Search results

you can argue that all you want. If I am going to spend time and money to find new systems it will not be a D&D like one.

I would love an opt in (through subclass or something) metacurrency, and martials that grow to mythic levels as at least close to a caster. As for the nerf to spells, I would take some clues from 2e here... like haste ages you ext...

you know how you attract people to your cause... you talk about it (here, tick toc, facebook, game stores, cons) so if I get the two guys that run games that talk about mechanics (the one that ran the spell jammer WotC game and the one that runs the CR game) to talk about caster supremacy and...

I regularly see newbies go for warlock and sorcerer and even barbarian over figher TBH

one of the things I played around with in my fantasy best D&D ideal system was combat feats and not combat talents that you could not switch...

I will not "go sit over there and shut up" and yes I knwo that isn't exactly what your wrote, but it ends the same. we got 4e when 3.5 had people so annoyed at caster supremacy that everyone was speaking out. We now have many new players to get to win over... once we do we can tell wotc we...

this is why I want a class (we can call it fighter) based off the champion fighter but ALSO a more complex warrior class (call it warblade, or warlord, or swordsage, or animeswordguy) and as long as we are spliting the class give us a half caster magus/swordmage/bladesinger/eldtrichknight

I think 6e should do all three...

TBH jack Vance novels would be more arcane tricksters or eldritch knights with 1/2 caster instead of 1/3 and getting spell prep, int mod plus 1/2 level preped and 1 slot per level (maybe at high level like 12+ get a 2nd 1st level slot)

I think having a pool of martial exploits that work for those pillars is better, things that let you do things other then damage.

you are incorrect not if one person says it hear and nowhere else... then you most likely have a point. However if enough of us are vocal here, on facebook, on tic tok, on twitter at game stores and at cons... we get to shape the discusions. listen to the last few videos and you will see...

the warlock's high arcana proves your point... it is a much smaller list then ANY other caster picks from and you only ever get 1/day per spell... here is a GREAT playtest... make a 17th level wizard for prof, skills, and hd/hp give them ONLY 2/day 5th level slots, and 1 spell known from each...

I hope by reposing this we can get back to the topic... but I bet I will see 5-9 argueing about if the fighter needs a fix and 1 or 2 more suggesting that nothing we say matters to MAYBE 1 about the topic of the thread,,,

no it isn't as long as all three are forced into only subclass of a single class we do not have what I suggested, 3 separate classes correct, and if you go back to my example build I didn't take sharp shooter or GWM I took lucky and two feats that give misc abailities... so I totally see what...

how cheery.... because we disagre on a game I am doomed. cause wotc never listens or redoes concepts... I don't get this, I am only not getting what I want if I stop pushing for it... as long as I push sooner or later just like at the end of 3.5 they will come through that I why I suggest...

I say all the time that we need to break up the fighter but I think we need to break up wizard too. Have beguiler class a necromancer class a sage class and a warmage class... have 1 list that overlaps all of them and 5ish spells per level that are only on 1 or maybe shared by two of those...

I agree in theory but (I think they call it asperating) teleporting is like a high school class... it's an owl thing and several character do it... but it must have limits but other then the school being warded against it we don't know what those limits are. If I were a wizard I would night...

I can run tiamat against most of my parties by level 12, and some as low at 7. Especially with melee focused high hp spellcasters

so if we rarely see combat done that way you understand the divide between player skill and character skill. again split up the martial roles more so those smart players can choose to be martial OR caster... yes... more options = better.... instead of "all teh experienced people that know how...

liek I said, close enough