Search results

  1. arscott

    Is Davy Jones from the Pirates movie a god?

    The closest analogue might actually be a Darklord of the shadowfell--Both cursed and empowered by the evils he's committed and the tragedies he's suffered, Granted incredible control, but only over his domain.
  2. arscott

    Dark Matter Campaign

    Pick up this PDF. It's a never-released-in-print supplement for the Alternity Version of Dark•Matter that focuses on the Final Church and the Demons they worship. The adventure is pretty nice, and is pretty easy to convert to d20M, and the general information on cults and demons is also pretty...
  3. arscott

    Suggestions for '10 HUge miniature set

    Elephant w/ howdah! Tri-horn Behemoth w/ howdah! Astral Dreadnaught, with separate floating eyeball. What about a Unique Eladrin Lord with a huge-sized mount? Perhaps that one sea-lord riding the crest of a living wave (making the water elemental folks kinda happy)
  4. arscott

    Editorial Calendar for April

    Dual Classing, Court of Stars, and a Dungeon/Dragon crossover called "Arcane School"? This is shaping up to be the best month ever.
  5. arscott

    Defenders and Monsters that Swallow Whole

    Seems like there are a number of situations where the swallowed target can't take the necessary action to actually take advantage of his or her mark ability. For example, most of the swallow abilities daze the target, rendering the swallowed creature incapable of taking immediate actions. That...
  6. arscott

    4E/Earlier Editions Hybrids: Why the difficulty?

    For Starters, Dragon Magazine has released several adventures in both 3e and 4e. I'm not quite clear whether those were 3e adventures updated to 4e, or 4e adventures that were converted for 3e, but either way it makes the point that such a conversion is possible.
  7. arscott

    D&D 4E 4E Dragons - Where's the beef?

    Anthony, find yourself a 3rd level party, and throw a 15th level dragon against them. See for yourself whether or not they run screaming.
  8. arscott

    What do I do with all of these blank dice?

    See, this sort of thing is why I, as a GM, am constantly forced to "forget my dice", and borrow players' "Lucky Dice" for those extra-important rolls. That 235566 one would be absolutely perfect for a 4e recharge die.
  9. arscott

    RPGA Scenarios Strengths & Weakness

    As far as the 4e adventures go, I find them railroaded, but not atypically so when compared to other convention games of a similar type. The tournament games I've played in have been just as railroaded as LFR games, as have most D&D games where I was allowed to create my own character. the 3e...
  10. arscott

    Problem Players and Problem DMs

    I'm not asking a game to transform a disfunctional group into a functional one. But I think there's become a tendency to label groups as disfunctional merely because they're having problems with the game. Where do you draw the line?
  11. arscott

    What levels should the D&D Pantheon Gods be?

    Planescape, basically. (Hence Shemeska's devotion to non-statted gods)
  12. arscott

    What would they be in D&D?

    So, we've pretty clearly established that Maximus is a Hexblade/Psychic Warrior or a 1e Monk, so how about another batch of characters? 5. Link Hero of the "Legend of Zelda" video game series. 6. Susan Pevensie Older Pevensie sister from C.S. Lewis's "Chronicles of Narnia". 7. Will Turner...
  13. arscott

    Problem Players and Problem DMs

    But doesn't this sort of thinking let the game off the hook for practically any flaw? "It doesn't matter if there aren't rules for character creation--A good DM can compensate for that."
  14. arscott

    Problem Players and Problem DMs

    But how is it a bad thing that this player seeks to be effective in combat? And in what way does his decision not to use a shortsword run contrary to role-playing. If there are better weapons available, choosing to use those weapons instead parallels the actions of nearly every historical and...
  15. arscott

    What would they be in D&D?

    Aragorn: 3e: half-elven ranger with some fighter levels 4e: half-elven warlord, multiclass ranger Odysseus: 3e: Human swashbuckler 4e: Human rogue multiclass warlord Maximus: Don't know a thing about him, but I bet his 4e version would make use of that sweet Gladiator article from dragon...
  16. arscott

    Hatin' the RPGA? (Forked Thread: The real flaw of 3E/3.5E/OGL)

    I'll bite. In what way does a game designed for (the modern) RPGA play not often meet the requirements of a home game?
  17. arscott

    Problem Players and Problem DMs

    If people are jerks independant of system, then I don't want to game with them even if they're my friends. Hence the my italics in the original post. I don't mean this in specific reference to the problem being discussed in the thread I forked from. I'm just kind of sick of hearing people say...
  18. arscott

    Problem Players and Problem DMs

    Forked from: Fighters didn't matter after 11th level? Submitted for your consideration: Any "Player Problem" or "DM Problem" involving a player or DM that I want to play with is a problem with the system.
  19. arscott

    Forked Thread: Pyramid of Shadows joys - 4e Grappling

    I'll second that. The 3e grapple rules themselves are pretty simple, and if one PC tried to grapple another PC there wouldn't be any problems (well, unless you get the low STR gnome grappled by the Goliath with the improved grapple feat, but that's not a problem of rules comprehension). The...
  20. arscott

    What levels should the D&D Pantheon Gods be?

    Gugalanna, the sumerian Bull God, was slain by Gilgamesh and Enkidu. Gilgamesh is described as a demigod, but Enkidu is fully mortal. In general, there are few circumstances where a clearly-defined non-god has killed a clearly defined god, but much of that is because deific status is never as...
Top