Search results

Yes and while facing the direction of that particular LOS, they cant be facing the opposite direction, thus there is no LOS "behind" them. At least for creatures with eye(s) on one side of their head.

So anything not specifically in the rules is not in the game? Ridiculous. Just because there are no facing rules doesn't mean facing is not in the game.

Then how when hidden, can you decern if an enemy you can see is able to see you?

So how it it to be determined? Line of site, that is what direction a creature is facing. There is no 360 degree of sight. That is metagaming, and fast tracking. Otherwise anytime a gard is posted at a point the party needs to get buy without being noticed the game breaks. Still waiting on...

How in the wild wild world of sports are the rules supposed to know what direction and creature in the game is facing? To find out you would need line of sight to determine which would in most cases require whomever is in control of that creature to tell you. Unless the creature has...

First as it has been stated several times there are no rules name or called facing in the 24 books. Second the Hide action is a rule, and it is the most specific rule about facing. So unless a more specific rule about facing can be produced there you go. Where in the rules is the "A creature...

Posts 359 and 382 should get you there depending on the form your PHB is in. As to the direction the creature is facing only the player/Dm controlling it would know.

And not all of us have access to a physical copy. It is in the rules glossary in the hide action of the 24 PHB. The topic of discussion for the last severl pages.

I guess I will need the definition you are using for facing.

It has a link the the 24 phb on DDB, I don't own a physical copy. Feeding y'all is getting tedious.

Now that that is done back to the topic at hand.

Post 359

Also you're moving the goalposts from facing doesn't exist in the game to show me a specific rule about facing.

I showed you it is in the rules. Show where it syas it is not in the rules.

Are you kidding, "if you can see a creature, you can discern whether it can see you." Decern - Decide; determine; decree. If this isn't facing, what is. I would still like to see where the 24 rules say there is no facing.

HERE "With the Hide action, you try to conceal yourself. To do so, you must succeed on a DC 15 Dexterity (Stealth) check while you’re Heavily Obscured or behind Three-Quarters Cover or Total Cover, and you must be out of any enemy’s line of sight; if you can see a creature, you can discern...

Where does it say ther is no facing, this discussion on the hide action is about facing.

SMH, are we not discussing the rules? Just because you want to metagame it or speed through the RP doesn't mean they can see everything at once.

A sentry is actively looking for threats in all directions, they don't see all of those points at the same time, unless it is a trait or magic. How does flanking work if the NPC' don't use facing?

To the player this is true, for the character they have a line of sight. It gets metagamed alot.