Search results

Yes to all of those examples. That's why the lithe rogue doesn't have much HP as the big muscle Barbarian, in fact the current definition makes it more likely to be Meat since 'healing' is almost exclusively the domain of divine magic and 'meat grow back' stuff. Only Second Wind is the only...

You misunderstand my posts--I'm saying that HP is always meat in regards to how 5e designs mechanic and interprets it.

Oh I know that nobody thinks it's entirely meat. I just want 5e(or really, most TTRPG that says that and then make the only non-magical way to heal is through a tourniquette and bed rest) to actually put their money where their mouth is and actually mechanize that. Hell, I'm a personal believer...

And I'd rather have DnD commit to the idea that HP isn't entirely meat points so allow me to non-magically pep talk someone and make then heal 3d8 HP.

Oh I very much understand, it makes complete sense to me but I have no respect for it. I've done plenty of self-done research and discussion but that just solidified my negative opinion for realism as the only goal. Wait, let me broaden that up a bit so I'm a bit more clear that I dislike even...

ALso personally I just do not give a naughty word if 'historically' how things actually works. Might as well say that 'in Wheel of Time' magic works such and such--Realism is just an aesthetic anyways, One I have nothing but scorn if that's the only goal one seeks.

I think the more reality simulator it tries to do the worse D&D-style games become. Worse that they're version of reality is such a bore

Curious! can I ask why you asked?

You clearly place a lot of importance in thsi, discussion. May I ask why?

Personally, I don't. And just make every single gun a player uses has unlimited ammo and waterproof.

Just make everyone considered to always be in armour.

because it can be done in 6 seconds or less, duh.

You unstrap the armour, put the medicine on them,wrap the wounds in the bandages strap the armour back on. All of those can be done in liek... less than 6 second.

Yep, that's all possible.

Yeah you just need 6 seconds to do all of that.

By putting on herbs and tying bandages duh

For the entire first paragraph; yes to every single one of those questions. Sure nerf Medicine, it's already a useless skill generally anyways.

Nah, bandaging, disinfecting and stitching can all be done under 6 seconds

No it's realistic. People can be stabilized from death in under 6 seconds from any kind of wounds.

Well in my case I've always seen people be stabilized from death in less than 6 seconds