Search results

So, a creator or publisher who CHOOSES not to use a word that some folks find offensive is a poor solution? It's actually more hurtful, or is a radicalization? That's some impressive mental gymnastics there. There's plenty of explanation of why each word is problematic and no longer used in...

Oh for sure, that was the intent. Still remains a highly problematic work.

Oh, for sure the book title "Oriental Adventures" was problematic when it was first published in 1985 and then again in 2001. I would find it kinda humorous if WotC did publish an "Occidental Adventures" book at some point.

I think Chris Pramas (the Dragon Fist designer) at some point released a revision moving Dragon Fist more firmly into 3E territory . . . or maybe it moved it further way . . . it's been a while . . .

Well, kinda. It's more occidental vs oriental . . . but practically, amounts to the same thing. Othering the non-Western world as "exotic".

So, some folks think these issues matter, but they don't? Because you don't think they matter? Or, rather than sincerity, it's fashionable to be more inclusive?

Sigh. So . . . not all Asian folks find the use of the word "oriental" problematic, but many do. So, it's not problematic? Do ALL Asians need to find the word problematic for it to be so? And we're back to not all Jewish folks find the use of phylactery in D&D problematic, only some. So it's...

Dragon Fist was released in between editions but is very D&D adjacent, essentially a hybrid of 2E and 3E mechanics. Nothing really from Alternity.

You realize that almost every word that is considered inappropriate, rude, problematic, or offensive started out with "no pejorative meaning", right? Words gain pejorative (or problematic) meaning over time as one group uses them against another. Like "oriental", for example.

Now we are moving on from litigating "phylactery" and re-litigating "oriental"? Okay. Thank you WotC, for removing the words "phylactery" and "oriental" from your products.

Go big or go home I guess. :D

That reminds me, I really need to get started on a Rick & Morty inspired D&D game, I hope my group goes for it!

Lore-neutered? Okay. Welcome to ENWorld I guess.

I'm not sure I get you here . . . the micro-settings in Radiant Citadel do not appear in other products.

How is that related to @FitzTheRuke's point?

Kinda missing the point by being pedantic, are we? Which edition had more settings, 2E or 5E, depends on how you count . . . but the actual point still stands. 5E has published a lot of settings and it hasn't killed the game. The "common wisdom" that too many settings killed 2E is false, it was...

So sorry you are tired. So sorry WotC and other companies have listened to folks and removed problematic terms and concepts. You suspect Jewish and non-Jewish folks who are offended (severely or mildly) are outliers. Suspect. Okay. I'm tired too. Of folks pushing back against reasonable...

Does there need to be consistency? For a while we had a degree of consistency, since most of the OSR and other fantasy heartbreakers borrowed so heavily from D&D. But if different games are using different words for a lich's soul box or to describe a character's ancestry, is that a problem? I...

Are you Jewish? If so, do you represent all Jewish people? If you personally do not find the use of phylactery offensive, then no Jewish people do? Or since not all Jewish people do, it doesn't matter? Multiple entertainment companies producing fantasy media and games HAVE listened and HAVE...

If they are writing/designing/world-building FOR WotC, why should they retain any rights? If, as a creator, you want to retain the rights to your work (which is reasonable) don't do work-for-hire.