Search results

Bearing in mind what you, or any one person in their community, sees is highly anecdotal and has little or little or no bearing on the whole.

This isn't the same as asking why Yoda and Obi Wan aren't playable out of the box. You can start the game as a force user, but don't pretend the game is somehow deficient because you aren't Mace gawddamned Windu from character creation.

You understand asking this question in the context of "A New Hope" would be like asking your Forgotten Realms DM why you can't play Elminster. Yeah, why can't you play the uber-powerful character that's already mastered the mystic arts of the setting. Maybe that's why they split the party, you...

I may take you up on that.

Really, I backed the Kickstarter. I am really looking forward to it as well... but, that's a bit of an exaggeration. Or you honestly don't have that much experience with RPGs.

Prefer, I prefer brick and mortar. However, the owner of the only LGS in my area is a total dong. Hence, I do most of my purchasing online.

While I can't speak for everyone, these are the reasons I wasn't a fan. To be fair, the story arc thing didn't bother me all that much. It's not that they weren't railroads (they were), but I rarely use published adventures anyway. The character/character creation thing was a serious problem...

Sure, nothing wrong with what you're proposing. I personally feel they shouldn't be in the core at all, but there's no reason it shouldn't be on one of the "Dials".

I don't disagree, but I don't see anything wrong with an option to add it for people who want it.

4e PHB Page 15, thumbnail titled: Attack Powers and Utility Powers. ... Daily Powers are so dramatic and powerful that you can use each only once per day. 4E PHB Page 54 A daily power can be used once a day. So a second wind, that can be used more than once a day is... Regardless of the...

Book says once per encounter, making it... In the cases where it's a power with a special set of situations there's a (special) to denote it. Again, regardless of the tied resource it's an encounter power, and again, not what I want in the new edition.

Neither fella, those are spell slots. But again, you're the smartest, most hansom man to ever throw dice. None of that changes the way I voted. One second wind a day. However, please continue with this semantic argument. I find your attempts to convince me endlessly entertaining.

I know, you're the rightest guy I know. And only you truly understand all that is D&D. I bow to your superior knowledge of what I think would be acceptable in the upcoming version, and the realities of 4e. A billion pardons master. Dope, all that said, I can go back to knowing second wind is an...

Not tired of pretending yet, OK, have fun with that.

Your argument is grasping. If you have the option to do it more than once daily, it ceases to be a daily (with the exception of very few examples). The ridiculous manner in which you're attempting to frame this discussion would mean everything in 4e is a daily. Yeah, at-wills, yeah their a...

Well, yes and no. In 4e second winds are per encounter. Being a big fan of 4e, there was too much access to healing for me. Star Wars Saga had the "second wind" as a "Daily" and in my opinion that was the sweet spot for the self-heal.

I say optional, and even then only daily.

Get both, they're both fun!

In the most recent Rule of Three, someone suggested using a similar mechanic to expertise dice for spellcaster's metamagic feats. Rodney... kind of said... no. But, I don't know. I wouldn't suggest the (say) wizard class having the expertise dice built into the class as a feature. I...

Interesting, I'll certainly look into it.