Search results

I think you hit it spot on here. There are tons of factors in how long combat takes (or any other part of the game, for that matter), and we've had the game released in final form for about a month. I'd question anyone who says "this is how the game plays..." at this point, since we'll only...

Matt has spoken up a couple of times about rules issues that he's trying to get across to the viewers, so I have no doubt that there's some rules teaching going on. And (and this is just my opinion, of course) that's a very good thing. I think there should be more of it, right up to the point...

I've been around here for conversations about other sites, and even the ones that started off positive or helpful turned into people talking trash about issues that typically had nothing to do with the initial question. So yeah, message received, and I always try to talk about the issue at hand...

I think it may be a bit too early. But I'll participate when we get closer. I'm glad to get a beverage with any of you. The bartenders crazily remember me because I always tip them.

I'm on a lot of different boards but I tend to read and not post to them. I'm a Redditer and actually mod a community over there where we discuss game design. Edited to add: there are a lot of boards still out there, but Enworld moderation doesn't really like to discuss different places here...

Honestly, that's a really good question. I've found myself heading over to the tabletop RPG forum much more than the D&D one for a while now as I've drifted off from 5E. I'm just about to go back to a game we're starting up again with existing characters so I'll be playing it, but we're using...

I am going to have to disagree with this. From the kids in Death House to the creature in the basement, to the Dream Pasteries to the experiments done by the Abbot to what Strahd did to Vallaki in my game ... it was plenty horrific. That's not to mention the dinner with Strahd and the eventual...

Thinking about this thread made me think about my life when I got started on Enworld. I live in the same city as Eric and heard about it right away, so I've been here forever. The thing was, I was an entirely different person back in those days. Edgy Internet warrior? Check! So there aren't...

I love me some 4E: it's my favorite edition. At the same time, DH doesn't interest me in the same way at all. I like DH and I'm looking forward to running/playing it, but not for the tactical combat minigame. I'd say that the people who hate 4E haven't shown themselves to hate on DH either.

This is the big question. Will they move to DH on Critical Role? I think the decision has to come from what people are saying about the new system, and especially what their existing fanbase has to say about it. My Magic Eight Ball is pointing to "signs point to yes" right now. Critical Role is...

It's interesting that this hasn't happened yet, and I'm not surprised. I think it would be really difficult to get the feel for Diablo (or Grim Dawn, a game I also love!) in a tabletop RPG. I would be genuinely surprised to see if you could get the feeling and pace of those games for a TTRPG.

I think that while Daggerheart can do a lot, it can't do everything. And options/rules/settings ... you name it, those are coming. The game is just getting started, and it seems clear they want to do a lot with it.

I've been watching the Umbra series and I think Matt's doing a solid job with it. If you have the time, I'd say it's worth watching.

I would say it's closest to early seasons of Supernatural, before the meta-plot really kicked in. Or the X-Files when the episode wasn't about the ongoing conspiracy.

To be sure. Daggerheart isn't trying to be an all-things-to-all-people game, and I expect there will be plenty who bounce off it, have your meh reaction, or just hate it. That's another reason why I think D&D isn't in any danger. I do hope that it expands to be another viable alternative to play.

This is a situation where what I want to be true just won't be. I'd love for Daggerheart to explode onto the scene and take the rpg world by storm but D&D is a brand. Its the “xerox” or “scotch tape” or “google” of the gaming world. People just know the brand. Now I think it will grow...

The ones I really note are Blades in the Dark (Jonathan Harper) and 13th Age (Rob Hensoo and Jonathan Tweet). Fortunately they have a solid "inspirational sources" list, which looks like this: (Note: Mods, if there's any issue with posting that screencap, I'll remove it).

Hearing about this new book, I thought I might want to check it out. I appreciate this discussion because I now see this book is not for me. Not going to yuck anyone's yum, but not for me. Like some other recent threads, it will be interesting to see how it does.

I have to agree on this. I have a friend who's very excited about Outgunned so I'm going to get to try it. From everything I've seen about it, it's high-octane action-adventure-centric. I'm not sure that was fully the intention of the Evil Hat game, it seemed more PbtA-based, which I'd call...