Search results

  1. pawsplay

    WotC WotC President Cynthia Williams Resigns

    Ecosystem, in the corporate gaming world, means the process of getting people addicted to your games. They are in the ecosystem because they keep coming back for nibbles and giving you money. The goal is a self-sustaining, rewards-based system that keeps them from "escaping" the ecosystem. It's...
  2. pawsplay

    What makes an TTRPG a "Narrative Game" (Apocalypse World Discussion)

    The Moves are the game. Also, DW is just different than the mainstream of PbtA games. I freely admit I slice the pie a little different. The Big Model / GNS doesn't really admit that "narrative" is a thing. It doesn't even mention story as something involved in Exploration. "Developing a story"...
  3. pawsplay

    What Games do you think are Neotrad?

    So the party will either fight the bone naga or not fight the bone naga, and they will leave the city and go some other place, and an NPC will talk to them. That sounds like a very far thing from knowing what will happen next.
  4. pawsplay

    WotC WotC President Cynthia Williams Resigns

    She was at M$ before, so it could be gaming-related, which could be a conflict of interest. Also, sitting on multiple boards like a rich person is a little different than payout-hunting as part of a tight startup venture with plans for the original crew to cash out within a few years.
  5. pawsplay

    Natural Bond and Beastmaster

    There is no specified order of operations, so you can do whatever is most beneficial. But you have to apply all the effects of a given feat or trait at each step.
  6. pawsplay

    WotC WotC President Cynthia Williams Resigns

    My guess is she was seeing writing on the wall, and she decided to quit so if they came after her it would look retaliatory. Or she just got bad health news. Those are just the two possibilities that spring to my mind. Such short notice is rare. It makes sense if it's personal for her, if she...
  7. pawsplay

    Removing "Friction" In-Game?

    Friction is not a fundamental force. It results from things like kinetic energy turning to heat, and from asperities (surface roughness). If those properties don't exist, your body doesn't convert kinetic energy to heat, and particles don't resist the movement of other particles. So you would...
  8. pawsplay

    D&D 5E (2014) Chris Perkins Lays Down Some Lore: Who Was Vecna?

    Who's that lich, running around with you-ou?
  9. pawsplay

    What Games do you think are Neotrad?

    I find it to be incomprehensible. I don't know what you think I said, or what I'm supposed to think you think I said. But maybe just respond to something I said.
  10. pawsplay

    David Wesely: The Man Who Accidentally Invented RPGs

    Sure, if you have some way of defining the scope of one resolution.
  11. pawsplay

    David Wesely: The Man Who Accidentally Invented RPGs

    The difference between playing pretend and an RPG is "the system decides." The system can be literally anything, but there is some formal method whereby potentially conflicting events in the narrative are resolved. It has to be something more formal than social clout; bullying is not a...
  12. pawsplay

    What makes an TTRPG a "Narrative Game" (Apocalypse World Discussion)

    Well, I'm not saying that. Your hot air balloon/jet fighter comparison makes a lot of sense to me as a metaphor. What I am saying about PbtA games is that they admirably meet their aims, but not by being "narrative." They have some goals, but the most distinctive thing about a PbtA game is that...
  13. pawsplay

    What Games do you think are Neotrad?

    If the party can either attack or not attack the bone naga ambassador, in what way are their actions constrained? The book gives you lots of options to use the material, but there is still no requirement that any particular thing happen. As I said before, if the party behavior is quite different...
  14. pawsplay

    What Games do you think are Neotrad?

    Yes, obviously. If it helps I have a published Paizo credit, albeit not in an AP book per se. Continue?
  15. pawsplay

    What Games do you think are Neotrad?

    What does "sticking to the module" mean?
  16. pawsplay

    David Wesely: The Man Who Accidentally Invented RPGs

    The Braunstein is the concept underlying all RPGs. Just take a system, any system, that lets someone play a role, and tell them they can try to do anything they want.
  17. pawsplay

    Removing "Friction" In-Game?

    Your body would separate into atoms.
  18. pawsplay

    What Games do you think are Neotrad?

    What if they do? What if they don't even anticipate the direction they're "supposed" to go? What if they try rigorously to follow the "plot" and all the bright glowing question marks they find, but they break something? What if one of PCs absolutely won't do something the PCs are presumed to do...
  19. pawsplay

    What makes an TTRPG a "Narrative Game" (Apocalypse World Discussion)

    At the risk of oversimplifying a long, complicated discussion that spans three different models of RPGs, and the post-model world we live in: "Narrativist" games are games that fulfill a specific kind of gaming experience Edwards thought was under-supported. His response was to envision a...
  20. pawsplay

    What Games do you think are Neotrad?

    Really? How?
Top