Search results

What splat book is it in?

See 2nd Ed guidelines for DM creating new classes.

The only people with levels in my game are adventurers. All others are just regular people with various levels of skills. About 2% of the population have any class levels.

In my game only certain classes qualify for the feat...

Group? It's a feat taken by an individual PC.

The PC states the distance. The DM determines the rest...

Nope. It is up to the PC to figure out the distance per RAW.

"You point your finger and determine the range (distance and height) at which the fireball is to burst." Even harder. Ever try to accurately name an exact distance?

A grid intersection is about the size of a bulls eye on a target... Grab a ball and throw it at a target from 30' or so away. Do you think you will hit it 75% of the time?

Line of sight, line of effect rules.

It's about as compelling as me making a Fighter with a 10 int and trying to get him to be a magic user type via UMD... :hmm: And then complaining that the rogue is better at it...

Nope. Living longer is not equal to learning more. Otherwise you wouldn't need to study. Just sit there and gain knowledge.

What you are overlooking is that the "feat" comes from longer term knowledge. If you are a spell caster and reincarnate, do you lose spell casting knowledge? If not, then you don't lose a known feat.

You still haven't answered why you'd get a "hunch".

And, IRL it isn't that simple either. If the hostage isn't being very still, you aren't going to get an instant kill either...

Yes, I've been doing the former for 30 years. On rolls for stuff that the player wouldn't know about, I make them.

Actually, the rule is on page 24 of the DMG.

It all depends on the artifact. It is up to the DM. There is no right answer.

and adjudicating all rules and outcomes.

Play with gamers who aren't sheeple?