Search results

Valid argument, it has merit, but I don't completely agree from a personal standpoint, though I do from a societal standpoint. Make sense? I don't know about writing. Having read the GUCK and Nymphology, and knowing people that have read Naughty & Dice, the only difference seems to me to be...

I would suggest it (and did) simply because I don't see a difference. But that's just me. All of this said though, my primary campaign includes not even a tiny bit of description concerning anything of the nature. Sex happens in the game, but off-camera and in everyone's own imagination (I...

Actually, it does. That's one of the best arguments I've heard. Thanks! hunter1828

In other words, describe it in writing, but don't show us what you mean? hutner1828

That's why I said What you don't get is that for the most part the whole idea of roleplaying of any kind is silly. Period. It's a question of content, just as with the contents of said book itself. The idea that adults (and I use adults because I am and I game only with adults) are sitting...

So, you don't own the PHB, DMG or the MM (all three of which include the various items listed, to different degrees) nor play the D&D game? hunter1828

Actually, I think this one should stay open so people can vote in the one they deem most appropriate for their choice. And if this one does close I think mine should too in the interest of fairness. hunter1828

Actually, the sex act itself (and rules for such things) are only a very small part of the BoEF (and a part I won't use myself). But this argument is weak. A book of pretend combat involving pretend fantasy races isn't silly. A book of pretend gods involving pretend fantasy races isn't silly...

Hey, thanks for voting and thanks for recognizing that this poll was asking about more than just one book. I really appreciate that, no matter whether we agree on the books or not. hunter1828

So, you would have a use of some sort for those two sources? Then your vote of is incorrect since the poll is asking about ALL four sources and not just one? hunter1828

My standard argument back...It doesn't change the content of those other books. The jokes in Playboy doesn't change the fact that there are naked women in it anymore than the childish writing of Nymphology changes the fact that there are sex-based PrCs in it. The flip side of this argument is...

Found it: "Thrills and Chills: Ice Age Adventures" by Arthur Collins in Dragon #68 (December 1982). hunter1828

As someone who isn't pierced and doesn't plan to be, I can understand that. But what about the other sources? This poll asked if any of FOUR sources were of use...not just the BoEF. hunter1828

No one "needs" them. Some people want them. What if one of the other sources included in the poll have such things? Is that ok, just AV shouldn't do it? The focus of this is NOT on the BoEF. It is on all four of the mentioned sources, Nymphology, Naughty & Dice, the Guide to Unlawful...

No, keep polling until there is a poll with more realistic choices. I didn't vote in the other poll because none of the choices were accurate for me. I'm not out to "prove" anything. Just get a more accurate feel of the different choices people have with various sources for adult fantasy rpg...

It doesn't matter what the intent of the product was. What matters is the content of the product. What this says is, "its ok to show nipples and have magic weapons that are essentially large adult toys of a certain shape...as long as it's funny. But if anyone shows nipples (or other body...

An OLD issue of Dragon (back in 1e) had an article on fantasy ice age games. Don't remember the issue number, though...have to check the Dragon Archive CD-ROM. hunter1828

23 "No" of one type or the other compared to 16 "Yes" of some sort...the difference isn't as large as I thought it would be. At least so far. hunter1828

As far as content goes, it doesn't matter what game system it's for. The content (and by that I mean primarily the written text) is still the same. The only think offensive about Valar's press was AV's self-admitted horrible initial press release which shocked the gaming community and gained...

Ah! Well, it was the first poll I've made here and I wasn't sure of the process...so brief delay. :) hunter1828