Search results

  1. Umbran

    Goodman Games: Our Efforts Have Been Mischaracterized

    It seems to me that a zero-tolerance attitude is common on the internet, but in realspace many people don't actually have the option to forgo business contact with any and all people who display their racism. It is like noting that ethical consumption is not a practical possibility right now -...
  2. Umbran

    Goodman Games: Our Efforts Have Been Mischaracterized

    Maps, for one thing. For another, with sufficient points of similarity, he could be on the hook for violation, even if it isn't a direct reprint.
  3. Umbran

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    Who suggested you, personally, should? We can't talk about things that don't apply to you, personally?
  4. Umbran

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    Nope, I don't. I've realized it isn't a valuable line of discussion.
  5. Umbran

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    Yeah, I don't know if that actually addresses/answers my question, but arguing it wont make things better, so I'll back off.
  6. Umbran

    Goodman Games: Our Efforts Have Been Mischaracterized

    It seems plausible, at least. I wish he'd come and do the interview with Morrus.
  7. Umbran

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    So, there are people who say that. Therefore, you treat everyone as if they are saying that? That's gonna make things better? At that point, it is probably time to close the thread. Shall I do that? It is like two clicks. We can end everyone's frustration sooo easily.
  8. Umbran

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    Why? Maybe because you don't have enough like-minded people around to run the game exactly how you want to do it? Or maybe you really want to play with your BFF, but the fullness of your preference isn't quite their bag? Or are we all absolutists around here, unwilling to make any compromise...
  9. Umbran

    Goodman Games: Our Efforts Have Been Mischaracterized

    Well, just for sake of checking out possibilities, let us consider, for the moment, the possibility that, in fact, he really wants to be inclusive, and has good intentions. How might working with an objectionable person fit in? In his, and many people's minds, the original is an iconic work in...
  10. Umbran

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    I know. Just because I have a different focus than you, don't treat me like I don't know the field. Instead, how about you start by thinking that maybe, just maybe, I have a point - just not your point. The statement I was responding to here was specific: "cogent narrative". To me, it...
  11. Umbran

    Goodman Games: Our Efforts Have Been Mischaracterized

    You're probably correct. I suppose the question is more about the long-term. Whether or not this project makes it, what'll the impact to their business be? The next kickstarter won't have the controversy drawing eyeballs, or have the FOMO-effect driving it. Will it fly as well?
  12. Umbran

    D&D General What Does New Coke Tell Us About Designing for D&D

    So, I know this is from a way back, but the thread popped back up, and I saw a quote and thought about it... My wife is a veterinarian. She's known she wanted to be a vet since she was, like, five years old. My wife's practice is centered on geriatric, hospice, and end-of-life care. She deals...
  13. Umbran

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    Sure. But, go ahead and try to play a session that doesn't generate a coherent narrative. I think you'll find that not producing a coherent narrative is, in fact, a failure state.
  14. Umbran

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    Unless you engage in play in which effect does not follow cause, or characters don't have even half-cogent reasons for their actions, the result is coherent narrative. "Coherent," doesn't mean, "esthetically pleasing," or something. It just means that it makes some basic sense as a series of...
  15. Umbran

    Judges Guild Makes Statement About Goodman Controversy [Updated]

    If I recall correctly, it also isn't enough to prove they spent the money on things other than the product. You have to show intent to defraud - like, documentation (or at least behavior strongly indicating) that they never had any intention of creating the product - they took the money knowing...
  16. Umbran

    D&D General 1s and 20s: D&D's Narrative Mechanics

    Mod Note: "Disingenuous" is, unfortunately, a polite word for "lying". Probably should avoid that accusation.
  17. Umbran

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    Mod Note: Please don't try to make the discussion about the person you are speaking with - that's a road to egos getting in the way, and people being insulted. Please stick to the substance, not your internet-mind-reading take on the mental state of others.
  18. Umbran

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    I suppose it is a viable approach, so long as it doesn't violate established narrative. If the Great Dragon has been plaguing the lands for a century, or Stradh the Vampire Lord is making an appearance, and the power of these foes has been remarked upon, ratcheting down to not slaughter a 1st...
  19. Umbran

    Goodman Games Revives Relationship With Anti-Semitic Publisher For New City State Kickstarter [UPDATED]

    Mod note: The trenches here seem to be dug and probably aren't going to reveal any striking new thoughts on the matter. As events unfold, please remember that what people in the RPG business do is not an excuse to badger, berate, harass, or otherwise treat your fellow posters with anything...
  20. Umbran

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    Jamie Tartt is a character from Ted Lasso - he starts as the best player on the team, technically. But, he's a ball-hog on the field, and a self-aggrandizing twit and general jerk off the field. He gets better.
Top