Search results

  1. G

    How do we fix the Sorcerer?

    This simply isn't true. Sorcery Points, even if used in the most inefficient manner possible, recover the exact same number of spell slots as Arcane Recovery. Sorcery Points are even better than Arcane Recovery when making higher level slots; a level 20 sorcerer can create two 5s and a 4 with...
  2. G

    Totally Original Class: Watchman

    I agree that the name needs to be changed. Not only is both oddly gendered and speciated (are only human males allowed to play this class?), it is also evocative of some lazy peasant leaning against a spear at a guard post. Someone else suggested sentinel. I like that. Marshal is nice, too.
  3. G

    AD&D 2E What PF2E means for D&D5E

    I bet Google knows the answer.
  4. G

    AD&D 2E What PF2E means for D&D5E

    They say PF2 isn't based on 5e, but the description of their new game concepts screams otherwise. They have a unified proficiency system that replaces BAB, save bonuses, and skill ranks, just like 5e's proficiency bonus. They also have a new character building paradigm (race/background/class)...
  5. G

    D&D 5E (2014) How do you rule switching weapons?

    I am very lenient with object interactions. I let players both stow and draw weapons as part of their object interaction. I also let players draw more than one weapon; they could draw a pair of weapons for dual wielding or draw more than one thrown weapon for ranged attacks. I even extend this...
  6. G

    D&D 5E (2014) Homebrewing Humans

    I like the idea of moving Variant Humans to be the standard human, but replace the earned feat with one of six "subraces," each one nominally themed on the six stats. Strong humans would get a smattering of strength-related abilities that might mirror some of the benefits of the Athlete or...
  7. G

    Can a character become hidden without using the hide action?

    That's true! You might hear it purring or licking. Mechanically, your passive Perception score might beat the sleeping cat's stealth score. A closer case would be trying to detect an animated broom laying in the corner of a dark room, next to a mundane broom. I'd rule that the animated broom...
  8. G

    Can a character become hidden without using the hide action?

    Yeah, I think so. I always ask myself if a PC or NPC is attempting to hide from someone (attempting to break LoS and become undetected) or if they are merely attempting to be stealthy. One requires a hide action while the other requires an action-less stealth check.
  9. G

    Can a character become hidden without using the hide action?

    I use the Hide action to allow someone to go from "detected" to "undetected," as it were. If a creature was never detected to begin with, it does not need to spend an action to be hidden as they are already hidden. If you walk into a dark room with an unseen cat sleeping on a table in the...
  10. G

    D&D 5E (2014) PC Permadeath: Yea or Nay?

    When a character dies in battle, I might have a "You've been captured" up my sleeve, depending on the context of the battle. Intelligent creatures with an agenda might have the motivation to burn a scroll of Revivify in order to turn a corpse into a captive, though, against many monsters...
  11. G

    D&D 5E (2014) Barbarian: Path of Least Resistance, 'cause Why Not?

    My bad. I meant, "Great job, OP!," but my Autocorrect hiccuped.
  12. G

    D&D 5E (2014) Anybody ever want to change characters a lot? How do you prevent that?

    In my experience, people are far less likely to switch out their characters if you have them put extra work into their backstories and incorporate their backstories into the game.
  13. G

    D&D 5E (2014) Barbarian: Path of Least Resistance, 'cause Why Not?

    This is a smattering of way-too-good abilities tied together with nothing more than a pun. Fail.
  14. G

    D&D 5E (2014) Foreshadowing Effectively

    I'm running Curse of Strahd and am having a hell of a time foreshadowing that Barovia is designed as a personal hell for Strahd, a place where his love is perpetually stolen from him and he is slain over and over again. If they ask the right questions and follow the right leads, they can take...
  15. G

    D&D 5E (2014) GMs of EN World: What player behavior annoys you the most?

    While it is half my fault as DM for not simply nipping it in the bud and moving the game forward, please do not hold a game up for 15 minutes arguing over a ruling, especially if it is over something that doesn't actually hurt your character.
  16. G

    D&D 5E (2014) Backgrounds

    Yeah, backgrounds are already fully able to be customized. Proficiencies, language, traits, and even your feature can be changed to suit your PC's needs. To me, extra backgrounds just seems like unnecessary bloat (aside from the cool new suggestions for personality traits, anyways).
  17. G

    D&D 5E (2014) Need suggestions for epic tasks worthy of a demigod

    I appreciate it; it was pretty jarring. But yeah, that's why I describe it in my pine cone example as "an utterly mundane task that requires an epic approach to get it done in time."
  18. G

    D&D 5E (2014) Need suggestions for epic tasks worthy of a demigod

    Ok, I'll bite. Go ahead and try to convince me that cleaning some poop is epic.
Top