Search results

  1. Eltab

    Question: how much extra effort would it really take to write modules supporting multiple systems?

    Probably already mentioned: The big problem I see is the pagecount eaten up designing every important NPC twice and printing those stat blocks. As an extreme example, Laeral Silverhand is fully statted out in the D&D 3e sourcebook Waterdeep: City of Splendors. She is two full pages long. Now...
  2. Eltab

    D&D 5E (2014) The Debate of "Canon" in D&D 5E

    The earlier Bond films, like the song "Blurred Lines" and Pepe LePew cartoons, can be used as object lessons: how _ not_ to behave / treat women. Although I did like the Roger Moore -era Bond film where a sex kitten type invites herself into Bond's bed while he is out; when he gets back and...
  3. Eltab

    Escaping Violent Players

    My group will eat just before play begins (because some of us are coming straight from work to FLGS). No alcohol, because FLGS. I must live a fortunate life; I have never had anybody resort to violence over an RPG in my presence.
  4. Eltab

    D&D and the rising pandemic

    I would be unhappy with the vaccine manufacturer(s) for selling product that does not actually allow me to stop 'walking on eggshells' about catching the germ.
  5. Eltab

    D&D 5E (2014) The Debate of "Canon" in D&D 5E

    How many people (by headcount, or by percent of audience) have to be in the group "I saw and liked the earlier movies but I didn't like this one" before it becomes the movie that has a problem, instead of the audience that has a problem?
  6. Eltab

    D&D 5E (2014) The Debate of "Canon" in D&D 5E

    I think the WotC staff had decided to make the Zhentarim a "playable organization" for 5e (along with Harpers, Emerald Enclave, et al) and to do that they had to remove the Evil gods who motivate / meddle in Zhent affairs. So Bane had to be demoted and de-powered. The other two gods I think...
  7. Eltab

    D&D 5E (2014) Best Rogue subclass for 12th level Ranger 3rd level Rogue

    If you had no swashbuckler already, I would have said that. Arcane Trickster is good for keeping enemies occupied while you whomp on their friends. Assassin sounds like it will fit into this group, if you all adjust your Plan A to give your character a Surprise Round.
  8. Eltab

    D&D 5E (2014) Command and spike growth

    I would give the Command'ed NPC a saving throw for every square that hurt them. They ought to stop or recognize the danger.
  9. Eltab

    D&D 5E (2014) Who are the greatest DEAD heroes of the Forgotten Realms? Help for campaign concept (Fantasy Court of Owls)

    This sounds like an invitation to run my 3e characters through a Bardic Reputation Enhancer a few times and send back the resulting legends.
  10. Eltab

    D&D General A Goliath and a Dwarf have a baby, describe it!

    Solid as a rock. Might even get the Wood Elf 'hide behind a tree' racial ability, but for hiding against stone surfaces.
  11. Eltab

    Paizo Paizo Workers Unionize

    The public sees the multiple layers of Administration that absorb most of our School Tax money before it gets to the classroom. So far there is no good answer how to distinguish (from outside) between needed management and squandering of resources. Some time soon now this tangent will move...
  12. Eltab

    D&D General Suggestions for Rooms in an Adventurers Guild HQ

    Rooms where you can practice with whatever Tool Kits in which you are proficient. Map Room (or alcove in the Library). Spell research labs / facilities. A wing where the 'hired help' can stay, in modest comfort.
  13. Eltab

    D&D 5E (2014) Orcish campaign idea

    One of the very last 4e Living Forgotten Realms modules (I've forgotten the name) involves negotiating with an orc tribe to decide to sit out an upcoming war. Your PCs are sent to persuade a tribe "join us against the outsiders". The possible ways in the adventure to persuade the tribe to...
  14. Eltab

    D&D General Who should play Gary Gygax and Dave Arneson in a D&D biopic movie?

    Bette Midler or Glenn Close could play Lorraine Williams. Especially if you want to take this movie down the campy route, and slather on 'villainess' makeup.
  15. Eltab

    D&D General Your quick post-it-note DM reminder

    Does the NPC have a Plan? Strategically, minions and cannon fodder are supposed to fight and get beat, but BBEGs or Godfathers are supposed to be working toward some goal. And tactically, my best fight as DM came when I worked out three turns of what the Dragon would do ... and after I got...
  16. Eltab

    D&D and the rising pandemic

    If this drug pans out - or whatever does pan out - it is not going to be an 'orphan drug'; it will be going to mass market. It won't stay highly-expensive. And as a matter of setting expectations, 'people can buy it off the shelf like you do aspirin' is far better than 'here are an obstacle...
  17. Eltab

    D&D 5E (2014) 5E Survivor - 5th Edition Survives! [+]

    Original Dungeons and Dragons 46 - 2 = 44 Advanced Dungeons and Dragons 51 Basic Dungeons and Dragons 50 + 1 = 51 B/X Dungeons and Dragons 50 BECMI Dungeons and Dragons 53 Advanced Dungeons and Dragons, 2nd Edition 47 Dungeons & Dragons, Rules Cyclopedia Edition 50 Classic Dungeons & Dragons 51...
  18. Eltab

    D&D 5E (2014) Wild Speculation: Athas, the World Without Dragons

    That is a neat idea, but the resulting BarrenWorld will be Athas-adjacent; it will not be Athas. Part of the tragic majesty of Athas' backstory is that the ruination of the world was started on purpose (although the end was not intended), it did not happen because of a naturally inevitable force...
  19. Eltab

    Paizo Paizo Workers Unionize

    President Reagan was dealing with an already-existing union, not an effort to start a new union. The situations do overlap, but I think not enough to make a good analogy. Neither Paizo nor the employees have "infinite" resources compared to each other, so neither can adopt scorched-earth tactics.
  20. Eltab

    D&D 5E (2014) Ray Winninger, in charge of D&D, states his old school bonefides.

    Is this an invitation to get into a one-ups-man-ship contest? I'm so old school I helped build our little red one-room schoolhouse.
Top