Search results

then tomorrow at noon it shall be.

Wik and Atras, let me know if Thursday at noon works as a start time for the two of you. if you both post in the affirmative, then that's when I'll set up your ingredients.

qft

ED. I've had judges come down hard on me before and generally felt wronged by the whole judgement thing. so I went back and re-read your entry again. earlier I've been called out for being too critical and I was working to avoid that. if you really want me to go into five pages of detail as...

ElectricDragon and Iron Sky, your decision awaits.

I'll be posting a judging tomorrow on the 8th match. it was a hard weekend and I've been mostly recovering from it today.

Round 1, Match 8: ElectricDragon vs Iron Sky before I get started, I do want to mention that 12 pages is a bit much to read through, Iron Sky. I like completeness compared to having to fill in the blanks, but try to not go quite so overboard in future rounds. Ingredients Bloody Dungeon Comet...

I'm offline the next two days, so I probably won't be able to put in a place saver post. my judgement will come probably on Monday. question: I had an idea for one of the previous sets of ingredients that I think covers the bases of what would make a good Iron DM entry (and it shows why it...

did you forget to put the encounters in there? just idle judge-like curiosity

other: I had a subscription to GAMES magazine and in the summer/fall of '78(?) they had an article on a new kind of game coming out that told stories with Dragons and Dungeons and stuff. I went looking for it after that.

the ingredients for Iron Sky vs ElectricDragon are posted.

ElectricDragon and Iron Sky, your ingredients are Bloody Dungeon Comet Agressive Moneylender Sleeping Death Patchwork Golem Shocking Arrows have fun!

ok, ElectricDragon and Iron Sky, I will put them up tomorrow (Thursday) at noon. I'm just on for a couple of minutes right now and won't have access again till late tonight. but noon tomorrow will work fine. -ph

Round 1, Match 8, ElectricDragon and Iron Sky I'm going to be offline for most of Wednesday, so if you want i can either give you your set of ingredients Wednesday evening around 8pm or Thursday around noon. does one work better or worse for you guys?

I felt that with both entries: the River Deltas were just there. both Bedridden Trolls were weak or very replacable, once the acid add-on keeping them in bed was eliminated. Rechan had a stronger Bard, but Atras evoked a more Monstrous response; but still a slight edge went to Rechan there...

actually, I've been house ruling them almost all the way back to 1e. when you find or buy them, they are gemstones, but when you put them in orbit they become little sparks of colored light, orbiting your head. they become gems again and fall to the ground when you die. or the wearer can...

judgement for Rechan vs Atras is done (and has a longer word count than either). edit: without reading the last dozen posts since Atras' FAIL request. and now, having just read them, I'm really curious what you all think...

and the winner is… different judges look at different things. my focus is almost always on the ingredients more than anything else. playability or usefulness is usually a wash and overall story or the feel of the scenario is extremely subjective, so I only count down on it if the story seems...

:) -ingredient ideator

Rechan vs Atras. ingredients are UP!