Search results

  1. Salthorae

    D&D 5E (2014) Zards Ban List?

    You could change them from flat -5/+10 to -Proficiency/2x Proficiency. So at 1st it's only -2/+4. I've found that works to bring some of the swinginess of the feats down at my tables. Love me some Minotaur sailor/reavers! I have an entire island of them on my homebrew setting :)
  2. Salthorae

    Survivor Aberrations: BEHOLD THE WINNER!

    Aboleth 26 Beholder 28 Berbalang 19 Chuul 23 Elder Brain 26 Gibbering Mouther 27 Mind Flayer 27 Morkoth 14 Neogi 21 Neothelid 23 Otyugh 26 Spectator 11-2=9 Star Spawn 16 Ulitharid 23+1=24
  3. Salthorae

    Unearthed Arcana New Unearthed Arcana - Subclasses 2 [UPDATED]

    Tobriand the metal mage, one of Halaster's "apprentices" might benefit from a change from wizard to something like a clockwork sorcerer depending on the abilities.
  4. Salthorae

    D&D General Background Vs. Backstory

    Xanathar's has some fun tables for these if people don't want to come up with their own! I have a whole questionnaire I give to my players (nothing is required!!) to get their thoughts flowing on who or what they envision for that character. Or they can roll stuff to get their creative juices...
  5. Salthorae

    D&D 5E (2014) [Poll] Are any of the subclasses underpowered?

    To be fair, Blade-lock isn't technically a Subclass. You could have a Pact of the Blade for any Patron after all. That's also game dependent a bit. A Pact of the Chain Warlock isn't going to feel like their choice was super good if the game only does Social situations so the familiar can't Help...
  6. Salthorae

    D&D 5E (2014) Could 5E Use A Branded Magazine In Stores (Again)?

    I mean, Hasbro owns WotC and D&D. They could fill Dragon with cross branded advertising for all their different divisions/lines of toys/etc., especially the board games and MtG and such with the budgeted advertising dollars. They would probably have enough just there to not have to open it...
  7. Salthorae

    Unearthed Arcana New Unearthed Arcana - Subclasses 2 [UPDATED]

    Dunno. It happened at some point today. I had the same thing happen when I followed the link
  8. Salthorae

    On Magic Users and Darts: What's Up With That?

    Pretty sure it was a 2e thing. I remember them having a RoF of 3/1, but even then you only got 1 Weapon proficiency to start the game. I always did a dagger just in case because it had flexibility.
  9. Salthorae

    Survivor Aberrations: BEHOLD THE WINNER!

    Aboleth 25 Beholder 28 Berbalang 22 Chuul 22 Elder Brain 26 Gibbering Mouther 26 Mind Flayer 25 Morkoth 18 Neogi 20 Neothelid 23 Nothic 7-2=5 - still a lame beholder with legs :P Otyugh 28 Spectator 20 Star Spawn 19 Ulitharid 22+1=23 - how is Mind Flayer beating their superiors?
  10. Salthorae

    D&D 5E (2014) [Poll] Are any of the subclasses underpowered?

    Honestly thats the problem with most of these. The only one I selected from this list is Four-Elements Monk. They're just not good. Beastmaster Ranger is doing pretty well with the Class Features UA, so I think they're good. They would have been my #2 choice on this list.
  11. Salthorae

    D&D 5E (2014) Could 5E Use A Branded Magazine In Stores (Again)?

    I guess they don't, and sure they are doing all that other stuff, but they're also still putting out Dragon+, which is very much a "magazine in e-format", even if it's not a PDF. I don't have time as a working person to keep up with all the different articles and streams and podcasts, etc. I...
  12. Salthorae

    D&D 5E (2014) Could 5E Use A Branded Magazine In Stores (Again)?

    I'm of two minds. I fully agree with @Umbran here, but at the same time, I never bother to read magazines in e-format, they're just too easy to forget about while a physical magazine is sitting on my table waiting to read.
  13. Salthorae

    Unearthed Arcana New Unearthed Arcana - Subclasses 2 [UPDATED]

    Bummed I missed it while this was still up Probably an early trigger or they didn't have the Subclasses 01 survey ready or something. Hope they re-post it again soon, some of what you guys are talking about looks very interesting.
  14. Salthorae

    D&D 5E (2014) [Poll] Are any of the base classes too weak?

    I did honestly, though I love them myself and play them more than any other class. My biggest gripe is the # of spells known, but other than that they have proven a pretty solid class in play for me.
  15. Salthorae

    D&D 5E (2014) [Poll] Are any of the base classes too weak?

    Can't vote unless you select at least one option. I'm probably in the minority, but think that most classes in 5e are pretty good. Some of the base classes are weaker than others, but overall I think the classes themselves are good. Even Ranger with some of the XGE subclasses is fine.
  16. Salthorae

    D&D 5E (2014) Concentration mechanic can ruin plots in adventures

    I'm not really seeing the issue though. Charm Person isn't a concentration spell. Nor is it one that you get to save against each round. Eyes of Charming let you cast it 3/day, Staff of Charming let's you cast it up to 9-10 times per day, and then you have all the caster's spell slots to cast...
  17. Salthorae

    D&D 5E (2014) Can you twin booming blade

    Hah. that is another can of textual worms. Though for this one Crawford agrees that RAI are that GFB can't be twinned.
  18. Salthorae

    D&D 5E (2014) Concentration mechanic can ruin plots in adventures

    I second these ideas as well. Goggles of Charming, Mass Suggestion go a long way towards your goals. As does the Mantle of Majesty.
  19. Salthorae

    D&D 5E (2014) Can you twin booming blade

    Perhaps... it's hard to keep track sometimes in threads of who is arguing what positions when sarcasm gets tossed in!
  20. Salthorae

    Is Forgotten Realms the Default Campaign Setting for 5e?

    From a mechanics perspective perhaps, but not a lore one. Where have you seen them in the Lore/Fiction outside the fiction of the Realms? To me the Lore/Fiction is more important to what defines a setting than the mechanics with certain exceptions, defiling in Dark Sun for instance. But even...
Top