Search results

If I'd ever go back I'd use e6 or e8, essentially cap at that level and PCs gain Feats every other level or so, and with greater level spells requiring either one of the below or combination thereof: multiple casters; be rituals (i.e. 10 minutes or longer); or granted as rewards in the form of...

You are talking about strangers or acquaintances and ghosting which isn't at all applicable to the OP.

Understood. Your Prince Valiant game describes how I see my current game progressing or perhaps where I am intentionally nudging the table (the players) towards. This example was also great. The conflict is immediate between the PCs and has room to escalate, bring about new questions and...

That is fair, have we come up with a better term? I may have missed it. Oh you will get no argument from me there. I just, after years of being an active participant, do not find that getting into those discussions yields much fruit.

I think what is more mature is for us adults to not to be so easily offended. And I was definitely guilty of this before so I'm not saying anything that didn't apply to me either at some point. Years ago I was offended by the term GM decides. I am not offended by these words anymore. Princess...

Yes and that reason (X happens) needs to makes sense to me and my table if I'm working under the sim banner. EDIT: You can try again after you level does not work for sim. My point exactly! So a dead-end in the lock-picking exercise needs to/should provide consequence whether it be time lost...

I think you are missing a step in this particular example...the PC should be afforded the opportunity to attempt to pick the lock again. In the same way I can attempt to hit a creature again during combat.

I quite liked the After the Battle scene. Does Prince Valiant require planning, particularly moral/ethical quandaries as you wrote up this example as opposed to say Burning Wheel where the direction of the narrative is discussed at the table with the players? i.e. greater player participation in...

I think it maybe because the math of 4e is fairly consistent across all its levels. Earlier editions had a different world outlook, your level 1 character was NOT that competent across the board.

Out of interest what is the relevance of (c) - are we talking like healthy characters? I'm not understanding the connection here for the word fit specifically.

Next year Father's Day celebrated

I'm not sure why there is such a push to include Fail Forward in skill challenges in games whose tasks resolution are very singular when it comes to a die roll. For instance the so-called Narrative games, as I understand it, include Fail Forward in a sense in all areas including that of combat...

He was just pointing out it should have been characters not players in your 5 words

Devil Contract Cost: Your Seed.

I like it as Moves against the PCs can be quantified. It provides permission for GM decides. Dice rolling provides an increased risk to the party (risk of increasing GM resource).

One can zero-prep using material one is familiar with (published or otherwise). For instance it's very easy for me to start a session in towns and cities of published settings where I have a decent amount knowledge of. What I'd also dig into are the characters: Who they are? Their bonds...

I don't play BitD but I've been experimenting with more player-facing mechanics etc in our D&D and I empathise with both situations. I treat each situation on a case by case basis. If the specific threat is something they expect OR if it's part of a larger player-facing mechanic I reveal the...

I propose a name for this approach, the staggered skill challenge

Like many things it can be used for good and bad :) Besides sharing in joy (laugh) it is an indicator for like-minded persons to enjoy a well written post or perspective. You can also use the thumbs up as a thank you. But otherwise yes it can be used to denote and cement tribal mentality

Good catch, I find this quite interesting. I can only speak to my table of course how this almost came about for our game (and we were committed to following it through). A while ago each PC was banished from a dimensional plane that was closed. I decided the banishment would work in a way to...