Search results

  1. Keeper of Secrets

    So, what makes 1e adventures so great?

    Reason #1 - That is all that gamers had and they came with decent stores, good maps and some memorable encounters. Reason #2 - Everything seemed original at the time because there were no knockoffs yet. Reason #3 - This was a shared experience for many gamers. Before the Internet and before...
  2. Keeper of Secrets

    4 Million gamers, 40,000 different styles of Play

    I think you're right. Whenever I play in games at Cons I get the feeling that there are so many different styles of play. So many of the styles of play take different approaches on story, combat, adventure and so on. I admit that Cons are not the best place to judge a player or a GM due to...
  3. Keeper of Secrets

    Arguments That Never Die

    You will find that there is a segment of the population that gripes just to gripe.
  4. Keeper of Secrets

    Tired of d20 yet?

    I'm not tired of it but I came into d20 D&D a little late. When d20 I was not playing D&D. We were playing a supers game. Then my first exposure to d20 was actually Mutants & Masterminds. It was not until after that (less than 3 years ago) that we started playing D&D on a different night...
  5. Keeper of Secrets

    Friday the 13th! Superstitions in your Game?

    Not an 'in game' superstition but one that my players had: We all know that many gamers have the superstition regarding dice. However, in two seperate games with totally different players they had superstitions regarding character sheets. In one group, we were playing Call of Cthulhu. They...
  6. Keeper of Secrets

    Warhammer RPG, Gotta love it

    I'm looking forward to giving it a try, too. I have the material and have been going through it (and sort of comparing it to the old Warhammer RPG) and it really is a welcome addition to my gaming shelf. My players are good natured enough to not mind taking a brief break from our usual...
  7. Keeper of Secrets

    Gencon Couples, Help me!

    If you drag someone to something like GenCon then they will have a bad time and resent you for it. If you want to be with her then just stay with her. I love GenCon as much as anyone but some things are more important.
  8. Keeper of Secrets

    GM Dilemma

    Clearly the players did not listen to what you had told them. Typically, when I start a new campaign I do one of two things. 1) The first session is actually everyone designing and talking about their characters so they form a cohesive story to start with. 2) I ask them what they want and I...
  9. Keeper of Secrets

    A Realization (maybe an epiphany?) about D&D

    I never made the switch to 3.5 and I think I may have made the right call. I like games with a certain amount of complexity in that the rules provide a lot of options. However, d20 is pretty havy on the rules side. That said, I wing it from time to time. I stay as close as I can without...
  10. Keeper of Secrets

    Defeating a D&D god

    According to some people who wrote in to Dragon magazine over a decade ago, their characters had already enslaved all the gods and they currently work in salt mines underneath the characters' keep. Contact that guy. He probably knows how to kill some gods.
  11. Keeper of Secrets

    Big Item

    To the original poster: how often does your GM give out sweet treasure? Is this out of the ordinary or are items like this 'par for the course?' I, too, am starting to think there could be more to it.
  12. Keeper of Secrets

    Would you spend $100 for a monster book?

    I would have to see it first. Though I barely use the monster books I already have, much less get use out of a 100 monster book that would likely contain a crap load of varients and weird creatures.
  13. Keeper of Secrets

    Cthulhu Dark Ages

    The funny thing is that you don't really need Cthulhu Dark Ages to run a game for Cthulhu set in the dark ages. There were not really any special rules to it and the history provided would probably be better suited if you just picked up an old Western Civ book and a specialized book on the dark...
  14. Keeper of Secrets

    Any other hobbies cause you to lose players?

    I have lost players to moving, working ner shifts, having personality comflicts with other players, etc. I have never (to my knowledge) lost players to other (quasi-related) hobbies. I wonder if anyone has ever lost any players to a competing RPG.
  15. Keeper of Secrets

    More guys play D&D than gals, Why?

    Ha! One of the females in my gaming group is also a scrapbooker. Then again, that seems to be a hobby that is increasing in popularity.
  16. Keeper of Secrets

    Strap Yourself In...WFRP, Here We Come!

    I am really happy the way the game flows. I have not yet gotten the opportunity to play or GM with it but I think I will get the opportunity in a few months time when another campaign I am in takes a small break from things.
  17. Keeper of Secrets

    More guys play D&D than gals, Why?

    I guess part of it has to do with guys are more interested in this TYPE of thing (role playing games, comics, computer games, playing 'army' etc.) Certainly the female population for these kinds of things have grown in recent years but it probably has something to do with conditioning. Also...
  18. Keeper of Secrets

    Tips on running a long-running campaign

    Lots of the advice here is really good. The best advice I can give - and this comes from experience - is that I actively engage the players/characters in the plots. I ask them to create pretty good backgrounds (after a few sessions of play as they can naturally fall into a background) and...
  19. Keeper of Secrets

    The most powerful class?

    Wow. It seems like cleric is certainly getting the votes. When I first saw the title of the thread I thought about what classes people might take to twink out. If I were just trying to make an uber-powerful character, I think I would certainly throw in some levels of fighter (to get a few...
  20. Keeper of Secrets

    What do you dislike about 1E?

    I like 1e alot. However, it was poorly organized, needlessly complicated in some areas and did not have a very workable index. However, I disagree with those who say the rules were poorly written. Sections of the books were written rather well but some sections were not as great. But I...
Top