Search results

Ahhhh, napalm! My answer to this question was an uncertain yes. Why? I doubt my point of view is going to be popular, but here goes. (Remember that I'm not a MBA, or anything.) It seems WotC (and thus Hasbro) might make more bang for their buck if they followed what seems to be Hasbro policy...

Ooops... Dang! I meant Shadeus! I think I'm getting punchy from looking at the screen too long! "Fine lame" isn't so good because of what those words can be taken for in English. Think about it ... "fine" and "lame". I'm glad you both have experience in fencing. BTW, I wasn't talking about...

Cool, but... Escrima is actually a Filipino word (not English), which is derived from the Spanish "esgrima" (fencing). It's not just stick fighting either, it's a school of martial arts. As an aside, I'm glad PA and Rauvel have stuff in common, but please don't get into discussions of fencing...

Quick take! Does that mean we can use the True King in the book? I'm hoping we get hosted here and/or FFG's site. d20 Dwarf hasn't been around here for a while, so we'll see. I'll let you know as soon as I do. Paul, thanks for the deity's weapon update. Thanks to PA for the accent symbol...

Reddist! Reddist, Can you give me an opinion on keeping the druid spells and school restricitons in the guardian? Or do you favor the old power full stop? Thanks! :D

More Broken Wake! [/b]Actually it's worse and better than you state. The fact of the matter is, most creatures don't have huge Fortitude save totals. The average is well below 10, until you start including 'high-end" critters like giants, dragons, and powerful extraplanar entities. The...

Death! Improved Death Attack is not OGC, but referring to it shouldn't be a problem. All of the Epic stuff is probably going to be in the SRD eventually. We could take the samurai approach and be bold, changing the reference only if someone says to. If we think it shouldn’t be done, then we can...

Art! As an artist and pro graphic designer, I'd like to add a bit to the discussion. First of all, it was good that the Graphic Artists Guild Handbook: Pricing and Ethical Guidelines was mentioned here. Unfortunately, unless you do artwork for WotC, you'll never see the rates that appear in...

Uh... I never had any problems with the issue you refer to. Of course, I photocopy everything I need out of the module I'm using, including the maps. I'd recommend this, even over a detachable book section, just because you can make notes on the photocopies without messing up a book. You can...

MDK Fine, it works for me. I didn't mean for the power to be invoked. The wording of the power, even though it's a supernatural ability (normally a standard action to use), suggests to me that the deathblow is a potential any time the hero rolls two threats ("with any melee attack that is...

Re: Maitre additional quest: Scene 1, take 2... What are the consequences of losing the duel in the quest? Must it then be repeated (90 more days studying the same or differing style)? Perhaps the maitre should spend time on several different styles (at least three). Those styles need not be...

Warrior of the Broken Wake comments... Good idea! How about, a successful reversal allows just a disarm attempt? Or is that putting the poor sod on the receiving end at too much of a disadvantage? I've seen a very tough paladin with a "burst" magic hammer and smite added in do almost forty...

I should have said that odd numbers are given value by using them as requirements; that's why you see feats with requirements of odd-numbered stats. It's your call on the Int requirement, but Int is how well a character learns and reasons. It also directly influences the Craft skill. I'd say at...

New maitre quest Rauvel, you're on the right track. This is a good idea, but one that only makes sense if Knowledge (tactics) or some such thing is required by the LgC. (Many "official" prestige classes overlook this very thing.) Perhaps the quest should include traveling the world and besting...

Nice redos! Redcliff, I need your real name (if I should already have it, sorry). Nice work on the edits. You left me a little work to do, but that's okay. [/b]I understand and your class is polishing up nicely. There's a problem, however. A monk at 1st-level has a base reflex save of +2. If...

DOH! Dang! I liked the new version (with the druid additions). I actually like it better than the old power, because it makes more sense and actually creates the type of situation I envisioned, without stepping on other powers. As the original was written, for example, a Sor1/Rgr12/Guardian 5...

Ladglasmar About Ladglasmar ... I'm still working on him, but I wanted anyone who's looking at the class to focus on the class itself. What did you think about my redo of the "One With the Land" Ability? :D

Finished round 1.5 I really like the way you've written these powers and the +1 to the attacks isn't a big deal. This class is great and you've done a wonderful job refining your writing. So has everyone I've seen so far. (You know who you are.) If there were anything to which I'd object, I...

More stuff.... I think I'm alone now, but just in case I'm not More editing points: Eliminate columns. Please use the "Game Rule Information" format from the PHB for the layout of class info. That is, the headings: Class Skills (without the space-wasting PHB Chapter 4 reference), Class...

More stuff.... Where is everyone? It's as if the whole gaming world were holding its breath! Two edits: Maitre d'Escrime Brawler Thanks! :D