Search results

  1. W

    D&D General Monster Expectations

    A Gnoll stealth-expert druid/assassin sniper named Grassy Gnoll would be a fun deep cut pun-NPC.
  2. W

    D&D 5E (2024) Rules that annoy you

    Regarding 6 seconds (in all the contexts) -- I don't know if it was the 120' move per 10 minute adventuring turn, or that speeds/ranges got cut in 3 when moving indoors, or maybe it was the AD&D 2e longwinded justification for why a combat round was a minute long. Either way, somewhere in the...
  3. W

    D&D General Not the Wicked Witch: Revisiting the Legacy of Lorraine Williams

    Regarding Buck Rogers and self-dealing -- I generally agree that there's nothing capital-w "Wrong" with it in a closely-held corporation situation. And yes, she was certainly not the only one to do it*. However, it is significantly risky in that it incentivizes you to see these other things you...
  4. W

    D&D 5E (2024) I just got a 2024 PHB From Gen Con. AMA!

    Is Heat Metal still no save? Any standout changes to Counterspell, Force Cage, Simulacrum, or Wish? Does Spike Growth still do damage per 5' square an opponent moves through?
  5. W

    D&D General I'm a Creep, I'm a Powergamer: How Power Creep Inevitably Destroys Editions

    Interesting. For my money, the updated race/class level limits were the most often used content, followed by weapon specialization.
  6. W

    D&D General I'm a Creep, I'm a Powergamer: How Power Creep Inevitably Destroys Editions

    AD&D 2nd Edition is an interesting case. And here, I'm going to focus on the part of 2e that comes before the Player Options era, and also before some of the late 'faux leather splatbook' era (I think everyone agrees that era having some very clear power creep). Now, 2E comes out and...
  7. W

    D&D 5E (2014) Legendary Resistance shouldn't be optional

    It is certainly part of the problem that so many save-or-penalty effects are 'lose all of your action(s),' which is uniquely debilitating to boss monsters*. As well, oftentimes the effect still leaves the sufferer vulnerable to attack*, without** ability to then test again or spend resources, or...
  8. W

    D&D 5E (2024) How many of you would implement the drop to 0 HP, get 1 level of exhaustion house rule?

    I think the notion that having a PC go down is a failure of the team as a whole more than the individual certainly rings true. Perhaps an answer then is to preserve the basic premise, but swap out exhaustion for something else. Perhaps a party where a PC drops to 0 gets a 'Morale' or...
  9. W

    D&D 5E (2014) Strength bows?

    If we were to implement this paradigm, a whole slew of martials would be Str15, Dex as-high-as-possible.
  10. W

    TSR The Full & Glorious History of NuTSR

    At MLB, did you work for The Los Angeles Angels*? *for the English-Spanish bilingual, 'The the angels angels'
  11. W

    Best John Williams themes! Go!

    You joke (I think), but even a lot of his scores for... products of lesser overall quality, shall we say... are often quite good. I remember both Sabrina and The Terminal being overlong and underwhelming (and Stanley & Iris being just a forgettable romance), but the scores were still of the...
  12. W

    Time Bandits: The Series Official Trailer (2024)

    Stipulation: We all get that you aren't impugning Kudrow's talent or as a person. This is about role/casting. Well, they try. It doesn't always work. Going back up to my Wallace Shawn example, I watched the original trailer for The Princess Bride, and I would love to be able to view it without...
  13. W

    Time Bandits: The Series Official Trailer (2024)

    Kudrow's style is a different permutation of comedy than we've seen recently. Kind of a comedic character-actor given main-character billing*. It's interesting to watch her play effectively the same character in two shows-- in Mad About You working off of general-actress-in-a-comedy-role Helen...
  14. W

    D&D Historian Benn Riggs On Gary Gygax & Sexism

    I think a lot of what Gygax wrote, and wrote mostly quite well, was an instruction manual for a style of gameplay that didn't/only partially materialized for many. The AD&D books (especially the DMG) work best when they seem to be trying to be take #2 on oD&D played in the manner originally...
  15. W

    TSR The Full & Glorious History of NuTSR

    Resolve conflict through boning? I can see it. I would've picked sloth, just to explain the 'Kirk-speak.'
  16. W

    Was Thac0 really that bad?

    I'm more adamant than most in the 'hey guys, can we please stop trying to posture our nerd cred*?,' but even I don't think this is just** people trying to show up to win the discussion. It's just the kind of thing that people regularly mention being a nightmare, and people who didn't have all...
  17. W

    TSR The Full & Glorious History of NuTSR

    I've been saying it for the longest time, the people who are worst to nerds are other nerds trying to establish dominance.
  18. W

    D&D 5E (2024) What Spell Sage Advice (& Descriptions) are you afraid won't be "fixed"?

    I'd like them to revisit Tiny Hut in general, but that's probably another thread. They would have been so much better off either consistently saying "The DM must make a determination" or frame all SA as "The way I would rule is..." Or, as mentioned, simply state the intent of the rules text and...
  19. W

    D&D General Professor DM from Dungeon Craft has a special message…

    Everyone should be aware of their body, their health, and the screening options available to them. You should get checked and screened as recommended. You should also consider getting checked earlier* than recommended -- provided a negative experience there will not keep you from going back...
Top