Search results

  1. Melan

    (Poll, please read 1st post) What does the DM have the right to restrict?

    Thanks for making the thread, Calithena. I was really surprised by the poll results - could a myth about current D&D players have been dispelled, or is it due to sample bias?
  2. Melan

    Thieves Guild aka The Fantasy System

    I have little of note to add, except that the main illustrator of the early releases, Janet Trautvetter, drew some really-hot-in-a-plain-Jane-sense women. Realistically equipped in chain mail, even. I wish more artists did this today. That's all. :D
  3. Melan

    What are the characteristics of an "olde school game"?

    Awesome! A significant point. On the other hand, I would agree that early 1e and OD&D had its own analogy of ecology, which I call thematic appropriateness. This means that instead of encounters making strict biological, social, etc. sense, they make sense in the context of a "dream-world" or...
  4. Melan

    Dragon Appreciation: Which are your favorite Dragon comic series?

    Now that`s WRONG. Still, funny as hell. :D None whatsoever. Thank Zeus.
  5. Melan

    Dragon Appreciation: Which are your favorite Dragon comic series?

    Finieous Fingers and Zogonia are the best (esp. counting Mount Zogon), but Phil&Dixie was also nifty.
  6. Melan

    Undermountain maps - yeck!!

    Now isn't that quaint. Take that, Ed Bourelle! :\
  7. Melan

    Worldwide Adventure Writing Month

    Heh, and if I finish my entry in time, that will be some major weird stuff. Weird on the level of Arduin or those early Judges Guild modules. :D (Started this morning, typed in seven pages so far, finished playtesting yesterday, most of the illustration booklet is done, things are starting to...
  8. Melan

    Tarts, Trollops and Vampires: Random Encounters in the City

    My favourite city encounter system is Judges Guild's charts in City State of the Invincible Overlord. It is reasonably easy to use, but has enough subtables and attendant tables (e.g. "Questioned by Guards or Constables" or "Craftsman Profession") to provide a lot of variety. In the City State...
  9. Melan

    Does D&D even have a component of "midieval" anymore?

    All in all, D&D is as mediaeval (and has been since the Original D&D booklets) as it is Tolkienesque. Very thinly on the surface. BTW, T. Foster, those are good examples, but none of it makes D&D mediaeval. What would make it mediaeval would be a focus on feudal systems, PCs behaving as parts...
  10. Melan

    Does D&D even have a component of "midieval" anymore?

    Have I got a game for you! I give you... Advunced Peasants and Crapmongers (by our friends at Totalitarian Scum Regime Games) :D
  11. Melan

    Does D&D even have a component of "midieval" anymore?

    Very good commentary. To tell the truth, not even the fantasy literature that served as D&D's inspiration was very mediaeval. Conan wasn't a mediaeval personality, and Ffahrd and the Grey Mouser (D&D-style adventurers if there ever was one!) were essentially modern people in a world with a thin...
  12. Melan

    New OSRIC/AD&D 1e Modules & Supplements

    Pod-caverns of the Sinister Shroom and Red Mausoleum from Expeditious Retreat Press are very highly recommended. The first, in particular, is the best designed new adventure module I have seen since Necromancer's Tomb of Abysthor, and all that in just 16 pages. The modules by Rob Kuntz (Pied...
  13. Melan

    You know what I hate?

    Cool! Thanks!
  14. Melan

    You know what I hate?

    Empire of the Petal Throne? Now this is becoming very interesting. Would you have any more information on the subject, Faraer?
  15. Melan

    You know what I hate?

    Undermountain taught me more about improvisation than any other single product. Running it was messy, it was chaotic, and my players loved it.
  16. Melan

    D&D 4E Palladium's philosophy for D&D 4e? Pros and cons

    That sort of immature antagonism is something typically found in immature individuals. Not discounting your poor personal experiences, I would not play with these people in a more codified game, or in fact any game. If a basic level of trust and maturity is missing, any social association is...
  17. Melan

    D&D 4E Palladium's philosophy for D&D 4e? Pros and cons

    Or he just has a different idea about the same. :cool:
  18. Melan

    D&D 4E Palladium's philosophy for D&D 4e? Pros and cons

    Just mix together vanilla, chocolate, and about thirteen or fourteen other flavours. Pour on a glass of vodka, and a generous spoonful of tabasco sauce. Voila, RIFTS Ice Cream(R)(TM)!
  19. Melan

    Tegel Manor Rides Again!

    Be careful with the gazebo. It bites. ;)
Top