Search results

  1. bmcdaniel

    New News Page Layout

    I like it, but I miss that the old format automatically generated a forum topic. I'm not sure whats going on with this new format. Some news stories (like this one) can be commented, but not as part of the forum; some news stories (like...
  2. bmcdaniel

    D&D 5E (2014) Likes and Dislikes?

    Like: - Narrative elements (Background, Personality Traits, Bonds, Flaws) that were inspired by story-telling games - More abstract combat does away with lots of tiny little modifiers, instead using simple advantage/disadvantage mechanic. - Bounded accuracy - Concentration limits number of...
  3. bmcdaniel

    13th Age 13th Age monsters in 5E

    Me too. This sounds very cool.
  4. bmcdaniel

    D&D 5E (2014) Skilled contests and advice wanted

    For the specific example, I would count a hit as hitting the target, while damage is how close to the center of the target the shot landed. That simulates the ability of a great archer to put the arrow where it would do the most damage. Contrarywise, if I was modeling an arm wrestling contest...
  5. bmcdaniel

    The Ultimate (A)D&D Kitbash

    Simple: 4e, but * More simulationism; * More fluff; * Less concern about making everything balanced, in particular PCs could choose "cool" but sub-optimal powers.
  6. bmcdaniel

    Teleport foes over a cliff - Forked Thread: Push+Wall=save

    My inclination is to stick with the 3E way of handling this: you can only teleport someone onto a flat, stable surface capable of supporting their weight. Did that particular rule go missing in 4E? -BMM
  7. bmcdaniel

    4th Edition Reference Sheet/DM Screen in Downloads

    Hi all, I've uploaded to the Downloads section, a set of 4th edition reference sheets (also suitable for use as a DM Screen). It incorporates all errata to-date. Comments appreciated. Thanks, BMM
  8. bmcdaniel

    4E Miniatures Buying Advice

    I'd suggest a slightly different strategy. Your plan is a kind of "top-down" plan to figure out what you need, then go and buy it. I would suggest that that you should start with a "bottom-up" approach of browsing the last few sets, seeing what is really cheap, and buying a whole bunch of really...
  9. bmcdaniel

    Dynamic Excel "Wiesbaden Charactersheet"

    Any idea when v13 will be ready? I love the sheet but have been holding off making LFR characters for Gen Con in the hopes that v13 will be ready. But we're getting close... BMM
  10. bmcdaniel

    4e Cosmology Changes

    I like it primarily because the planes now have enough room for whatever new planes you want. Need a plane of mirrors? Check, you can add it. Need a sub-plane where the followers of one particular god go to die (instead of fading into non-existence)? Check, you can add it. Need a strange new...
  11. bmcdaniel

    The Law and GSL

    Plus consideration isn't necessary for a license. IAAL, but this is not legal advice. You get real legal advice when you pay for it.
  12. bmcdaniel

    Minions: Known or Unknown?

    The players will only know what the characters see. "In the room you see a half-dozen orc flunkies, wearing cheap leather armor and wielding an assortment of weapons. There's also huge orc wearing expensive plate armor and wielding a wickedly barbed axe covered in runes, and some sort of orc...
  13. bmcdaniel

    Making your own power cards

    If possible, It'd be great to get these formatted for business card size. You can buy pre-punched sheets of business card stock. You can't for playing card stock :( BMM
  14. bmcdaniel

    Manual of the Planes, Dec '08

    Yuck. I had the Astral Dreadnought. Its like the worst bits of 1e non-fantastic stuff. I hope thats just a placeholder. BMM
  15. bmcdaniel

    D&D 4E What was Paizo thinking? 3.75 the 4E clone?

    While it is theoretically possible that some marketing research regarding D&D was not part of WOTC's acquisition of TSR, such an event is highly unlikely for two reasons. 1. Regarding a legal exclusion: there would be no business purpose in excluding market research regarding an asset that was...
  16. bmcdaniel

    Rodney Thompson: Non-Combat Encounters

    Aren't you a big fan of Paizo's Adventure Paths? Almost by definition, these are "single stories" that have to happen. They certainly are fairly "railroad"-y (and I say this as a fan myself). BMM
  17. bmcdaniel

    Use Magic Device: Keep or Kill?

    Kill it as a skill. Make it a power for Rogues.
  18. bmcdaniel

    D&D 4E Why I'm "Meh" About 4E

    Greyhawk already has half-demons (hello Iuz) and plenty of draconic races, so tieflings and dragonborn don't seem like much of a stretch. PCs could play 'em too (ever read the 1st edition Rogues Gallery?). Even if your DM didn't allow it as a starting race, you could get there via the...
  19. bmcdaniel

    Mongoose reaction to OGL/SRD

    Well, I'm sorry to hear that. Glorantha is a fantastic world, IMHO, and I think that D&D is better at simulating the truly world-shaking heroes like Arkat, King Argrath, Harrek and Jar-Eel better than BRP ever could.
  20. bmcdaniel

    Necro is IN! Planned Products

    QFT. Especially because once a DM allows a class/race into the game, its awfully hard to remove it later when it becomes clear its unbalanced. An unbalanced monster, magic item or spell is more easily disposed of.
Top