Search results

  1. IanB

    Was Paladin a Paladin?

    Clearly he's an unaligned paladin.
  2. IanB

    Comments and dislikes of lore and other changes in the 4th ed MM.

    The beholder aura functions the way it does because the beholder is a solo monster. Solo monsters generally have to have things they do on other people's turns, in order to make them more interesting and challenging to fight.
  3. IanB

    Warlord - Inspiring Word/Aid the Injured

    To be clear, the warlord version does expend a surge; that is why it is an encounter power while the cleric version is a daily.
  4. IanB

    Warlord - Inspiring Word/Aid the Injured

    Aid the Injured is a power, Inspiring Word is a class feature. You can't really directly make a level/power comparison between the two. Also note that Aid the Injured is a decently valuable utility power for someone multiclassing to warlord to take as an option, and will be more valuable than...
  5. IanB

    Dungeon Adventure: Heathen

    I love the delve format personally, it is basically how I set up my own encounters too.
  6. IanB

    4E is for casuals, D&D is d0med

    I think this is changing and is a big part of why the half-orc got the boot - and I'm all for it. Nearly every group I've played with since about '96 or so has included one or more women and there has been fairly universal eye-rolling or worse about the sexism that has been inherent (if not...
  7. IanB

    Why do I complain about 4E?

    Yeah, there is no 4e general forum, but that doesn't appear to have stopped people filling up the rules forum with non-rules issues. The sooner the rules forum gets back to Mistwell arguing with Hypersmurf, the more right the universe will feel.
  8. IanB

    Whatever happened to social combat?

    If I had to hazard a guess, they couldn't simplify it down enough for the core 4e philosophy of not overcomplicating things. I wouldn't be surprised to see it appear in something like a DMG 2 though.
  9. IanB

    I got BUSTED!

    Other things one probably shouldn't announce to people (like say on a public message board?) include one's downloading of illegal copies of copyrighted material.
  10. IanB

    The Star Pact Handicap

    My feeling is that 4e magic items are designed such that you would never see a weapon with a passive +2 Will defense bonus (at least hopefully, otherwise we'll be back to Christmas tree time.) Implements fill the "weapon" role for classes that use them and I figure they should basically be...
  11. IanB

    The Star Pact Handicap

    Putting my DM hat on for a moment, I don't think I'd allow those to stack, any more than I'd allow a ranger to apply his off hand weapon's daily power to an attack made with the main hand weapon. There's not a terribly strong RAW argument for not letting them stack, but I get the feeling we're...
  12. IanB

    Why do I complain about 4E?

    Actually because of various work issues and scheduling collisions, I've barely been playing DDM myself - won't be making the qualifier this weekend, etc. Unfortunately I probably won't be at GenCon this year for various reasons. I think a lot of the local (and probably national) disillusionment...
  13. IanB

    So, then, what is D&D?

    D&D is rolling dice and killing kobolds.
  14. IanB

    Why do I complain about 4E?

    I can understand why Jeff wants/needs to proselytize for 3.5/Pathfinder (hi Jeff!) Let's say one of his current players moves away, and he needs someone else for his Saturday game. He calls me up and says, "Hey Ian, haven't seen you for a while since I dropped DDM, but we're looking for another...
  15. IanB

    Artificer role speculation

    I'd say leader too, but I would not at all be surprised if the sorcerer ended up with a primal or elemental power source instead.
  16. IanB

    Steak anyone? I hear it's divine.

    I would remove the removal of text descriptions of all the monsters in the MM. ...OK maybe that isn't a dynamic.
  17. IanB

    Ray of Frost and Cloud of Daggers; Red Headed Stepchildren of Wizard At-Wills?

    I find it sort of odd that the cloud of daggers aftereffect isn't considered a Zone, which means you can't dispel it, etc.
  18. IanB

    D&D 4E 4e, Non-Martial Characters, and Limited Feat Choices

    What seems to be the real central issue here, and what this thread has so far mostly danced around, is that there is a big difference between what a feat is now, and what it was in 3.x. Feats are very minor boosts now and are intended to be that way. No longer are feats the central feature that...
  19. IanB

    Paper Minions - WT?

    So, can someone explain to me why it is a bad thing for players to know which ones are the minions? I think that's the concept I'm just not getting here. The game seems specifically designed to encourage players to use anti-minion abilities against minions, so how is it metagaming when they do?
Top