Search results

  1. GMMichael

    Darkvision Ruins Dungeon-Crawling

    Well, we're at least referencing D&D and other games that have an ability similar to darkvision. Which is a lot, I think. I think @Argyle King noted correctly that darkvision is an asset. The king didn't note what darkvision can remove from the play experience. So: What is lost by a party...
  2. GMMichael

    D&D General How Saving Throws broke in modern D&D

    Looks like we're waiting to hear back from OP, but I just read this into it: "Diverging saving throws are saving throws that improve faster for one class than another class." On one hand, there's very little reason why level 20 in each class shouldn't end up with about the same hit points and...
  3. GMMichael

    D&D 5E (2024) DMG 2024: Is The Sandbox Campaign Dead?

    The campaign advice, as described, accomplishes two goals for WotC: it makes newbie DMing easier, and it focuses DMs on new WotC products. Level up enough times, and a DM doesn't need advice on sandboxes. But let's also note that this leaves the door open for an Advanced DMG. "Buy, buy, buy...
  4. GMMichael

    D&D General How Saving Throws broke in modern D&D

    Oddly, I think saving throws are on their way to recovery. Save vs. Petrification seems pulled out of thin air, but Proficiency with Constitution saves seems more intrinsic. If D&D would just realize that defending takes just as much effort as attacking, I might consider a 7th ed campaign.
  5. GMMichael

    D&D 5E (2024) BG3 is the new Skyrim

    OMG, just shoot me in the knee.
  6. GMMichael

    Darkvision Ruins Dungeon-Crawling

    Sure, but modern combatants aren't looking for secret passages, trying to haul treasure, or following magical motes. They are watching for traps (mines) hopefully, and a torchbearer can do this too, but only the torchbearer chooses from the dilemma: do I follow the sparse lighting already in...
  7. GMMichael

    Darkvision Ruins Dungeon-Crawling

    It's a difference, but I'm thinking more "remove them from combat" than "PC gets disadvantage, 4 point penalty, must guess where opponent is, etc." It's the former case of "everyone gets low light treatment" that treats everyone exactly the same.
  8. GMMichael

    Darkvision Ruins Dungeon-Crawling

    There's a third choice. - Let everybody have the information and treat them the same, with exceptions for scouts. If there's a melee in poor lighting (i.e. by firelight), even the darksighted characters are going to have to deal with moving shadows and light sources. Being able to see...
  9. GMMichael

    Darkvision Ruins Dungeon-Crawling

    Meh. DMs have it bad enough. PCs can help a little. The DM describes everything in normal vision range. On her turn (?) a PC can ask, "I use my darkvision. What do I see?" Or the DM says which enemies are in dim light, and the darkvision PC can go, "I don't have disadvantage due to darkvision."
  10. GMMichael

    D&D General Cautionary Tale with DnD Beyond Account

    That would be nice, wouldn't it? If DDB is like most things corporate, actually getting a person on the phone who understands your problem, and is enabled to fix it, will be an ordeal of its own. Blockhead, I sent you an XP in the hopes that gaining a level speeds up the process.
  11. GMMichael

    Darkvision Ruins Dungeon-Crawling

    It's the D&D dungeon crawling motto: Doors & Darkvision.
  12. GMMichael

    Darkvision Ruins Dungeon-Crawling

    Oh, come on. Playing slot machines involves a lot of important choices. Do I ask the gal next to me to put out her cigarette, or move to another machine? How much longer can I hold out before my bladder bursts? Someone on the other side just hit a big payout, so should I move to another set...
  13. GMMichael

    D&D 5E (2014) Not upgrading? What version of D&D 5e are you sticking with?

    The poll needs a 5RD-only option. I'm not paying for that stuff.
  14. GMMichael

    Monster Manual Previews Reveal New Empyrean, Half Dragon, Cyclops, and Animal Lords

    Huh. The cyclops always struck me as a singular-not-dual type of guy.
  15. GMMichael

    D&D 5E (2014) How Often Do You Rinse and Repeat?

    The only reason to do the same thing each round is if it's working. If the PCs can't recognize this, then Darwin wins again.
  16. GMMichael

    Reynard's Repository 2025

    This seems to throw a good chunk of the armor rules out with the bathwater. How are you accounting for a solid AC 20?
  17. GMMichael

    Darkvision Ruins Dungeon-Crawling

    I didn't catch the "common misconceptions" part of that blog. Nor: This isn't backed up, but seems to be the underlying prejudice of most of the blog post. So, traps can't be spotted within 20 feet, but they can within 40? I mean, some traps might "come" at the PCs, but I expect those to be...
  18. GMMichael

    D&D 5E (2014) Building A Campaign Around The BBEG

    Leading off with hatred. Interesting . . . That's pretty cool. Let the PCs choose the takedown. Death by spear. Power source shattered. Forced to wear a big, red, "F." What about an Ancient Gold Dragon? I've been thinking about those for some reason lately. Yeah, I was going to say...
  19. GMMichael

    D&D General Instead of Steed

    New ability: Remove-Stick-From-Butt. @AlViking 's Retreat option is good. It's not, by the way, too late to look to Santa for paladin-like inspiration. I'm guessing Summon Sleigh is out, but temporary darkvision might be cool. I just can't picture a D&D character who's not into mounts...
  20. GMMichael

    D&D 5E (2024) I am so torn [UPDATE: I bought it]

    But are you going to shelve it next to your copies of Level Up A5e or Tales of the Valiant?
Top