Search results

There are always reasons. I am saying that however compelling those reasons may be, I find the end result to be shallow and counterproductive to its stated purpose, which is purportedly to encourage a broader array of mixed ancestry characters within the game. It does nothing for "pure...

And I want to be able to express my characters through both. That option, as it applies to mixed ancestry characters, is seemingly being taken away from me - or at the very least, moved squarely into the realm of third party and homebrew.

At the cost of disincentivizing mixed ancestry characters for everyone who cares about their mechanics, whether they're hardcore optimizers or not.

It is always going to be a field for rules optimization. That's the point I'm trying to get at. Trying to reign in optimizers is a fool's errand. Even with the proposed "pick-a-parent" system, optimizers will identify which species statblock is "superior" for a given optimization purpose and...

How is saying that your mixed-ancestry character can either be 100% parent A or 100% parent B - with no options in between - not "turning blood quantum"? Optimizers are going to optimize regardless of what rules character ancestry adheres to. The only way to make them stop would be to eliminate...

For context:

The first two are part of Ysgard, with Jotenheim being a realm within the first layer and Muspelheim being the plane's second layer. Niflheim is the second layer of the Gray Wastes (of Hades).

With the caveat that I am nowhere near enough of a Dragonlance lore expert to truly know how disruptive of a change this would be, I like the idea of the three robe colors as indicators of philosophical outlook (possibly reflected in the teachings of the each of the three magic moon gods)...

Honestly, from a worldbuilding perspective, I think both the Dragonlance High Sorcery white/red/black robe classifications and the Star Wars Light Side/Dark Side divide would benefit greatly from being decoupled from the Good-Evil spectrum.

Aasimar, Soul Knife, and Psy Warrior have all been through rounds of UA before and published in previous books - their popularity is established. The question is "Do these options have support?", and they already know the answer is "Yes", so the need for additional playtest feedback is...

Oh, I certainly don't expect them to be sneakily slipped into the PHB under a new name - they didn't even ask about "half-elves", "half-orcs", or the "pick-a-parent" system in the UA survey. At best, they might make it into the DMG as examples of how to use a (hypothetical) species trait...

So far as I am aware, the only time they've said anything on the subject is when they were doing videos for the first UA packet on character origins, where they introduced the "pick-a-parent" system to cover all mixed-ancestry characters and stated "half-elves" and "half-orcs" would not be...

I do not claim to do so. If I have ever given the impression that I think I do, then I wholeheartedly apologize. The proposed "pick-a-parent" system works for you. Great! By all means, use it. I have no issue with WotC keeping it in as an option, even the default option. What I take issue with...

My concerns have nothing to do with how things work at my specific table. I can handle that just fine, with or without WotC. My concerns are the worldbuilding implications that "pick-a-parent" creates (What happens to Khoravar, Jhor'guntaal, and the three mixed Dragonmarked Houses the next time...

"Our setting has three moons... What possible use would we have for the most iconic monster tied to the lunar cycle?" - Weiss and Hickman, probably

Which is fine, considering that they can now just play orcs. That cannot be said for people who want to be able to keep playing "half-orcs" as their own thing.

There are people who would like to see updated versions of old settings, just as there are people who want to see new settings. These can even be the same people.

Sure, but that applies to anything. You can swap out Vecna or the Rod of Seven Parts, if you're willing to rewrite the entire book.

I mean, the villain's actions don't make much sense if they aren't...