Search results

  1. PeelSeel2

    Design Leadership from 1st to 2nd to 3rd to 4th

    I think it is good that we have veteran leadership at the helm of D&D at a time of great change. When I first heard the news about 4th, I was very apprehensive. If they just evolved the game like what happened between 1E & 2E, and 3e & 3.5e, then it would not be worth it. Having kept up on...
  2. PeelSeel2

    Are stat modifiers really bonus + 1/2 per level?

    I think you are dead-on with that point.
  3. PeelSeel2

    D&D 4E 4E Rogue for non-4E enthusiast

    Agreed. Don't know where he is coming from.
  4. PeelSeel2

    I need a Gnome!

    Huh? I think your post is in error. No one has actually played a Gnome.
  5. PeelSeel2

    Dungeons of Dread Preview 4

    Awesome previews. I can see making a 'wormling' Balhannoth of about 4-5 level to challenge a low level party. Awesome, awesome!! That could be an encounter to remember. I have always liked putting demons into my campaign, and now they seem complete: Easy to run, fun, and challenging!!
  6. PeelSeel2

    Cubicle whiteboard: Book titles we'll never [use]

    That is best. Some secrets are best left secret. Unless they involve sex, drugs or/and rock.
  7. PeelSeel2

    D&D 4E Going/Not Going to 4E which edition did you start with?

    Started with Modlvay and 1e, some 2e and rules encyclopedia, then 3.5e after it came out. I am switching to 4th because of the monster and DM'ing prep time. Plus they are apparently K.I.S.S.ing the new rules (keep it simple stupid). I like their design goals, their distillation of the generic...
  8. PeelSeel2

    We Used the new death and dying rules and it saved our ninja

    Blah Blah Blah. That is an opinion. The new rules add tension, hope, uncertainty, and dice rolls into a moment. All things which gamers love. And it keeps it simple.
  9. PeelSeel2

    D&D 4E What will your first 4E campaign look like?

    First thing we are going to do is roll-up my players Epic level characters as 4e incarnations. We stopped a 3 year + campaign because playing and DM'ing a campaign that was in the epic levels was about as fun as blowing your brains out. We are going to give it whirl at the epic levels. I had...
  10. PeelSeel2

    A worry about "special case monster abilities"

    I like the idea. You can tailor a monster to fit your vision of the part it is supposed to play in your story line. Who cares if other monsters do not have it!! It also keeps the characters guessing and on their feet. This is a welcomed change from the rigidity of the 3.x mosters...
  11. PeelSeel2

    Will you try the new "Death & Dying" rules now?

    This is a good clean rule. We have been playing with -con for ever, this extends it a bit, but add's a high level of uncertainty to it too. Your character can go negative a lot more hit points, but once he/she he reaches 0 or below, he/she is unconcious and dying, having to make a roll every...
  12. PeelSeel2

    D&D 4E 4e Heal info in new Confessions article

    If you do not like the extra healing, get rid of it. Make a 'grittier' 4e. I will play 4e as-is for a while, and then decide on personal changes. I do not like the idea of second wind. I didn't like it in Star Wars, I do not like it in 4e. I will play it, however, and then form a basis in...
  13. PeelSeel2

    Fluff vs Crunch

    I agree with what the one poster said. Anyone want to buy a boat?
  14. PeelSeel2

    Detect magic

    Does a silver dragon in alternate form or Doppleganger that is changed have an aura that can be seen with detect magic? I would rule no, because it is a supernatural ability. The magic aura of transformation fades after the change in form. Does detect magic allow invisible creatures to be...
  15. PeelSeel2

    Remember when ...

    What a brilliant idea!! They could fuse that with their online system, put cards out for classes, items, monsters, etc. You can't play them until you actually get the card and activate it online! They wouldn't need to put out the PHB, DMG, or MM. Just come out with 'collectible' cards...
  16. PeelSeel2

    DM thanks

    Last year they tried thanking me with a car bomb. This year it was uranium poisoning.
  17. PeelSeel2

    Burning a Web spell

    In real life, just where you burn it.
  18. PeelSeel2

    Keep on the Borderlands - your experiences?

    I have had this module since 1982. Never played through it or ran it until last year. I always wanted to. I have read this module more times than I can count. Always with nostalgia. In the last year and half I have went through and found all the modules I loved and read but never DM'ed or...
  19. PeelSeel2

    Running the Tomb of Horrors in 3.5

    I would rule that you cannot take 20 on searching for anything. The act of taking 20 implies failures. Failures, with search checks, have a negative consequence. Failure on a search check means that character fails to notice/find something, which is detrimental. If it is not finding the...
  20. PeelSeel2

    UA Action Points - what happens to unused points?

    Nothing in the Rules compendium.
Top