Search results

  1. GMMichael

    Should Wizardry Require Player Intelligence?

    You might want to re-read the original post. That would be kind of awesome. But terribly slow for combat magic. Digression: should wizards even use combat magic? It might be best left to the battle mages . . . That's hard to address without a specific game reference, but if wizards require...
  2. GMMichael

    Should Wizardry Require Player Intelligence?

    No, and I'm not asking wizard players to cast spells. Rubik's cube? I guess the fighter can do some push-ups for his attack, then. Ah, faith. It's for a different thread, but I've always thought that cleric PCs should have faith in the GM and their own actions when trusting that their deity...
  3. GMMichael

    D&D General Tiered Enemies

    A lack of "locking" is loosely responsible for the D&D Effect: PCs think they can reasonably fight anything. For example, dragons having challenge ratings across the board (just 3e?) ruined the idea, "we're fighting a dragon!? This is going to be epic!" Now it's more like, "we're fighting a...
  4. GMMichael

    D&D 5E (2014) How do you handle Insight in your game?

    The character could, but I would expect it more from a PC. From the sound of it, neither of us is married to D&D enough to worry too much about it . . . Are you reading it as, "roll insight to notice mannerisms?" Because I'm reading it as, "roll insight to determine intentions." Which is a...
  5. GMMichael

    Should Wizardry Require Player Intelligence?

    I thought of that, which is why the subject says, "wizardry." But it makes me wonder: should other caster players have other requirements? Is it, though? Alien: Isolation makes the video game player solve a shape-matching puzzle to unlock doors. It tells the player, "you can't just press a...
  6. GMMichael

    Other Modes of RPG Play?

    I would like to add acknowledging that the abbreviation NDND should be a thing.
  7. GMMichael

    Is Losing your Turn The Worst That Can Happen

    Those actually sound like interesting options to me. So I'm hearing that the sucky part was just that it was the most frequent status condition.
  8. GMMichael

    Should Wizardry Require Player Intelligence?

    Oh, so wizardry should require player wisdom instead? 🤓
  9. GMMichael

    Is Losing your Turn The Worst That Can Happen

    Right? What if Stunned just means that your physical options are out, which doesn't affect your mental or magical ones? Or you still have your muscle memory (physical), but your mental options are restricted? "Never lose a turn" seems like a boring game to me. I don't want to see it in every...
  10. GMMichael

    Should Wizardry Require Player Intelligence?

    GM: Stephen, you're up. SH: I c a s t m a g i c m i s s i l e . GM: And? SH: O h s o r r y . I d i d n ' t c a l c u l a t e t h e f l u x c a p a c i t a t i o n y e t . GM: No problem. Everyone, Stephen's wizard starts casting a spell. Stephen, let me know when you're ready. Gronk, you're...
  11. GMMichael

    D&D 5E (2014) How much does cover cost?

    Good question. Spartans cover each other, according to Zak Snyder, anyway.
  12. GMMichael

    What is Amazon’s beef with DCC?

    It must be Amazon phishing for OP's age, then. @rhythmsoundmotion , do you have an Alexa in the house?
  13. GMMichael

    D&D 5E (2014) How do you handle Insight in your game?

    So the duke's valet dropped a bag on the ground and almost spilled its contents. He gathered it up quickly, but looked nervous about it, so a PC shouts "I'm rolling Insight! What are his intentions?" And the DM has to say, "welp, he's sleeping with the duke's boyfriend?" I'd assume that the...
  14. GMMichael

    A review of Shadowdark: Streamlined Modern OSR

    Dungeon delving strikes me as a high-prep type of game. Could you clarify this? Not from an old-school perspective. Or a role-playing one. As someone who GMs more often than he PCs, I like the rolls to suggest what kind of character I should be making.
  15. GMMichael

    What is Amazon’s beef with DCC?

    I think Amazon has a beef with Texas, not DCC. Which is understandable.
  16. GMMichael

    D&D 5E (2014) How much does cover cost?

    35 silver, and a link:
  17. GMMichael

    Is Losing your Turn The Worst That Can Happen

    I . . . can't respond for most players. And it depends on the game. Losing a turn in a game that takes 10 minutes per round means you get an extra smoke break, which is nice for some players. Some players couldn't care less what happens in combat. The game's about intrigue and character...
  18. GMMichael

    Friends, Gamers, Editors, Lend Me Your Ears! (New Rules)

    Do you: love reading about RPGs? consider yourself a grammar fanatic? enjoy bashing on RPGs that aren't yours? have a minimalist streak? want a new, free, game to play? exhibit none of the above? If so, follow the link below to an 11-page, medium-type-size .rtf of Modos RPG game rules...
  19. GMMichael

    D&D 5E (2014) How do you handle monster knowledges in your game?

    My preference is a good, old-fashioned reconnoiter, preferably while the creature is eating another party of heroes.
  20. GMMichael

    D&D 5E (2014) How do you handle monster knowledges in your game?

    Erm, it could also mean that none of the PCs' attacks will do anything. Does a Knowledge check have retcon powers? "You've heard that these creatures can't be cloven," ::looks at a whole party of axe-wielding dwarves:: "so you brought a stiletto, just in case." Good call noting that study is...
Top