Search results

  1. The Shaman

    WotC to Release 1st Edition Premium Core Rulebooks Reprints

    Classy. Good on you, Whizbros.
  2. The Shaman

    Which D&D worlds have Sci Fi Space Ships?

    The Wilderlands. And every homebrew I ever ran.
  3. The Shaman

    "Gamism," The Forge, and the Elephant in the Room

    I think this goes back to some degree to the notion of transparency, of the rules and the adjudication. While I tend to swim in the rulings-not-rules end of the pool, in my experience the games that facilitate that approach offer relatively concise, clear rules from which the referee can...
  4. The Shaman

    "Gamism," The Forge, and the Elephant in the Room

    Getting a stun is good - it costs your opponent any remaining actions in the round, and denies them a long action and allows them only one normal action in the next round. But a stunned character isn't helpless. He can move, parry, dodge, back away, or attack and rely on a reaction parry (a...
  5. The Shaman

    "Gamism," The Forge, and the Elephant in the Room

    In my experience, Mr Edwards' "bitterest roleplayer" tends to be the guy who shifts pretty readily between thinking in- and out-of-character, engaging both the rules and the game-world. In that sense they're among my favorite players to have in a game. Combat in FB is very gamist, but it's...
  6. The Shaman

    "Gamism," The Forge, and the Elephant in the Room

    Thank you for saving me the trouble of crafting a reply. :)
  7. The Shaman

    Help me find an online game-running aid

    I have an Obsidian Portal wiki fo my Flashing Blades campaign and I'm very, very happy with it. The ability to hyperlink everything together, connecting people, places, organizations, and events, is a big help for me in running a sandbox setting. I can tell at a glance who an npc's friends and...
  8. The Shaman

    Bear psychology question

    Not necessarily, as Nagol points out. Bear Attacks: Their Causes and Avoidance. Speaking as a former park ranger who worked on black bear management in a national park, these are spot on.
  9. The Shaman

    Dungeon graffiti

    My caves tend to be filled with petroglyphs and pictographs, none more so than the witch doctor's cave - those pictures painted on the walls or scratched in the varnish are their spell books. Graffiti get scrawled or (less frequently) chiseled into stone walls, particularly in prisoners' cells...
  10. The Shaman

    Dungeon graffiti

    "I'm a meteor swarm layin' mother-:):):):)er, mother :):):):)er!"
  11. The Shaman

    Things to Talk To in the Dungeon

    I'm told by players past that one of my more memorable encounters was a pair of goblins, one of whom pissed himself and fainted immediately on seeing the adventurers while the other ran away, straight into a trapped door, and died. Once they roused the fainted goblin, he became their window...
  12. The Shaman

    Take a trip down memory lane

    It's times like this I really miss the XP button.
  13. The Shaman

    Time for WotC to start officially supporting older editions?

    The OSR's got this covered already. Yes, please. DDI could be the real umbrella under which disparate gamers cluster, not another edition.
  14. The Shaman

    Why the love for the Edition Treadmill?

    The grass is always greener in someone else's hydroponic garden. I do find the whole thing terribly funny, though. With all of the different vesions of D&D out there - OD&D, Holmes D&D, 1e AD&D, Moldvay D&D, Mentzer BECMI D&D, 2e AD&D, 3e D&D, 3.5e D&D, 4e D&D, plus all of the OGL derivatives...
  15. The Shaman

    Your Current Game?

    The Dance of Steel, my Flashing Blades campaign, going strong for over a year now.
  16. The Shaman

    ...A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Store

    That's one product that Whizbros could sell me. I'd buy a copy of that in a heartbeat.
  17. The Shaman

    A mini-rant re: Pathfinder and D&D

    "Honest?" We have different ideas about what defines honest discourse, but telling people, 'U r duing it rawng,' then admitting you don't really know what you're talking about, doesn't strike me as a particularly forthright way of contributing to a conversation. My question is on point, by the...
  18. The Shaman

    A mini-rant re: Pathfinder and D&D

    You can answer the question, 'Is Pathfinder D&D?' but you can't answer the question, 'Is Castles and Crusades also D&D?' I find that puzzling. And then again, I don't.
  19. The Shaman

    A mini-rant re: Pathfinder and D&D

    Why can't you answer the question with the same directness with which you decalre Pathfinder to be D&D? So far, every time I've asked you a direct question, you respond with, 'Well it could be this, or this, or this, depending on yadda-yadda-yadda.' But you don't seem to have anything...
Top