Search results

  1. Mistwell

    D&D 5E (2024) [HOMEBREW] Ranger Ideas +

    I think there is a solution for the Ranger Hunter's Mark that doesn't require changing the Ranger class itself. Major Hunter's Mark Does the same thing as Hunter's Mark, but is a level 3 spell [so comes online at level 9], has no concentration, and gives you a choice of an add-on for when you...
  2. Mistwell

    Dungeons & Dragons Announces Horror Subclasses Unearthed Arcana

    So disappointed there is no Wizard (Necromancer) subclass announced for this. Wizard had, I think, the most number of subclasses removed between the 2014 and 2024 PHB, and when given the opportunity to finally put one of them back in they put two Warlock subclasses in instead, AND an Artificer...
  3. Mistwell

    D&D General When We Were Wizards: Review of the Completed Podcast!

    I am characterizing Williams as an unethical businessperson during that brief window when she effectively took over the company (and for a few other decisions well after all this which hasn't been discussed in this thread). I am characterizing Gary Gygax as both an unethical businessperson and...
  4. Mistwell

    D&D General When We Were Wizards: Review of the Completed Podcast!

    That's not what I wrote on that part of the topic however. I wrote extensively why my view isn't based on the inchoate dislike towards her, isn't based on rumor over years, but is based directly on specific events in the podcast where she does bad things. I then also wrote about alternatives...
  5. Mistwell

    D&D General When We Were Wizards: Review of the Completed Podcast!

    I said repeatedly I think gary is worse. You repeatedly quoted posts of mine where in those posts I say I think Gary is worse. I then directly wrote to you saying that comparing Williams to Gary isn't the point, that Gary was worse relative to Williams but the standard for being "good" isn't...
  6. 555a5a92-3497-4f5a-add6-357434d94cd8.png

    555a5a92-3497-4f5a-add6-357434d94cd8.png

  7. Mistwell

    D&D General The First Demise of TSR: Gygax's Folly

    Here is the link from the first post. That's what triggered Snarf to make this thread. Note the comment I was replying to. If Snarf is accepting of criticism of Williams, I have yet to see it. Every response I've ever seen from him on the topic is either dismissive, or worse.
  8. Mistwell

    D&D 5E (2024) Bonus action minor illusion (wizard illusionist 3rd level ability) creating cover and halflings

    If you make an object which you're moving out from, attacking, and then ducking back behind, you shouldn't face the issue of the illusion being exposed from return fire. If they can't see you, they can't target you well nor see if you're hit or not. They're not going to try and shoot through a...
  9. Mistwell

    D&D General The First Demise of TSR: Gygax's Folly

    Fair point and thanks for asking. Been a rough few weeks. Getting better but yes, short fuse lately. Sorry about that. Will endeavor to lighten the tone.
  10. Mistwell

    D&D General The First Demise of TSR: Gygax's Folly

    I am not in any way asking him to hate Williams. I pointed out in the other thread some serious failings of Williams with direct reasons. Snarf then quoted that post by linking to it, then ranted about Revisionist History and how people get stuck thinking something based on rumored conventional...
  11. Mistwell

    D&D General The First Demise of TSR: Gygax's Folly

    Because the post you linked to of mine, without direct reference, was about the podcast. Which you knew, because you had just linked to it without replying to it to start this thread, remember? Saying "see the record" without linking to the record or referencing a specific part of it isn't a...
  12. Mistwell

    D&D 5E (2014) To Be or Not to Be: Legendary

    I agree non-legendary creatures can absolutely be a solo threat to a party. It's more difficult to pull off but it can be done and your example is a good one. I'd say flight, or some other meaningful distance or barrier between the party and the foe, is pretty important to pull this off. The...
  13. Mistwell

    D&D General The First Demise of TSR: Gygax's Folly

    You mistook my saying you stated falsehoods with my calling you a liar. I don't think you're a liar. I think you believe falsehoods because of the extreme bias I mentioned which you have in favor of Williams. Which I found ironic given your essay on Revisionist History, and your unwillingness to...
  14. Mistwell

    D&D General The First Demise of TSR: Gygax's Folly

    You state several falsehoods in your rendition. 100% provable falsehoods. For example, you state the only person surprised by Gary's ouster is Gary. However, we can all hear directly from many people there at the time they were all surprised. We know this. We're certain. There is no doubt at all...
  15. Mistwell

    D&D General When We Were Wizards: Review of the Completed Podcast!

    None of them could imagine it. Rose Estes, who isn't a bit fan of Gary at the time, was stunned. Everyone was stunned. Gary didn't even know it was Williams behind it when it was happening.
  16. Mistwell

    D&D General When We Were Wizards: Review of the Completed Podcast!

    There are much more ethical means to accomplish those goals. She chose unethical ones because they were shortcuts and it left her in charge rather than someone they could all agree on together in arbitration or with a mediator or with the bank holders. I think people are finding excuses to...
  17. Mistwell

    D&D General When We Were Wizards: Review of the Completed Podcast!

    Agreed. He was behaving awful. This does not make me think Williams was not also behaving awful. She was behaving "better" than Gary, but that's not the standard. Everything she did in that week was deeply weasel-like and nasty. There were much better and more honest ways to attempt to obtain...
  18. Mistwell

    California bill (AB 412) would effectively ban open-source generative AI

    Where a company incorporated is irrelevant for this topic. That's purely a tax issue, not a regulation issue. Same with data centers (which are copied across the globe including in California for load balancing) or training, all irrelevant. Where the humans doing the work are located is all that...
  19. Mistwell

    Spoilers THUNDERBOLTS* (spoilers I guess?)

    Again, it has an asterisk i the title with (spoilers I guess?) Can we please stop gaslighting with what's written in the thread title? What does "I guess?" mean to you?
  20. Mistwell

    California bill (AB 412) would effectively ban open-source generative AI

    If you regulate it in California, where most of the AI companies are based, 1/7th of the nations GDP, and 1/8th of the population, that generally is enough to force the issue. They're not going to run one version for California and another for the rest of the nation, and other states and often...
Top