadow Raven: Shadow ravens are undead birds created to serve as familiars and pets. Most are gifts from evil gods or manufactured by necromancers by some unknown ritual. Shadow Raven, Undead Bird, Shadowy Bird: ? Shadow Raven...
  16. Voadam

    Undead Origins

    Plot & Poison 3.0 Undead, Undead Creature: ? Nonliving Creature: ? Undead Item: These follow the verminous item creation rules but use undead. Ghoul, Undead That Feasts on Flesh, Undead Wife: ? Evil Lich: ? Shadow: ? Wraith: Her Fury magic item. Drow: ? Her Fury Her Fury is a +2 keen unholy...
  17. Voadam

    What Media Format Is Your Preferred Campaign Style?

    <Looks at his maps and minis> Well, I would say that depends a little on DM style.
  18. Voadam

    Goodman Games: Our Efforts Have Been Mischaracterized

    The PDF is $130, so $117 with the discount. So about $30 each for four 200 page PDFs.
  19. Voadam

    TSR Why would anyone want to play 1e?

    The races from OD&D and the 1e PH were Tolkien but the classes branched out from the beginning with the cleric (van Helsing/bishop Odo/bible miracles), and then paladin (Anderson), assassin (Lieber), monk (Remo Williams), druid, bard, and illusionist coming from different inspirations.
  20. Voadam

    TSR Why would anyone want to play 1e?

    The long term AD&D campaigns I played in and ran after 2e came out usually used at least some stuff from both editions. Sometimes with a little basic material mixed in as well.
Top