Search results

  1. C

    D&D 5E (2024) RIP, 2014 PHB backgrounds

    As mentioned above, and IME, not everyone understands this. A lot of the complaints about the UA are "Why do farmers speak Halfling?" Or "That's stupid, why do Gladiators speak Orc? Is WOTC saying all gladiators are orcs?", etc. Its reviewers, "influencers", etc. as well. People don't get...
  2. C

    D&D General Finding Stuff in a Bag of Holding

    I don't think it was in the rules, but we used to have it take 1 round to reach in and feel around to grab whatever specific thing you were looking for. If you wanted an "object interaction" or quick grab of something, we usually kept a running tally of what was in the bag, and randomized on...
  3. C

    D&D General Survivor Thread: Best D&D Movie

    Krull didn't make the list? Gasp! But, my glaive! No, not that glaive, the spinning whirly one that returns like a boomerang! Its got it all. A hero, a princess, a ragtag band of bandits turned heroes, a cyclops, and a dungeon, I mean castle, with cool enemies!
  4. C

    D&D 5E (2014) D&D Cartoon Character Miniatures Are Coming!

    Definitely. This is a prime example of where digital renders do not look anything like the final product.
  5. C

    D&D General The Venn Diagram of D&D and Magic: the Gathering Players

    I've played DnD for 40 years or so, and played MTG back in the Mirage and Ice Age eras. I haven't played Magic since then. So my answer would be "I play DnD, but played magic a long time ago". I like the Magic Crossovers, and have been eyeing some sort of Innistrad game for awhile now.
  6. C

    D&D General The Case for Evil Orcs (Minor Rings of Power Spoilers)

    In my games, I've tried something slightly different: removed all mention of "good" and "evil" from characters, monsters, gods, and spells. So, Protection from Evil is just "protection" and protects against things attempting to harm you. Detect Evil doesn't work. If the PC's continually...
  7. C

    D&D General "I have Played in or Run a Campaign Set in the Forgotten Realms" (a poll)

    I think a lot of it comes down to mistaking quantity for quality. There is so much material out there for the Realms, it must be awesome! The Realms can be good, but it takes a solid and creative DM to manage it. Do you use all the existing Lore? Do you retcon stuff? Do you change...
  8. C

    Grognard view of One D&D?

    As a grognard, it takes me a very long time to realize that things aren't aimed at me anymore (games, TV, music, movies, technology, even DnD). Once I finally realize I'm not the target audience, everything makes sense and then I can settle into what I want to do/enjoy doing, rather than...
  9. C

    D&D 5E (2014) Spelljammer Errata

    But NA "culture" is not monolithic (including as it does Mexico and Canada, as well as the USA). There are hundreds of cultures represented in the United States alone. Do you just pick the largest "cultures"? This ties back to my previous question in the post above...
  10. C

    D&D 5E (2014) Spelljammer Errata

    So I have a question then. If you are a company like WOTC, how many sensitivity readers are you hiring? How many cultures do you reference or ask for editing/reading for problematic rules/background writing? If you only select 2 or 3, because, remember, people are calling for full time...
  11. C

    D&D 5E (2014) When making decisions for your character in 5E, which is your top priority? RP or G?

    I tend to not pay that much attention to mechanics when I make decisions about my character. I also don't spend very much, if any, time thinking through my character's "progression" at chargen. I'll let those things develop organically. Note, I am also playing Basic/OSE. Its not something as...
  12. C

    D&D 5E (2014) Best guide for running Tyranny of Dragons?

    You should also check out The Alexandrian blog. He reviews plot holes, missing things, and in some cases rebuilds the adventures for ease of running. Lots of people like his work.
  13. C

    D&D 5E (2014) Are Wizards really all that?

    The only role it can't fill simultaneously on the team is healer, a la a cleric who might use healing during combat, which as everyone knows is sub optimal... But since every character has the ability to heal with a short rest or heal everything on a long rest, its actually a rather unnecessary...
  14. C

    D&D General Poll: Do DMs/GMs need to trust their players?

    I trust the players I'm playing with to follow game as laid out in session zero that they agreed to. I'm also trusting them to not fudge dice rolls (when not using the VTT supplied one), to not change their character sheet, or not to add gear or stuff they didn't actually have. I tell players...
  15. C

    D&D General Beginning a new campaign advice - foreshadowing and railroading

    The other element of this type of plot, a la Mutiny on the Bounty, is that a ship of that type NEEDS to stop at an island to restock its stores. Part of the voyage, pre-mutiny, is also using up supplies. Ships often carried enough to get them from point A to point B. Otherwise, it was belt...
  16. C

    Dragonlance Dragonlance Brings New Options to D&D

    Are you sure that's saying what you think it does? Writing his "faith" about things like "brotherhood, cultural divides, and bridging differences" and "seeking salvation and returning to your creator and home" doesn't sound particularly earthshattering, or out in left field. Like, don't all...
  17. C

    Dragonlance Dragonlance Brings New Options to D&D

    It took me awhile to decide if I wanted to respond to this, and how... As my brother has a severe developmental disability, and I grew up with that in the 70s/80s, etc., and played DnD and read and played Dragonlance, NOT ONCE did I interpret, view, see, or feel the Gully Dwarves were being...
  18. C

    D&D General Languages in D&D Are Weird, Let's Get Rid of Them.

    In my games, I assume that players are literate in their own language, whatever cultural language that might be. But that's it. If you "know" 4 languages, you can read and write your own, but the other three you can speak and generally understand. You'd have to spend downtime/resources/skills...
  19. C

    D&D 5E (2014) How do you define “mother may I” in relation to D&D 5E?

    I'd also add that when MMI is invoked, it is because the player disagrees with a decision by the DM, and chose to complain on a forum or twitter or whatever rather than talk to their DM about it. So it could be as simple as a stylistic difference, a game interpretation difference, or an...
  20. C

    Dragonlance Do you plan to buy Dragonlance?

    I doubt it. I'm not keen on the direction of 5e/5.5/OneDnD as is, so I'm unlikely to get the book for the campaign, as I'd likely have to change it so much, its just as easy to use the old materials. Now, the Krynn Battle game I'll take a close look at. I've not found anything really easy to...
Top