Search results

  1. Malin Genie

    Use Magic Device question

    What happens when a caster with the Use Magic Device skill attempts to use a scroll beyond her caster level, but does actually have some caster levels to start with? For example, Griselda is a 5th level bard with a +12 Use Magic Device Modifier. She attempts to read an arcane scroll of...
  2. Malin Genie

    PCs using bluff on PCs

    I think there is middle ground here. A character - PC *or* NPC - can lose an opposed Bluff check and still be suspicious, still attack, or take some completely different action in response (upend a bowl of custard on his own head and dance a jig, for example.) The win on the opposed check...
  3. Malin Genie

    Figments of my Imagination

    Area control. The illusion of spikes rising up from the ground, or a fissure opening up in the ground, or (with major image for thermal effects) a sheet of flames appearing will often keep creatures at bay. They don't even get a Will save unless they either inspect or try to move through the...
  4. Malin Genie

    Fighting With Spears

    Playing a longspear-wielding Barbarian/Ranger I have found the most effective Feat to use with a longspear is, in fact, the simple Spring Attack. You can choose, if an opponent closes, to take your AoO, then just step back and full attack, but you can also move away or past the opponent while...
  5. Malin Genie

    D&D 4E I bought GURPS 4e!!!! (and returned it the next day)

    Ditto - the balancing factor (especially given the much higher costs of the books here in Australia) was the binding - so now I shall go out and buy!
  6. Malin Genie

    D&D 4E I bought GURPS 4e!!!! (and returned it the next day)

    Before I go off and order my copies - what exactly is the 'binding problem'? Is it affecting all copies or just a particular run?
  7. Malin Genie

    Evil Campaigns

    My one suggestion - a Lawful Evil party can work but Neutral Evil or Chaotic Evil won't (as a party.) For solo adventures Neutral or Chaotic Evil could be interesting...
  8. Malin Genie

    Why does Undead=Evil

    I had always thought (as a player, not a character) that it was negative energy animating the body (in the case of mindless, animate undead,) and that the soul of the dead creature was not involved in the process at all. The inability to raise a body once animated stemmed not from any 'damage...
  9. Malin Genie

    Do Entangle, Grease and Web ruin D&D?

    No - Evard's Black Tentacles ruins the game. Grappled - so cannot cast spells, need an attack action at least to escape - and then risk being grappled again next round - yeuchh!
  10. Malin Genie

    Can fiendish animals coup de grace?

    I agree that animals will not CdG. That won't stop them attacking a downed but living foe, though, and the net effect will probably be similar....
  11. Malin Genie

    CAn you ride your own tensors floating disk?

    Brings to mind an image of a wizard siting on his Floating Disk moving it along with a long pole, wearing a flat, broad-brimmed black hat and a striped shirt, and singing opera...
  12. Malin Genie

    What is 'interacting with' an illusion?

    Excellent timing - that must have just gone up on the website! Thanks for the answers - that pretty much tallies with what I expected. So new question: if I create an illusory wall, until it is studied (or something is thrown at it or someone touches it,) it will completely conceal those...
  13. Malin Genie

    What is 'interacting with' an illusion?

    As the title asks. More specifically, if an illusion of a wall, or pit, or similar obstacle is produced, does 'looking at it' comprise interaction? Does examining without touching comprise interaction - and if so, how closely does it need to be examined? Example: A character creates an...
  14. Malin Genie

    Goodberries while Unconscious?

    Realisitically, neither a potion nor a berry would be a good idea, more likely leading to aspiration and suffocation than to healing. Given that potions are specifically allowed, however, and for the sake of the game, I'd say yes.
  15. Malin Genie

    Sneaking in the wilderness - who's right?

    That pretty much fits with what I remembered - but I don't seem to be getting the chance to Spot / Listen for *them* at maximum encounter distance, nor do they seem to be getting range penalties (even at 100ft, I should have a decent chance to spot/hear a *non*-hiding opponent (Spot and Listen...
  16. Malin Genie

    Sneaking in the wilderness - who's right?

    I've found, particularly in Living Greyhawk, DMs are using Spot / Listen / Hide / Move Silently in a way that makes sneaking and scouting damn near impossible. In particular, characters attempting to scout ahead are usually asked to make Hide and Move Silently rolls, and if they 'fail' are...
  17. Malin Genie

    City Council Book?

    Thank you both (damn, that was quick) !
  18. Malin Genie

    City Council Book?

    I remember somebody mentioning a book on a City Council with councillors, their relationships, secrets and motivations, plot hooks and so on, in a thread about "Crunch vs Fluff" (although I'm not sure about the actual thread name.) Does anybody here know the name of the product / where to find it?
  19. Malin Genie

    Most versatile single class

    First, second and third choices, bard. Fourth choice, probably cleric. Bards have: Good spell selection, including Movement spells (dimension door, shadow walk) Information-gathering spells (clairvoyance/audience, scry, legend lore greater scry) Infiltration (invisibility, silence, sculpt...
  20. Malin Genie

    Do you use accents/"funny voices" when playing your PC?

    I think each character (PC or NPC) should have a 'voice'. And if that 'voice' just happens to sound exactly like mine, when I'm the DM and kind of tired, well that's just a complete coincidence.
Top