Search results

  1. MacMathan

    D&D 5E (2014) Historical European Weapon Equivalents

    If I recall correctly, there was some dart usage by the Gaelic kerns/ceithernach up until the approximately 16th century. Of course it can be hard to tell from historical references the difference in a dart, javelin or short spear sometimes.
  2. MacMathan

    D&D 5E (2014) Historical European Weapon Equivalents

    Love it! Any chance of a similar thread on armor?
  3. MacMathan

    D&D 5E (2014) Sell me on Wizards

    Sounds mostly like an issue for those who only played wizards in 3e at their zenith of power. If you played wizards at low levels in 1e or 2e the 5e wizards seems awesome. If you played a 4e wizard you are already used to being in line with the other classes in terms of power level across tiers...
  4. MacMathan

    D&D 5E (2014) 5E Player's Handbook owners: What's the current condition of your book's binding?

    So far the 5 books in my group are holding up fine. Looks like things are trending in the 10% range which is waaaay too high, IMO. WotC might want consider another printer or going with a sewn binding.
  5. MacMathan

    D&D 5E (2014) DungeonScape Beta Gloat Thread

    So far really unimpressed, to call the web version a beta is a stretch and I have a lot of software publishing experience. At best the web version has the functionality of an alpha and the interface is pretty dreadful. I hate to say it but as of right now WotC's 5e tool set release is feeling...
  6. MacMathan

    D&D 5E (2014) Conjure Fey -- Super Disappointing

    There is definitely room for more fey and beasts too. If you don't want to be a dinosaur druids begin to run out of beast forms at 9th level hopefully the dmg will have guidance on a dire templates or advancing monsters in CR.
  7. MacMathan

    D&D 5E (2014) Does anyone who got an mm at Gencon want to offer up spoilers to us?

    Are there any templates that increase CR or advice on how to scale monsters up to increase their CR?
  8. MacMathan

    D&D 5E (2014) What armor can druids wear? Is there a way to get a decent AC?

    My current druid wears hide and uses a shield with a decent dex(14) fro an AC of 16 not bad really especially since it is possible at level 1.
  9. MacMathan

    D&D 5E (2014) Really want access to DungeonScape

    Personally sad they are doing iOS first as it means I will have to wait even longer. Plus all I really want is a simple character generator at this point. Looks like I will just have to finish my own excel based one. Seems like the web version would have been the most inclusive, especially if...
  10. MacMathan

    AD&D Commemorative Core 3: I Haz 'Em!

    Damn my pre-order store won't have then until Wednesday.:eek: Glad they look good
  11. MacMathan

    Base measurement in DDN

    Would not minis need to be 45+mm scale if 1 meter =1 inch?
  12. MacMathan

    Convincing 4th Edition players to consider 5th Edition

    Excellent explanation. Please someone XP for me as I must spread it around
  13. MacMathan

    D&D 5E (2014) Will there be a "default" mode of play in Next?

    I imagine the default will be whatever they turn Encounters into. The public out reach games will set the tone for what new players expect.
  14. MacMathan

    The (Non-)Playtest Experience, or How the Hit Die Mechanic was a Non-Starter

    One point that might make it more palatable for your group is that the overnight healing mechanic has not IMO influenced the design of the play test module. Some posters have expressed concern for the assumptions to the game that are forced upon adventures but I think the Caves works when...
  15. MacMathan

    The (Non-)Playtest Experience, or How the Hit Die Mechanic was a Non-Starter

    To the OP and Rounser I hope you can both find groups that will actually play-test the rules. Go ahead and pull something if it is offensive but please play the other 99% and give feedback as to what you have experienced. At this point I hope anyone bothering to post online about issues is...
  16. MacMathan

    How Much Houseruling Are You Willing To Do?

    I am in the none to very little camp since I have limited time and want that sort of thing sorted for me by the people I am buying it from. What I really want to see is what the 'official" houserules/modules are that they use for Encounters and such since this is where a lot of new people get...
  17. MacMathan

    How do you feel about Dex in the first playtest?

    Compared to 4e I suppose not but I don't remember the combat dominance in 1e/2e, then again I am oooooolllld :)
  18. MacMathan

    How do you feel about Dex in the first playtest?

    IMO it feels like Dex has become even more of an uber stat compared to the others. It can give you ac, init, melee, and ranged attacks not to mention influence many exploration based skills. Compared to Str and Con it currently seems too heavily dominant in the combat pillar. Also I would say...
  19. MacMathan

    [L&L] Balancing the Wizards in D&D

    So you went easy on the PCs and did not play the wizard up to his Int score? Anyone can do that with any monster as a DM and give players an easy win. I thought you were a Combat as War guy also? That wizard sure did not act like it. To suffice random anecdote is random meanwhile across...
  20. MacMathan

    Just Two... More... Days!

    Me too I would love a sub forum for testers so I can still come here but otherwise I need to leave for at least a week to give everything a fair shake
Top